Mini 1344: Murder on the HMS Regalia - Game Over

[Espeonage]

iso 0 second line.

Basically it means that most of that content will be based entirely on assuming you are town, therefore that post can't be used to point him as either town or scum, so basically it should be acknowledged but not analyzed.

[NabakovNabakov]

To clarify: I read the thread before my substitution was confirmed, but I did not start writing my first post until afterwards.

@Shotgun: Some play draws votes because it's disappointing, unusual, or frustrating. Your play drew my vote because it's indistinguishable from good scum play.

[drmyshotgun]

I'm sorry that I attracted a vote from you.

[Espeonage]

To clarify: I read the thread before my substitution was confirmed, but I did not start writing my first post until afterwards.

@Shotgun: Some play draws votes because it's disappointing, unusual, or frustrating. Your play drew my vote because it's indistinguishable from good scum play.

Still counts. As someone that used to do a fair bit of replacing. Taking your reads from before getting your role is much better than any other way of approach.

[sword_of_omens]

@phil umm..were you serious about your read on BK?
His posts seem pretty lazy to me...

And although Peregrine was pretty null for me, cant say I care for Psyche's play so far...
@Psyche, have you caught up yet, or do you plan on catching up?

[Psyche]

Getting there, sorry.

[Espeonage]

I lol'd

[RichardGHP]

Eleventh Vote Count of Day 1

Lynch:

[1] Espeonage - [D3f3nd3r]
[3] Malakittens - [BK201, guille2015, Espeonage]
[5] D3f3nd3r - [image, TheTrollie, Malakittens, Ser Arthur Dayne, drmyshotgun]
[1] drmyshotgun - [NabakovNabakov]

[3] Not Voting - [Phillammon, Psyche, sword_of_omens]

Quarantine:

[3] Espeonage - [drmyshotgun, Malakittens, TheTrollie]
[2] sword_of_omens - [Ser Arthur Dayne, Espeonage]
[2] Ser Arthur Dayne - [guille2015, BK201]

[6] Not Voting - [NabakovNabakov, sword_of_omens, image, D3f3nd3r, Phillammon, Psyche]

V/LA: drmyshotgun, until June 20
image, until June 22
sword_of_omens, until June 21
Malakittens, until Friday

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch and 7 to quarantine.
Deadline for this day is June 23, 1630h UTC+12. You have two days, seventeen hours.

[Phillammon]

I was serious about all I said. As I said, not too good at this...

@Mod: Is there a plurality ruling on Quarantine if there is a lynch before an agreed quarantine?

[guille2015]

Less than 3 days to deadline. Lets get this show going.

My opinion on quarantine, is to quarantine the second most suspicious player. Considering that the first would get Lynched.

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

My opinion on quarantine, is to quarantine the second most suspicious player. Considering that the first would get Lynched.

No. We aren't doing that. We are quarantining the best town read. Which just happens to be Sword of omens. So if you would please switch to him, that would help. Kthx.

[guille2015]

Correction, you are not doing that, and a small handful of players. My problem with that is that we do not know if Sword is a PR. And if he is a good player, he will not say whether he is or not. Besides, something Nab said that I did not consider before, is that the Role of the VT is to pull the Kills away from the PRs. It is dumb to jail the best town read.

I am fine with jailing Espeonage/Mala or Ser Arthur.

[BK201]

Less than 3 days to deadline. Lets get this show going.

My opinion on quarantine, is to quarantine the second most suspicious player. Considering that the first would get Lynched.

Want to move your quarantine to Esp with me?

[BK201]

I say we lynch Mala and jail Ser Arthur D. But I'm fine with jailing Espe instead.

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Want to move your quarantine to Esp with me?

Okay. Let me put it this way. If we quarantine Esp, it will be very, very bad.

[Psyche]

So much theoretical talk earlygame that meaningful reads are sparse...

[drmyshotgun]

Want to move your quarantine to Esp with me?

Okay. Let me put it this way. If we quarantine Esp, it will be very, very bad.

Not sure... Why?

[TheTrollie]

y would it be bad. he is either scum (so let's quarantine him so he can't use any potential powers and so someone else has to do the kill who may be tracked or whatever) or he is not scum in which case we should trust his VT claim and thus should quarantine him

[RichardGHP]

@Mod: Is there a plurality ruling on Quarantine if there is a lynch before an agreed quarantine?

No.

[sword_of_omens]

@phil, please explain in detail your BK read for me...what questions did you want answered and what good discussion?


@guille

Besides, something Nab said that I did not consider before, is that the Role of the VT is to pull the kills away from the PRs. It is dumb to jail the best town read.

So what you're saying is you didnt bother to read my post #211 about VT's then?
I'm on my phone so I can't properly quote it, but it's there in the first paragraph...

[Phillammon]

Let's lock this guy up tonight.

Unquarintine:
Quarintine: Ser Arthur D

Question in point: Why?

Remind me of this post after the first scumflip.

Considering you're a good candidate to be the first flip, I'd like it if you didn't wait for a flip as if that has anything to do with the read I am asking for. You didn't specify a specific player flipping so how could it?

Question in point: Also why?

You have a point, actually. There's not really that much content behind BK, and what there is seems to need more backup. Could I switch thatto slightly leaning scum?

[BK201]

@Phill, b/c guille's #297 is good. I'm basically sheeping it. Also, I'm for jailing the 2nd scummiest.

How can you ask why to the second part?

[Psyche]

This is the most terribly bland D1 I have ever laid my eyes on. It's a miracle that I got through it.

But there are definitely some angles to investigate, so I'll do that. Tomorrow.

Sorry for my slow entrance. Once I'm in, though, you see consistent contribution. Promise.

[Phillammon]

The why is "What have you got on Espe?"

[BK201]

-Espe claims VT on page 1 or 2.
As a goon doing it, it kind of gives an excuse to not be the NK.
As town doing it, it makes it easier to kill PRs, which is anti-town. First game with Espe but he seems to smart to be anti-town like that.

Plus he is being a magician with his reads.