NY 151: Playground Mafia (Game Over-Mafia Win!)

[andrew94]

I have thought about it and decided to claim.

I claim the shot on lady and i am the vig.

anyone dare to counter?

now that thats done,

we're lynching

ohgodmylife or Hezlucky (most likely SK)
or ill shoot them. same thing

dlg get off the benmage wagon and vote the above.
tml vote one of them.

[andrew94]

edit:

scooby didnt do anything night 1 and 2

[Psyche]

Could be SK. No clear reason why he claimed.

[Psyche]

So...why Lady, then? Where'd the insight that she was scum come from?

[andrew94]

i read the thread during the night. it was gut.

and why would i claim as a SK, thats just dumb.

[Code_X]

Thoughts

I think there is still strong evidence that Benmage is town, despite the "lynch me."
Looking at LLD's posts I'm seeing her connected to TML, redFF, Hez, and FG.
It looks like one scumteam from the reveal, safest to assume 6 to begin with, 5 left
...which means the fifth is probably one of the myriad contentless lurkers coasting through this game
14 alive, (up to) three kills again tonight, there is a remote possibility this is mylo

Vote: The Mini-Librarian
Your cop claim stunt was what made me think LLD was town.
Nice trick, scum.

This post is fucking horrible.

Reading LLD at the minute.

[andrew94]

when ur done vote ohgod thanks

[Code_X]

rack

- Obvious is obvious.
Macros- Who? Get to posting or get to dying.

Pine

- As explained above, he's not scumhunting he's nitpicking.

Nero Cain

- Dodging questions in early game, just being a general shady character.

Candy Corn Vampire

- Her KK vote and "case"(a term I use loosely), combined with the rest of her posting being absolute fluff.

mastin2

- Bad reads, worse explinations.

Junpei

- Again, post or die.

vijay2vasandani

- Something is bothering me about your posting. Call it GUT for now.
Praetyre- Post or Die (or be replaced FFS).

I find it quite amazing that all these are dead and all of them town.
Macros is now DLG who TML has found innocent.

Praetyre is now SC.

I sense as a result LLD will have defending her scum buddies more than attacked them? Thoughts?

On a meta level does LLD bus her scum partners? I have no experience of playing with her.

[Code_X]

Ok. What I've analysed looking at LLD.

That previous suspicion list strikes me as she plays scum to not bus heavily - mainly because all her scum reads are dead townies.


Defends OMG/FS

There's a Firestarter wagon? I know a few people were displeased with his opening post, but I didn't see a lot wrong with it. It was a little weak but not scummy IMO.

Her response to Mastin 448 is interesting.

8 voters, 2 former-voters, 3 interested players, 13 to lynch.
Rack's been pseudolynched already, even without the above players' opinions. Look at the names involved.

[Benmage, The Mini-Librarian,

drmyshotgun

, Firestarter,

Kublai Khan,

Pine

, Lady Lambdadelta,

Candy Corn Vampire

], {NihilisticNinja, Psyche}, (

mastin2

, Maxous, DV).
[Voting]{Voted}(Interested).

Tell me, LLD, does this look like a town-driven wagon to you?

Um, with the exception of Pine and maybe CCV and Firestarter, I believe most players on this wagon to be town.

Ninja is town. Psyche is null-town for me right now.

So I mean, it looks pretty town to me.

Now I'm town and Maxous is town if we believe the cop innocent - and TML is town if we believe his claim. Which I have no reason to dispute. So she's probably bang on it is a town wagon.

Firestarter, Pine and Psyche banded in the exception list.

----------------------------------------------------------

Her interaction with AH is interesting.

Agrees with Anti-Hero's reads and he ends up dead that night. Which I see as a scum kill - more so than Vijay.

He suspected.

Updated Reads

Town:

vijay2whatthehellisthisusername

,

Nero

, Benmage, Lady, HezLucky, scooby, red, mastin, psyche,

khan

, shotty 2, NihilisticNinja, The Mini-Librarian, DeasVail
Scum: firestarter, jason, drmyshottyizsik
Null:

rack

, Maxous, Macros,

Junpei

, Praetyre,

pine

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Firestarter

Now, I agree with a lot of your town reads.

But you're going to have to sell me on your scum reads. I have a dead read on Jason, I think. His very first content post this game looked really town to me.

But right now, I have town reads on Jason and Shotty, a fairly null read on Maxous and a null read on Firestarter. .

