NY 151: Playground Mafia (Game Over-Mafia Win!)

[Benmage]

Any preferences on who I investigate?

Me, pysche, max. Tho I imagine you being blocked or dying. Lets hope you have 1 nights worth of investigation left.

MEANING

REDFF

you protect RachMarie.

Oh add Maxous too the list as well.

[StrangerCoug]

SC

you've been so all over the place.

List me your top 3 scum reads, scummiest first.

HezLucky, you, and a tossup between OhGodMyLife and FakeGod.

[redFF]

Lol strangercoug more like strangernoob.

What do you think one vote for hezz is going to do? Vote on one of the wagons please. The effort it's taking to lunch ogml solidifies him as scum for me.

[StrangerCoug]

Oh, so we practice cannibalism now? [/spelling Nazi]

I am not here to be pushed around. If I cannot garner enough support for either HezLucky or Benmage right now, then I will vote one of them, but I want the fact that HezLucky cannot post a simple case on maxwell brought to everyone's attention at this moment. The reason I'm more reluctant to vote OhGodMyLife right now is because 1.) my vote on him was to test a theory by a player who since replaced out and of whom some people now suspect of being a serial killer and 2.) I don't buy OhGodMyLife and maxwell as both scum the way HezLucky's been going after him.

[StrangerCoug]

EBWOP: going after them

[HezLucky]

StrangerCoug has morphed into obvious scum who is pretending to be a noob / distracted. But he is not.

This makes him scum.

[DeasVail]

No, he was screamingly obvious town, sorry you're too fucking incompetent at this game to be able to read him or me correctly.

Look at the attitude!

Look at how exaggerated it is!

It's scum trying to have a town response, but not actually a town response!

[maxwell]

No, you're actually stupid and unbearable to read with your anti-logic. Genuinely.

[maxwell]

StrangerCoug, you're still pointedly ignoring me pointing out that your read on me has done a 180 without explanation.

[DeasVail]

No, you're actually stupid and unbearable to read with your anti-logic. Genuinely.

Stupid does not equal incorrect.

[maxwell]

No, but in this case it does and I'm about to mentally file you away with redFF under the "ignore" pool if you're going to keep operating on a different plane of thought from everyone else. One more time, though: I say OGML is stalling on delivering content and that I will vote him if he continues to stall. The implication here is that he's scum who can't justify his opinions (wait, where else have I seen this?). This is apparently "the wrong reason" to vote someone, according to you. Do I have that right?

[DeasVail]

It's usually pretty easy to fabricate opinions and justifications as scum.

There is no reason for scum to stall considering the above and even if not, it just attracts attention to them and doesn't help their situation. SO, the perceived stalling is much more likely to not be all that related to alignment.

Where your reasoning is wrong: You say that if you express a problem with the stalling and OGML continues stalling, then you somehow have more reason to vote for him. However, you are not actually considering that scum would no way intentionally keep stalling after that, and that continued stalling would in fact mean that the stalling is most likely not influenced by OGML's alignment.

[maxwell]

Oh cool, amateur psychology mafia theory, a thing I love to see. That has to be one of the worst arguments I've seen put forth in a game ever. It's not too hard for someone to try to justify their suspicions if they're town because it's just what they feel, even if they're unable to properly articulate it they can at least try to explain it where scum are more concerned about convincing people and saying the right thing so as to not appear suspicious. I'm done with you, hopefully the vig decides to take you out because you're not operating on the same plane of reality as anyone else.

[FakeGod]

@FAKEGOD

out of the act of self preservation.

VOTE OGML, otherwise I will be very very,---- fuckit. I'll vote you if you don't vote OGML in your next post.

UNVOTE:

VOTE: OhGoDMyLife

Did as requested.

[FakeGod]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Benmage

[StrangerCoug]

StrangerCoug, you're still pointedly ignoring me pointing out that your read on me has done a 180 without explanation.

I currently see you being scum as unlikely given HezLucky's refusal to put up a case on you that is more than just you bussing OhGodMyLife, to which I'm getting that your counterattack against DeasVail in post #2766 is related. (Speaking thereof, what do you think of HezLucky)?

StrangerCoug has morphed into obvious scum who is pretending to be a noob / distracted. But he is not.

As I said, nobody of either alignment has a need to be distracted. Ever. And trying to get answers to perfectly legitimate questions does not make me a noob. Anybody who finds me a nuisance has three options:

1. Work something out with me so that I am no longer a nuisance. (Hint: It's common sense to be reasonable.)
   
2. Replace out and find a game I'm not playing.
   
3. Kill me.

I

REALLY

prefer the first option.

