NY 151: Playground Mafia (Game Over-Mafia Win!)

[Maxous]

as in the sk.
particularly if all claimed roles are true

[Code_X]

Whatever.

If Andrew isn't the vig - the real shouldn't claim. Hence why Andrew's claim itself was odd. Why ask if anyone was going to counter-claim.

The real vig will just shoot him.

[maxwell]

That's my point - serial killers are usually NK immune, he's claiming a shot for last night but none of the other nights. I know he replaced scooby, is he going to claim scooby just didn't shoot on either night prior? Do I need to spell this out any more? The claim stinks in a big way and I'm completely willing to take the fall on this if he's town. If you guys want to play direct the SK you can try that but I don't think that sort of strategy works well, ever, especially not at this stage in the game.

[StrangerCoug]

If I am dense in the first place, then you can help me find my way in a universe in which lynching town reads is ever a good idea.

That was my question in the first place

..

Hence why I answered it first.

I'll spell it out for you: P.R.O.G.R.E.S.S.I.O.N.

Elaborate on how this "progression" works. I still don't see it.

I don't think there has ever been a game where I haven't voted someone I thought was going to flip town. BECAUSE NEWS FLASH I CAN BE WRONG.

So can the rest of us despite us thinking that the person we're voting is scum. This is no excuse.

If I was powerbusing it wouldb't be my GF with an innocent on, nor someone as strong as LLD.

WIFOM.

we're lynching

ohgodmylife or Hezlucky (most likely SK)
or ill shoot them. same thing

Reasons?

[HezLucky]

That's my point - serial killers are usually NK immune, he's claiming a shot for last night but none of the other nights. I know he replaced scooby, is he going to claim scooby just didn't shoot on either night prior? Do I need to spell this out any more? The claim stinks in a big way and I'm completely willing to take the fall on this if he's town. If you guys want to play direct the SK you can try that but I don't think that sort of strategy works well, ever, especially not at this stage in the game.

This is straightforward then. If Andrew is not the vig, the vig can shoot him, and if Andrew turns out NK immune the vig can out tomorrow and its instalynch.

[DeasVail]

Deas - do you believe Andrew's claim?

Yes, and I haven't read through properly, but maxwell saying that he's more likely SK than Vig because scooby didn't shoot makes no sense.

[Code_X]

Anyone?

I sense as a result LLD will have defending her scum buddies more than attacked them? Thoughts?

[DeasVail]

I don't think there's much indication either way.

[Code_X]

You think 2457 is irrelevant yeah?

[DeasVail]

Pretty much. If anything it's more likely she started attacking a buddy or two than just attacking town, but I haven't had the chance to have a good look back at her play yet, so I don't know.

[Code_X]

Pretty much all of them are dead town.

So that rather makes that argument flawed.

[DeasVail]

That was one post very early in the game. Did she attack anyone different later?

[Code_X]

You best read her Iso and then draw your own conclusions. I've laid out my opinion on the previous page.

How do you feel about OGML now considering you were all over him yesterday?

[DeasVail]

I still think he could be scum, but his reads on Benmage and Hez are good, so I'm really waiting until I can have a proper read-through before making up my mind on him.

[FakeGod]

That's my point - serial killers are usually NK immune, he's claiming a shot for last night but none of the other nights. I know he replaced scooby, is he going to claim scooby just didn't shoot on either night prior? Do I need to spell this out any more? The claim stinks in a big way and I'm completely willing to take the fall on this if he's town. If you guys want to play direct the SK you can try that but I don't think that sort of strategy works well, ever, especially not at this stage in the game.

This is straightforward then. If Andrew is not the vig, the vig can shoot him, and if Andrew turns out NK immune the vig can out tomorrow and its instalynch.

I am not sure whether andrew is indeed the vig, but I agree that we should give the vig, if there is one and andrew's lying, a chance to shoot andrew.

[Benmage]

not sure what to make of benmage at this point, the post people are voting him for is bad but comes across as somewhat more condescending and sarcastic than I think people are reading it. His defense also looks bad to me but the stangercoug/code_x/fakegod votes on his wagon give me pause.

Dont like much of this post... but this part especially.

-Calls out the reasoning to vote me.
-And all my defense...

Hows it both?

[DeasVail]

I think I may delay going back through the game, as I'm pretty sure maxwell is scum.

Vote: Maxwell

Might get a case of sorts up later.

[andrew94]

no sir vote ohgodmylife.

or hezzlucky.

[DeasVail]

By the way, this is where I'm at right now. And I have skimmed through a couple of these ISOs to check that I still think they're town.

Town

Andrew94

TML

DLG

Code_X

Benmage

RedFF

Maxous

StrangerCoug

Some of these are strong, some of them weak, but I'm pretty sure most of the people in the list above are town, and with me that makes 9 out of the 14 players alive.

[DeasVail]

By the way, this is where I'm at right now. And I have skimmed through a couple of these ISOs to check that I still think they're town.

Town

Andrew94

TML

DLG

Code_X

Benmage

RedFF

Maxous

StrangerCoug

Some of these are strong, some of them weak, but I'm pretty sure most of the people in the list above are town, and with me that makes 9 out of the 14 players alive.

[DeasVail]

Ugh, sorry about double post.

no sir vote ohgodmylife.

or hezzlucky.

I honestly wouldn't mind either, but what's wrong with maxwell?

[andrew94]

ohgod and hezz are way more scummy than maxwell.

lynch one of them so i can shoot the other to prove my role.

[DeasVail]

ok

Vote: OGML

[andrew94]

ok everyone sheep us.

p.s. protective roles on me plx

[Code_X]

Dream on.