Post 22: This is still awful 'HO HO HO you have activated my trap card' bullshit from UberNinja.
Post 37: And this is still
bullshit.
Post 38: DeltaWave's initial Haylen vote is bad as well. There's simply no explanation as to why the behaviour he attacks her for is in any way scum motivated.
Post 116: Townish post from PeregrineV. Scum would be a lot more likely to ask for elaboration on all townreads than picking out one in particular, I think. And in general, scum wouldn't particularly want attention drawn to towntells dropped by actual townies, which I at least know that 2/3 of the townreads in question are.
Post 117: Apparently not
that
likely, though. This post does not sit well with me. Prozac seems to be carefully tiptoeing around actually accusing Grey of anything here.
Post 142: So basically, Slaxx's progression onto the Haylen wagon, going from voting UberNinja to doing an about face and voting Haylen as soon as Grey points out the incredible cognitive dissonance of Haylen trying to convince Grey he can't read her while voting him, it's not hard for me to see a town mindset behind this sequence, since it very nearly mirrors my own progression of thoughts on the matter exactly.
Post 147: ...the difference being that I wasn't convinced until Slaxx laid it out in this post.
Post 162: This post is decidedly uncharacteristic of the guy who made posts like
74 and
77, and seems like posturing for towncred.
Post 175: First of all, why the hell do people say 'rereading' when they actually mean 'reading'? If you haven't read it yet, you can't reread it!
Secondly, MoS, have you still not read the first 7 pages of the game? Just wondering.
Post 252: This is a pretty awesome point, actually.
Post 293: ...And Prozac's response really isn't.
Post 317: Some ridiculous hairsplitting about the meaning of the word 'null' from UberNinja. And I'm pretty sure Murasa is not the only person to have mentioned null reads in this game, and yet Uber has never spouted this nonsense at anyone else. I have a hard time believing that he actually believes what he's saying here.
Post 421: Really want to know why Prozac is so high up on the town reads in DeltaWave's list. It just doesn't seem to fit with the rest.
Post 430/431: Seriously cannot see these posts coming from scum. If he's scum, Slaxx already knows whether Delta's omission of MoS from his list is a meaningful slip, he's not going to get into a debate with his team about its significance. If he wanted to write it off, he'd just say "I don't think it means anything", he wouldn't say "that's a good catch" then five minutes later "oh but my teammate disagrees because the names were obviously copy/pasted". Way too convoluted to be anything but genuine.
Also he seems to have noticed the same thing I did about the WTF placement of Prozac in DeltaWave's list.
Post 434: This post also makes it unlikely that Slaxx (or Grey, or Jason) would have killed Glork. I mean, there'd be two other scum who might have very good reasons to want Glork dead, I guess, but it still points to townSlaxx to a certain degree.
Post 476: "Regarding Haylen (whether she's scum OR town) I'd expect scum to take a conflicting stance and not either be in favor of, or opposed to, the wagon." - was there anyone doing this? I think everyone took a pretty explicit stance either for or against the wagon.
Post 498: I'd like further expansion on this from DeltaWave. Glork and Slaxx's conversation made it pretty damn explicit that they were talking about a Delta/MoS pairing, and I don't see how he could have misinterpreted that.
Post 561: "Murasa, you're defending Haylen like they're your own mother. Nobody can be that confident of a read at this point." - this seems to be wilfully blind to the number of other people who
were
that confident of eg. a scum read on Haylen.
Post 761: Good job we had people like Prozac doing everything in their power to prevent it, eh?
