The game of the year: town won!

[mykonian]

votecount

Spyrex (3): callforjudgement, uberninja, mattP
lowman (3): amrun, PeregrineV, Lowman
nobody special (3): theamatuer, Trevor, Kondi2424
amrun (2): BBmolla, spyrex
BBmolla (2): zajnet, syndromeofadown
PeregrineV (2): Hoopla, zoraster
kondi2424 (1): Zdenek
uberninja (1): nobody special
YYR (1): RedFF
chevre (1): thetrollie

[callforjudgement]

Bleh, who's on my list who shouldn't be?

Found it, it was Captain Corporal.

Vote Count

• LowMan (3)
  : Amrun PeregrineV LowMan
  
• Nobody Special (3)
  : theamatuer Trevor kondi2424
  
• SpyreX (3)
  : callforjudgement UberNinja MattP
  
• Amrun (2)
  : BBmolla SpyreX
  
• BBmolla (2)
  : Zajnet syndromeofadown
  
• PeregrineV (2)
  : Hoopla zoraster
  
• Chevre (1)
  : TheTrollie
  
• kondi2424 (1)
  : Zdenek
  
• UberNinja (1)
  : Nobody Special
  
• YYR (1)
  : redFF
  
• Not voting:
  Chevre Chronopie dramonic Ellibereth Elmo TeH AzN Fritzler funkybike1 Kairyuu manho Mastermind of Sin Milk petapan Rhinox Robotnick2 SleepyKrew Staeg sykedoc TeChNoWC YYR

With 38 alive it is 10 to lynch.

[Zajnet]

VOTE: spyrex

if he flips town, kondi's next.

[TeChNoWC]

Sounds like we are on the same wavelength, and having the same reservations in terms of mislynches and the vastly easy way for them to occur.

I think, given that criteria + the fact that Spyrex has a hefty bag of scumtells that he may be the next best bet for a lynch, but I don't want to rush another wagon just yet.

Lol lets just kill spyrex he is so fuckin scummy kondi has been more town lately.

Also his town read on t bone read that he already knew his alignment.

VOTE: spyrex

Yes I'm indecisive what of it? I'm sticking with this vote until spyrex is lynched though

Way to miss the point, MattP.

Yep. Aaand now I am back to worrying that lynching Spyrex would be hitting town because another keen wagoner jumps at the chance for a lynch. It just seems that every person I consider scummy and scrutinize manages to get a wagon of eager beavers. Heck, even the eager lynchers get wagons on them by eager lynchers for being eager lynchers. It just doesn't stop.

No idea where to start now. Need to do yet again (sigh) more reading.

[Nobody Special]

I will not be voting for SpyreX.

[Zajnet]

I will not be voting for SpyreX.

Would you rather lynch kondi first? One of them is probably scum...

[TeChNoWC]

Doesn't look like I have much say in the matter anyway.

Wagoners and quick lynchers must love this game. 10 votes out of 38, just over a quarter. And the rest sit by and watch the mayhem unfold.

[Nobody Special]

Yes, I'm pretty sure kondi is scum.

Vote: kondi

[callforjudgement]

OK, so my problem with this game: there are

way

too many people driving lynches on random people for no good reason. I'm starting to feel that it's currently impossible to lynch scum, because scum can easily put pressure elsewhere in order to save a buddy. As such, I'd be particularly suspicious of players who are on mislynches while actual scum are being wagoned, but we won't determine that until later when we have scumflips.

Meanwhile, we can look for players who are jumping on lynches unjustified; it's a much weaker scumtell without flips (although I won't mourn the in-game death of players like that even if they're town), but it probably has a better chance of hitting scum than anything else right now. (I imagine that there are some scum in crazy lynch mode trying to burn through townies quickly, and several more lurking to avoid early pressure; the lurkers are going to be near-impossible to catch until the player list shortens a bit, though.) I still feel good about my SpyreX vote, as a result.

One other thing I'm wondering about is the Lowman wagon; we have people vocally calling him town, and people equally vocally calling him scum. If he flips scum, I'd be very suspicious of anyone defending him. (Possibly even if he flips town, although it's a weaker scumtell in that case.) This isn't to say that voting him is a particularly townish thing to do either! It's just, I can't tell how the situation got that polarised on such little information, and am wondering why people are treating the situation like it's such a major apocalypse.

Sounds like we are on the same wavelength, and having the same reservations in terms of mislynches and the vastly easy way for them to occur.

I think, given that criteria + the fact that Spyrex has a hefty bag of scumtells that he may be the next best bet for a lynch, but I don't want to rush another wagon just yet.

Just as a sidenote: its 38 alive, not 39, since Luffy's mislynch. I was pondering over the numbers when I noticed it, because I have been thinking; with the mimes dead (seven from memory), how many scum do you think that leaves? and what are our odds of hitting town vs scum on a lynch? Is it possible that there are only a small minority of scum left, like five or six?

NS, do you have a post restriction?

[Nobody Special]

I do not. What makes you think I would?

[callforjudgement]

I do not. What makes you think I would?

I didn't, but in the last two games I've read where you were scum, you fakeclaimed a post restriction to explain why you were lurking. I wanted to make it harder for you to do that again if you were scum, while not affecting you at all if you were town.

[Nobody Special]

Oh, yeah, that. No, this game is just mindbendingly huge, and it took me a good while to really get into it. (Did you really read ALL of WiH3?)