So Jason/Fakegod - Shotty/Maxwell (probably town based on day 3), Maxous (she has said very little about - will re-read him), Firestarter/OGML again.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------


Sticks up for RedFF slightly. She does similar in a way in 1373

Next, he starts to do SOMETHING when he makes a comment about RedFF's logic/saying he is buddying or something stupid like that. On the whole, the two posts it took to say these things were unnecessary and just bad.

Then he gets into a discussion with Librarian, with a vote for RedFF in the middle. You have legitimately said one thing about RedFF this entire game, and your vote on him didn't project any further insight. I am forced to assume you were making this vote with almost no reasoning.

Casts a bit of suspicion at Firestarter but no elaboration.

@Nero: I found Firestarter to be scummier than I expected on a reread, mainly his first post.

--------------------------------------------------------------


Comes out and votes Shottyiszik/Maxwell in 1494. Back to

Junpei

town in 1586

Then pretty much spends the next 10/20 posts ranting about Junpei and Nero.

I could get behind a Psyche lynch the below really looks like scum encouraging scum.

Just don't get discouraged, Kay~? ^_^

Pretty sure Maxwell isn't scum. She's driven lynches/voted townies. The initial scum read tells me she doesn't bus scum particularly.

Hez is town.

I really haven't seen much in FakeGod, so I'd like to know why he's scum.

Maxwell is scum.

LLD - said nothing about OGML - interaction with Firestarter is more interesting though.




------------------------------------------------------------------------


UNVOTE: Benmage

VOTE: OhGodMyLife


----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Going through the list.

Psyche. Red. FakeGod. Maxous - come off as likely scum partners. I'd say OGML is scum and at least two of these.

HezLucky - who there was no real interaction with. SC - mainly because of her first list.

Benmage - christ! If I was selecting someone as SK. Could be him. I need to re-read him. I don't though think he's the right play today.

We are lynching from the top though and yeah OGML is my preferred choice for today.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Anyone else fancy chiming in on AntiHero's reads?

Also the fact Red made out he thought AH was a vig kill makes me think he knew it was a scum kill. He is very likely scum.

[Code_X]

Maxwell's reads bottom of Page 98 are fucking terrible also.

[Code_X]

Red, Psyche and Fakegod - check out there posts today.

[Code_X]

Actually when LLD went after Maxwell there was never any danger he was being lynched. She can't have gone through the whole game not bussing/casting suspicion at her partners.

Fact he's voted for Andrew and then said he may switch to two of my very likely scum reads as though he could be scum. He's in the scum pile.

[Code_X]

493

This alone is what the town needs to follow.

AH was killed for these reads.

Time to look through KK.

[Code_X]

You know Nero speaks a lot of sense.

Reading start of Day 2 around Page 40 is useful.

Vig should take down Psyche. He's scum.

[DeasVail]

Thoughts on Recent Posts

I feel that Psyche's lack of involvement is a nulltell. Overall, I have a very weak townread on him, although I will try to have a limited reread of the game in light of LLD's flip.

Hez's 2402 is not very good in my opinion. It's basically *Benmage said he wanted to lynch LLD the next day, but he didn't know that she would die, and now that she's dead and flipped scum he's obviously scum because he was obviously planning to bus her!*

Hmmm...

Also the point about knowing Junpei-slot was town is bad too. Scum, if anything, would try to avoid predicting a townflip from an upcoming town lynch.

OGML's 2411 is ok, but I don't understand why he no longer considers TML cop.

I'm not liking Hez's posting.

Psyche's 2436 has no purpose except to look town.

In response to OGML, I think that what TML did was good. He made himself a bit too obvious with the LLD innocent thing I think, but he should definitely have lied when pushed on it. I don't understand why you think differently.

Also, about RedFF, I always have trouble reading him and decided to have a good think about him. I've decided he's probably town because he tends to try and be slightly more consistently involved as scum rather than going for periods without posting anything (as far as I recall) and I don't really think he's scummy.

[DeasVail]

I was going to start formulating updated reads on players, but now I can't. I will do later.

[Code_X]

Deas - do you believe Andrew's claim?

[Psyche]

I do not post to look town.

[Code_X]

Not your posting that bothers me as much as LLD's.

Though you could at least try and be useful.

[maxwell]

Pretty sure I'm voting the SK right now. Just saying.

[Maxous]

-___-

[maxwell]

What's that supposed to mean?

[Maxous]

okay that might of been patronizing >.>

anyway a sk would be foolish to claim like that.
if Andrew is the sk the vig better counter claim.

[Code_X]

No he shouldn't.

He should shoot him duh.

[Maxous]

prolly nk immune.