[Benmage]

unvote vote Fakegod

[Benmage]

I think we can start pooling the votes, Fakegod didnt post for 2 days, to come back and do that..

Lets end this day, tomorrow should be telling anyways.

[Benmage]

My vote puts Fakegod at L-2.

SC, if you're done... since you said you have little preference between OGML and FG, mind putting him at L-1, so we can get a claim, lynch, and end today.

[StrangerCoug]

...Yeah. Since neither of us are getting anywhere with the other at this point, let's at least do something we both agree is a good idea—dispose of the lurkers.

VOTE: FakeGod

[Benmage]

FG has 24 hours as far as I'm concerned to claim before hammers are good to go.

MOD

can you player request prod Fakegod?

[DeasVail]

Maxwell:

Replacing:
DeasVail

~~

Also,

FakeGod please claim.

[DeasVail]

By the way, why is the main problem me not agreeing with everyone else rather than me being wrong about you?

[FakeGod]

I claim

Weak Doctor

.

First of all, I apologize if I made glaring mistakes in this game as Weak Doctor. I never played Weak Doctor before, and I had not the slightest idea what is the optimal play for Weak Doctor.

My breadcrumbs:

My thoughts:

1. Psyche Merry or Pippin
2. Kublai Khan Boromir
3. scooby Angry Smeagol
4. FakeGod poor me
5. OhGodMyLife Theoden
6. The Mini-Librarian Denethor
8. DeasVail Legolas
9. kdowns Samwise
10. Code_X Merry or Pippin
11. Benmage either Gandalf the grey or Saruman
12. Pine Gollum
13. drmyshottyizsik Bilbo Baggins
14. HezLucky Merry or Pippin
15. drmyshotgun Frodo Baggins
16. Nero Cain

F

aramir or

S

auron
17. redFF

E

omer or

U

ruk-hai captain
19. mastin2 Either Elrond or Balrog
20. Lady Lambdadelta Galadriel
21. Junpei Either Aragorn or Ringwraith
22. Maxous Gimli
24. StrangerCoug Either Gandalf the white or Treebeard

I would vote pine over Junpei.

Only two players in this list that I listed two characters for, that I did not use "Merry or Pippin", or "either or", are #16 and #17.
#16 says "F" and "S", which stands for "Flip Side", which, when #17's "E" and "U" are flipped sideways, spell "W" and "D" (U was best I could do there)


As I figured that as weak doctor, I should pick a target, hope that the target was town, and stick with him entire way.
I randomly chose Junpei for my N1 target, and stuck with him. That's why I didn't want him lynched.
This is where I outright say my night result.

Junpei is town.

Pretty sure this guy is scum.

VOTE: Nero Cain

@

Junpei

: asdfjkl

n

;as;dlkfjas;ldkfja;slkfjsal;dkfj

1

asdfjl;kjla;sdfk;l

Also, Junpei replacing out might make him a bad sport, but not a scum. Since when did replacing out become a scum tell?

In the post above, the 8 letters your fingers rest on when you type are "asdfjkl;". Only letters not included in it are "n" and "1". I saved Junpei on since N1.

Here's my softclaim:

FakeGod-

What's been preventing me from putting him as stronger scum is 1774, which I find to be the kind of interesting post that would only come from town. Otherwise, it really seems like he could be scum to me. His posting has been minimal, but not controversial and I think it's possible he's just purposely flying under the radar. However, another thing I question is whether he would be more pro-town if scum.

I have my reasons.

Also, regarding meta, I was never scum in any of my games. (I completed 15 games total; I keep track in my wiki) Therefore, unfortunately there are no data I could bring as evidence to support that I am town from any of my games.

Now that Junpei was dead, I decided to save my strongest town read, LLD.

W

ow,

LLD

was Godfather???

D

idn't think she would be scum.

Agreed with Hez and SC. Also agreeing with DLG and andrew that TML should claim.

VOTE: Benmage

Here, I express few things.

One, obvious breadcrumbing for my role.

Two, my N3 target, who was LLD.

Three, LLD died. Someone broke through my protection and killed her.

Four, my surprise that I'm still alive. I picked a scum for my target..... doesn't that mean I should be dead?

I came to conclusion that I was probably roleblocked during Night 3.

[FakeGod]

Also,

@Benmage: I am not going to negotiate with terrorists.