Open 391 - Theft on Cookie Island - Town Wins

[projectmatt]

I'm a little bit confused as to why it can be Chimi because it seems like he's sort of towntelling. Dumb question, but is there ANY chance that the innocent could be ruined by a godfather or something?

[FuDuzn]

This is an Open game, no Godfather mentioned in the setup so I would safely assume there is no Godfather.

And it could only be you or Chrimi, even if we mislynch toDay the other is dead Tomorrow.

[projectmatt]

yeah w/e

what i was trying DID have the desired effect on rainbowdash - it made her vote for Sando, I was hoping that the other players would think that me/Chimi couldn't be partners either

Too bad Thomith got quickhammered

Whatever, sorry dudes.

vote: projectmatt

[FuDuzn]

Well played Matt, I was really hoping it was Chrimi.
UNVOTE:
projectmatt

[FuDuzn]

Bah, I is dumb.
VOTE: projectmatt

[Rainbowdash]

yeah w/e

what i was trying DID have the desired effect on rainbowdash - it made her vote for Sando, I was hoping that the other players would think that me/Chimi couldn't be partners either

Too bad Thomith got quickhammered

Whatever, sorry dudes.

vote: projectmatt

Well it was a smart move, but I was almost for sure voting you over Chrimi when comparing to a Thomith partner. You just got unfortunate Chrimi hammered (right move with his read) before I could do all that much.

Killing Hikari though was a big mistake though since it couldnt have been him as a cop which you needed to get rid of ASAP.

GNR shouldnt have power lurked, I was sure he was scum but trying to figure out how to get him lynched, Thomith doing the COP thing gave me what I needed to do that then everything just blew up in my face with the OOTN move.

Im happy my FD read was right though. Can at least take that away

Vote PM

[AcRv]

... Well this is easy
VOTE: projectmatt

[Rainbowdash]

... Well this is easy
VOTE: projectmatt

Well... it WAS a forced win after the Thomith lynch. This just made it faster even though we were lynching PM over Chrimi today either way.

[AcRv]

Yeah, I was going to say that with the hammer vote no matter when it happened. I couldn't think of any better smart arse comments. I don't blame PM for claiming, seeing as our win was guaranteed, as we all know.

[Chrimi]

Then we simply VOTE: PM

[Chrimi]

Good job PM, you weren't on my suspects list until near the end there

Thanks for the game guys, it was fun. *superhighfive*

Good job town *thumbs up*

[FuDuzn]

This was like a tale of three games for me. I subbed in and was gung ho, then I made the mistake of trying to play in a whole bunch of games at once and I become lost in this game(and it showed), then my passion for this game was re-lit and I was starting to enjoy it again. The only thing I was sure of the whole time was that Thomith was scum, so at least I can hang my hat on that.

Good game guys.

[Quaroath]

Vote count 5.01

Projectmatt - (Everyone)

Projectmatt has been lynched

The hanging tree it calls to thee
A noose it tied with you and me
Swing low under my limb dear sir
To dangle from yonder eldest fir

In last words the condemned does say,
"I do not forsake my love of whey,
You protein fools, all are dastards thee,
From your worship of cookies I tried to free,

Alas my work, it has been undone,"
With that, the thieving bastard swung
Projectmatt, he is a man, no rookie
The last man... of the thieves cookie!

Projectmatt - Mafia Goon - has been lynched!

Town wins!

Have a lot of thoughts about the game, but I don't have the time to get into it right now. I really enjoyed the game but the setup start mechanic is a nightmare for the mod. One person not picking up a role pm can cause major issues with the game, as this first play through showed.

I'll post more when I haven't been awake 28 hours

[Quaroath]

Vote count 5.01

Projectmatt - (Everyone)

Projectmatt has been lynched

The hanging tree it calls to thee
A noose it tied with you and me
Swing low under my limb dear sir
To dangle from yonder eldest fir

In last words the condemned does say,
"I do not forsake my love of whey,
You protein fools, all are dastards thee,
From your worship of cookies I tried to free,

Alas my work, it has been undone,"
With that, the thieving bastard swung
Projectmatt, he is a man, no rookie
The last man... of the thieves cookie!

Projectmatt - Mafia Goon - has been lynched!

Town wins!

Have a lot of thoughts about the game, but I don't have the time to get into it right now. I really enjoyed the game but the setup start mechanic is a nightmare for the mod. One person not picking up a role pm can cause major issues with the game, as this first play through showed.

I'll post more when I haven't been awake 28 hours

[Om of the Nom]

Yay.

[Chrimi]

Quaroath, you double posted

We win!

[Rainbowdash]

Things I want to know

1) How is this setup balanced? Its at best mildly town sided.
2) Why would scum ever recruit? It turns a somewhat difficult win into a very difficult win.
3) Why did Hikari die at all with the hypo result?
4) Why did OOTN NOT die night one?

I really dont think this setup is balanced though, its so town sided its not even funny. The first setup basically is a win for town if they lynch scum in the first day, probably even second day with JK alive. Second setup is just brutal beyond reason for scum to deal with, recruiting was scum mistake number one.

[Amrun]

Thanks for killing me night one!

[Sando]

RD was 100% right, no lynch was the correct option. That didn't make it the best option, so I figured I'd have a crack at getting an easy win for town. My problem was that RD basically forced scum to pull the only trick they had (bus their partner in suicide position), then basically fell for it. I watched the quick hammer happen and was just sitting there praying it happened. Ballsy move there PM, I know you basically had to do it, but wow, nearly pulled that one off. Whether you'd have won the game I dunno, but props for the ballsy move.

I was massively confused day 2, I had no idea what anyone was talking about with the cop came. Then Day 3 comes and I claim, and I'm told by RD that I'm not actually the cop... whaaaaat? Oddest claims and reactions I've seen.

[Chrimi]

Haha sando, I was confused the whole game, I didn't listen to all your ramblings, just pushed for the scum ^.^

[Chrimi]

Haha sando, I was confused the whole game, I didn't listen to all your ramblings, just pushed for the scum ^.^

"All your ramblings" referring to EVERYONE, not you sando >.<

[Guy_Named_Riggs]

yeah...lurking didn't really help...never does...

As soon as I saw dash enter the game, I was like, "Crap! I'm screwed!"

[Thomith]

yeah, next time i pull a gambit like that remind me not to make it so obvious and not flail so bad.
I think i was doing *ok* until then, but pulling the cop breadcrumb out of the bag was my biggest mistake imo.

[Hoopla]