NY 151: Playground Mafia (Game Over-Mafia Win!)

[RachMarie]

what on earth is a weak Doc?

[FakeGod]

If I protect an anti-town player, then I die.

Wiki:
https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Doc

[Benmage]

absolutely redunkulous.

unvote

I need to think

[Psyche]

Oh, so that's how you do it. Cool stuff, fakegod.

[DeasVail]

Leave FakeGod alive.

The "I have my reasons" made sense as a softclaim to me at the time.

[DeasVail]

N2 target?

[FakeGod]

@DV: I saved Junpei N1 and N2.

[DeasVail]

Hmm why did you save him N2?

[FakeGod]

As the Weak Doctor, I take a chance of death every time I pick a new target.

I took that chance Night 1, and I didn't die.

I saw no reason to switch target and risk death again. Plus, Junpei was confirmed town to me at that point, so I chose him again for N2.

[maxwell]

Fakegod, why didn't you claim when RedFF claimed doc?

At this point I find it terribly hard to believe that there'd be both a doctor and a weak doctor in the setup given the other flipped roles and claimed roles. Reads say RedFF is more likely town, so the vote stays. Will re-read ISOs tomorrow morning to try and affirm my thoughts.

[Code_X]

If I protect an anti-town player, then I die.

Wiki:
https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Doc

Yet the night you protected LLD she died? Surely it should have been the other way around.

Confused somewhat.

UNVOTE: Fakegod

Going to review my suspects list from a few pages back. A number of these claims feel dodgy.

[VisMaior]

What 2 docs on LLD? S/he must be some good player.

[Code_X]

2 Docs and a Strongman on her. Doesn't add up does it.......

[DeasVail]

Eh, I don't know. First time I got weak doc, my plan was completely different.

[VisMaior]

Yea Im not actually buying that claim much. The bredadcrumbs appear very contrieved to me.

[DeasVail]

I don't think we should lynch him (at least not yet) though.

FG, if you are weak doc, either target someone where it'd be useful to have an indication of their alignment, or someone who is likely to be killed by scum. There are two options I see:

1) Have him claim who he is going to doc. The problem I have with this option is that the only purpose is to know who he targeted if he dies, but scum killing him would make things confusing considering the number of kills and the possibility if kills being blocked.

2) Only reveal who he protected the following day. Hides from scum who he is going to target, but leaves us in the dark if he targets scum.

[HezLucky]

lol fakeclaim is fake.

[redFF]

vote:fakegod

not buying that, it also counters mine. I also think those breadcrumbs could be tailored for all sorts of roles and he just switched them around for weak doc.

Why didn't you claim when I claimed doctor?

[RachMarie]

Boy LLD was really popular?

Umm FG if you are a weak doc and die when protecting scum instead of town then why did you not die for protecting LLD who was the Mafia Godfather. Your claim is not adding up here.

[DeasVail]

I don't see how it's particularly unlikely that there is both a weak doctor and doctor in this game.

I do think FakeGod could be scum, but I think it's better not lynching him now because of the chance that he is town (and there are things which lead me to think he could be town: his softclaim and claiming with a claimed doc).

I think it's better to run up someone else to claim (maxwell please?) and then probably lynch them.

[DeasVail]

Umm FG if you are a weak doc and die when protecting scum instead of town then why did you not die for protecting LLD who was the Mafia Godfather. Your claim is not adding up here.

Do you think that makes him more likely scum?

[Code_X]

DeasVail is probably scum.

[DeasVail]

DeasVail is probably scum.

ok.

[RachMarie]

@ DV can you understand my skepticism here and wanting a bit more clarification?

[DeasVail]

@ DV can you understand my skepticism here and wanting a bit more clarification?

Yes, but you haven't answered my question, which you seem to have interpreted as an accusation.