Worst Role Mafia - GAME OVER!

[saulres]

Thanks for running this, izak. That was a fun game with a lot of fun roles!

[callforjudgement]

@saulres: Ooh, neat, I genuinely didn't catch that one. (I'd probably have tried to explain it away as misreading the role PM, but I doubt anyone would have bought it.) There's another one.

[Oversoul]

To be honest there weren't enough Third Parties.

[mcqueen]

In retrospect, in order to make 100% sure about Phillamon, I should quickly have posted "not hammering", allowed Trevor to crossvote, then hammered Phillamon. (I was planning that in advance, but the quickhammer moment got to me.)

PEDIT: @saulres: The slip wasn't wrt my vote; I correctly obeyed the role exactly as written, although it had several loopholes. (I was genuinely offline between MN voting for me and the day ending, that wasn't any sort of gambit or deliberate lurk.)

izakthegoomba said "who said hammering couldn't trigger the goo," so it's possible your vote would have been voided, then both Trevor and Phillammon would know you were scum.

[Phillammon]

Very, very fun game. But not enough 3ps, yeah. Certainly not enough to get these guys off my case...

PEdit: I was told voting wouldn't trigger. I did consider whether hammering would, briefly...

[callforjudgement]

Haha, shadowgirl's role made people

flip

survivor rather than actually

be

survivor? What a brilliant troll, izak; force the living players to agonize over the moral issues when actually there aren't any.

Was shadowgirl's role deliberately included as bait for dana? Or was that just an unfortunate coincidence?

[callforjudgement]

Oh, and if hammering Phillamon had triggered it, hammering

me

would trigger it too after that, and it'd be impossible for anyone to win.

[Trevor]

Hey izak can I have gimmicky alt?

[Gimmicky Alt]

Hey hey hey why did I get shotgunned

[mcqueen]

Hey izak can I have gimmicky alt?

lawl?

[saulres]

Question for those who were alive when I had to claim, and didn't know Panda was also a werewolf: Did I succeed in convincing any of you that it was just Amrun and me?

And did anyone see a way for me to get

out

of claiming with that post restriction on me, which wouldn't have gotten me lynched by avoiding saying "I am town"?

[Tierce]

Oh, and it's definitely worth reading my mason QT with RedPanda too; if you skip it, you're missing half the game. (Without it, I don't think I'd have caught RedPanda + saulres as 2/3 of the wolf team; it was one of my scumbuddies who worked out Amrun was the third, I forget who.)

PEDIT: Sorry, Tierce. Fated to always be on opposite teams for life, are we?

One day. One day we'll both be town.
Hope springs eternal.


People were amused we hadn't thought RedPanda and CFJ were both scum, but they missed something: during D1, there was no way for town to suspect there were two scumteams. The moment izak revealed a certain mafia QT post in the dead QT, I got the mafia/wolf pairing.

I definitely don't like bastard games, it makes my work feel pointless.
When games are not carefully balanced (and yes, I know this is WRM and that I accepted my recruitment into the game), it gets really frustrating to play. This was far more exhausting for me than it should be when obvobvtowning from post #1. Nothing against izak, I just think that the whole concept of Worst Roles (obviously) punishes traditional mafia play. I didn't particularly enjoy the experience.

[Oversoul]

I didn't enjoy my role either.

Especially since it didn't have super bastard powers.

[mcqueen]

Oh, and it's definitely worth reading my mason QT with RedPanda too; if you skip it, you're missing half the game. (Without it, I don't think I'd have caught RedPanda + saulres as 2/3 of the wolf team; it was one of my scumbuddies who worked out Amrun was the third, I forget who.)

PEDIT: Sorry, Tierce. Fated to always be on opposite teams for life, are we?

One day. One day we'll both be town.
Hope springs eternal.


People were amused we hadn't thought RedPanda and CFJ were both scum, but they missed something: during D1, there was no way for town to suspect there were two scumteams. The moment izak revealed a certain mafia QT post in the dead QT, I got the mafia/wolf pairing.

I definitely don't like bastard games, it makes my work feel pointless.
When games are not carefully balanced (and yes, I know this is WRM and that I accepted my recruitment into the game), it gets really frustrating to play. This was far more exhausting for me than it should be when obvobvtowning from post #1. Nothing against izak, I just think that the whole concept of Worst Roles (obviously) punishes traditional mafia play.

I didn't particularly enjoy the experience.

Because of me.

[Tierce]

Also I definitely rock at getting writing styles from anon sources. I nailed the Gimmicky Alt ownership (just as I had guessed theamatuer's anon neighborizing in Paranoia Mafia); I also realized who made a certain mafia QT post.


PEdit: Contrary to what you might think, my world doesn't revolve around people in my blacklist, mcqueen.

[Phillammon]

My role kinda sucked due to my "be very open" policy and a bad name. I should have stuck to calling myself ditto, that would have made things easier...

[YYR]

I posted more in the dead QT than in the actual thread.

[saulres]

Roles suck because they're Worst Roles. I hated not knowing what my button did and being paranoid about pushing it. Fortunately I was scum to fall back on something interesting for me, that role would have really really sucked as town. But that's what we signed up for (except Tierce) -- bad roles.

[mcqueen]

PEdit: Contrary to what you might think, my world doesn't revolve around people in my blacklist, mcqueen.

Yes, but still partly because of me.

It's ok, now is where you pay me back for all I've done to you. I've already used my vig shot, so I'm pretty much unarmed.

[Gimmicky Alt]

Imagine how much fun I could have had with this.

[mcqueen]

PEdit: Contrary to what you might think, my world doesn't revolve around people in my blacklist, mcqueen.

Yes, but still partly because of me.

It's ok, now is where you pay me back for all I've done to you. I've already used my vig shot, so I'm pretty much unarmed.

= It's my fault we lost.

[Oversoul]

I think what makes me feel worst about this game was the fact that I was town with a fairly good ability too.

If I had been some super weird ass third party or neutral traitor that got recruited if shot at, that would have been fine

but the way I played

hurt the wincon I didn't know I had

I thought it would be cool kinda like that Quagmire lol I didn't read my role PM thing everyone has been talking about lately, but it wasn't that cool.

I thank you for running the game, Izak, it certainly was an endeavor and a lot of the roles in here were pretty cool (Phil's role, Shadow's role, Dana's role, BB's role) and the fact that it ended in 3p lylo is also pretty cool

But I don't think I am going to participate in the next one

[callforjudgement]

Question for those who were alive when I had to claim, and didn't know Panda was also a werewolf: Did I succeed in convincing any of you that it was just Amrun and me?

And did anyone see a way for me to get

out

of claiming with that post restriction on me, which wouldn't have gotten me lynched by avoiding saying "I am town"?

I was trying to convince RedPanda that you were lying about having no remaining scumbuddies in the mason QT, just to confirm that he and you were scumbuddies. (His reaction was hilarious, he was trying harder and harder to convince me that you were telling the truth but that he planned to double-cross you anyway.)

[ShadowGirl]

Good game to scum; I think town got too wrapped up in roles/personalities in this game and that second guessing some roles ended up coming down to the wire, although it seemed like town was going go to be out for the count way sooner. I personally was very happy with my role which wasn't as annoying/bastardish as many others so I certainly enjoyed the game overall, and I wish I could have been alive much longer than I was. (:

[YYR]

Can we get links to the different QT?