[callforjudgement]

Oh, yeah, that. No, this game is just mindbendingly huge, and it took me a good while to really get into it. (Did you really read ALL of WiH3?) :eek:

Sure! Although not all in one go :)

[Nobody Special]

Masochist.

[Zajnet]

Yes, I'm pretty sure kondi is scum.

Vote: kondi

Ok.

UNVOTE: spyrex

VOTE: kondi

Same as last time, if kondi flips town, I'm voting spyrex.

[SpyreX]

If you lynch me, will you guys do me the favor of at least trying to get a group and forge through some of these lynches that need to happen?

[zoraster]

will you join me on Peregrine, SpyreX?

[kondi2424]

I can do this. Spy WILL be lynched tomorrow. VOTE: kondi

[UberNinja]

p-edit: @ kondi... uhhh wtf... no, he goes today. stop being stupid.

Spy's been obvious scum for a long time, but everyone's been too

lazy

afraid to do anything about it.

Agreed. It is time for a SpyreX lynch.

lowman is town.
NS is scummy, but he is always scummy, so idk.
amrun is town.
kondi is likely scum.
spyrex is strange, but he is the powerful wizard. i would rather sheep him than go against him.

No, kondi is town.

Did you really not read kondi's post about people not wanting to vote SpyreX? Because you just exemplified it.

but spyrex is voting amrun. i think she is town. so i really don't know what to do.

Hint: Vote Spyrex.

Wagoners and quick lynchers must love this game. 10 votes out of 38, just over a quarter. And the rest sit by and watch the mayhem unfold.

Too true. Damn this setup.

VOTE: spyrex

if he flips town, kondi's next.

Yes, I'm pretty sure kondi is scum.

Vote: kondi

Ok.

UNVOTE: spyrex

VOTE: kondi

Same as last time, if kondi flips town, I'm voting spyrex.

um excuse me, what is this?

get the fuck back on Spyrex kthx

HAMMER!

On to the next mislynch!

VOTE: petapan

OKay, so, there's not even been a flip, and you KNOW this is a mislynch, AND you're ready for the NEXT mislynch?

Then we have a the slip right above this post.

Vote: IceGuy

Why did you not pursue this lead?

SpyreX is on my scumlist now as well. I disliked his campaigning for policy lynchee rights in his opening post of the game, and the fact he is now steadfastly enforcing policy all over the place. Weird vibes.

Let's do it. Hop on, sister.

So many people have probably fallen behind. I'm going to shut up for a while and let others dictate terms for a while. My thoughts are known.

May I ask for your opinion now?

I'm fine with that hammer, even though Moneybags was town. So be it. He wasn't a bad lynch and I think the original impetus was town driven.

So who do you think the scum hops were?

My lynch list:

BBMolla
SpyreX
Peregrine (new addition)
Uberninja (new addition)Happy with my vote, but will swap over to SpyreX if others are interested.

Others are most definitely interested.

I'm starting to think that UberNinja is town.

I'm also thinking Trevor is an idiot.

Thank you.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: SpyreX

SpyreX has four votes. We're making progress.

Yep. Get your ass back on!

I know you're not a newbie, and I know you know that tell, but knowledge of a tell does not prevent one from committing it.

So, the insatiable urge to feign surprise as scum was so great that it eclipsed my knowledge of this tell.

I legitimately lol'd at this post. <3 Hoopla

[SpyreX]

Not with hoopla, Zor.

Here's the dealio: Lynch me with this lynch.

HOWEVER, before you do let me do the full VCA and give my opinions on the chunk of this game that opinions can be actually given on. I'll actually TRY to give a little bit on everyone but farrtttt.

More importantly, since it fell apart immediately which is why I'm fine dying, FORM A CONSENSUS AMONGST YOURSELF AND BURN THROUGH SOME LYNCHES FAST. This game size, low NK's and the fact we control the majority of kills means that there is absolutely no reason STILL for the rampant lurking and noiseposting. Apathy is going to eat this game if it doesn't become immediately clear that apathy = death.

I will fufill my part of the bargain tonight. I'll probably just use myko's VC's instead of the armada. Of course, I expect them to actually get fine tooth combed so that if there's mistakes they get caught.

[UberNinja]

Apathy is going to eat this game if it doesn't become immediately clear that apathy = death.

I will shamelessly sheep all of your reads if you flip town, based 100% on this part of your post.

You still need to die though, unfortunately. Otherwise I will never forgive myself if you're scum.

[Nobody Special]

HAMMER!

On to the next mislynch!

VOTE: petapan

OKay, so, there's not even been a flip, and you KNOW this is a mislynch, AND you're ready for the NEXT mislynch?

Then we have a the slip right above this post.

Vote: IceGuy

Why did you not pursue this lead?

The Careful Reader will note that I made two unrelated posts shortly after this one, then disappeared for a full 1,200 posts. By the time I got back, he was gone.


Also, SpyreX is so town it hurts. Please to not be lynching my Wizard Friend.

[theamatuer]

Get NS. He's buddying Spyrex for towncred

[Chronopie]

I have to point out, even though I myself am guilty of the apathy Spyre's trying to fight, he does have a point. Vocal town lynches vocal town, lurker scum wins.

So I wouldn't lynch him yet.

[Trevor]

Vote: Spyrex

Not on the top of my scumread list, but his actions have felt fake and I've called him out on this multiple times today.
Also lol @ kondi votes.