NY 151: Playground Mafia (Game Over-Mafia Win!)

[Psyche]

Holy crap that's a lot of power that died.

@Anybody: Do you think it is possible a Serial Killer in this game could be investigative immune along with a godfather that was?
Particulary @ Hez, benmage, and SC who I think(?) have been in numerous games.

Doubt it. You want an investigation immune godfather AND sk? That makes the cop downright useless. More likely SK is nightkill immune.

Which leaves Psyche, Maxwell, Hez and SC.

This is a good list. Minus me.

I still think lynching HezLucky is the correct answer for refusing to justify how maxwell was bussing OhGodMyLife. Yes, OGML flipped scum. That was what I thought at the time.

LOL and you wonder why you're on the list.


@DLG: You mean I was actually right about Psyche the whole time?

Vote: Psyche

1 for 5 ain't bad, or something.

lol

it doesn't have to be 0 for 5 if you try harder to find a better vote.

[Psyche]

Gah. Rach is cop!

Well, at least my redff read was right. Sigh.

[RachMarie]

Wait Psyche are you calling me useless? Though I have to admit with both a town and a mafia roleblocker I and my predecessor have not been the best of the west or anything here

[Psyche]

No, no. I just had a hunch.

[HezLucky]

Holy crap that's a lot of power that died.

@Anybody: Do you think it is possible a Serial Killer in this game could be investigative immune along with a godfather that was?
Particulary @ Hez, benmage, and SC who I think(?) have been in numerous games.

Doubt it. You want an investigation immune godfather AND sk? That makes the cop downright useless. More likely SK is nightkill immune.

Which leaves Psyche, Maxwell, Hez and SC.

This is a good list. Minus me.

I still think lynching HezLucky is the correct answer for refusing to justify how maxwell was bussing OhGodMyLife. Yes, OGML flipped scum. That was what I thought at the time.

LOL and you wonder why you're on the list.


@DLG: You mean I was actually right about Psyche the whole time?

Vote: Psyche

1 for 5 ain't bad, or something.

lol

it doesn't have to be 0 for 5 if you try harder to find a better vote.

The toher vote I am interested in right now is maxwell's obvbus from yesterday.

once psyche and maxwell flip scum (minimum 1 out of 2) we can then proceed to get strangercoug for being useless

[redFF]

vote:psyche

I have a townread on hez from pretty much the whole game.

I'd lynch Psyche, maxwell, code x, maxous, sc and benmage before hez. that should be the lynch order btdubz.

[StrangerCoug]

So

SC

is anyone more blatantly town than I, now?

Yes. Practically the whole game. Do you see the rest of us pumping our egos?

Wait wait wait... YOU STILL fine me scummy??

Let me see your top 2 scum.

When you asked the question, it hadn't changed from the end of yesterday: HezLucky, then you. DLG's pushing really hard for a Psyche lynch in #2864, and I'm buying.

UNVOTE: HezLucky
VOTE: Psyche

Psyche.... I am the only reason you are alive.... last sentence did you mean someone else?

Do you think it's a really good idea for you to say that to DLG's biggest read? I know he's not seriously considering you, but the implications will not look good if Psyche flips scum.

Which leaves Psyche, Maxwell, Hez and SC.

This is a good list. Minus me.

I still think lynching HezLucky is the correct answer for refusing to justify how maxwell was bussing OhGodMyLife. Yes, OGML flipped scum. That was what I thought at the time.

LOL and you wonder why you're on the list.

If you're going to comment about the list, why don't you provide some useful input? maxous is entitled to his opinion, and if I am not knowledgeable about why I am on the list, I will ask.

The toher vote I am interested in right now is maxwell's obvbus from yesterday.

once psyche and maxwell flip scum (minimum 1 out of 2) we can then proceed to get strangercoug for being useless

Explain how I am any more useless than you.

[PeregrineV]

Vote Count 5-1

(as of Post 2881)

Psyche (4)

- DLG, HezLucky, redFF, StrangerCoug

Not Voting (6)

- Benmage, Code_X, Maxous, maxwell, Psyche, RachMarie

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch

Deadline:

Friday, July 13, 2012, 2pm CDT

Replacing:

No one

Prods (48 hours):

None

V/LAs:

No one

[Code_X]

Psyche

I've already made clear why.

[Code_X]

Ergh fucking phone posting

vote psyche

Out of interest what roles do Joats normally get? May be worth reviewing DV

[Code_X]

DLG I purely unvoted because I hadn't read the thread. Something I always do when replacing in is unvote, read then vote, alas day ended before I read.

[Benmage]

Stop the mislynch now noobs.

[Benmage]

Post like this:

That it was so long ago is what makes it okay to laugh at it.

Here's what's been happening to me this game:
I joined it because I was looking for a fast mafia fix.
But found it to be far more active than what I was used to. And on top of that, I found that this and the assortment of players in the game was making the whole thing a chore.
And then when school concerns took over, the thread grew enormously and I struggled to grasp the motivation and passion to read and analyze such an overwhelming load.
I asked to replace out, and almost made it out, but a missent PM by Peregrine and guilt over the whole thing had me running back.
But I still couldn't get over that readthrough hump, and school was only getting more hectic.
Once school was over, I was in a Game with more pages than I had ever been asked to handle before. And I still lacked willpower.
So I just whittled my time away and ignored the game, feeling guilty but trapped every moment of it...And here we are.

I've ruined myself. I've set myself up for failure.
But now I'll try to make up for it, at least a little.
Or maybe I'll just give up, overdue-like. Eh.

Benmage's case on me is him trying to frame that which is a whole lot of nothing. I don't see I can be accused of anything except of absolutely nothing.

DONT COME FROM SCUM. Because than the person would be the biggest douchebag ever. And noone wants to actually be a douchebag. This is just a defeated townie. This isn't lying scum.

What his tactic was to tactically lurk? And than play this apathetic card? No... he's a sad pathetic, undeserving player.... but this lynch is atrocious.

I'd much rather lynch

SC

, who some how idiotically can fathom me scum.

Yesterday fine, but my interplay with Fakegod, case on ogml... them both flipping scum. Like woWW, to still believe me scum, is one of the most stubborn things I've ever heard of.

[Benmage]

Ah here's the post that makes me chuckle at the notion I could be scum... I suggest lynching one scum, and vigging the other.... Yep totally partners... What did SC want, oh yeah 2 town. Me and Hezz.

So who should I target then?

How about Fakegod or OGML...whichever doesn't eat rope. SO we can analyze both competing wagons.

[Benmage]

Ah here's the post that makes me chuckle at the notion I could be scum... I suggest lynching one scum, and vigging the other.... Yep totally partners... What did SC want, oh yeah 2 town. Me and Hezz.

So who should I target then?

How about Fakegod or OGML...whichever doesn't eat rope. SO we can analyze both competing wagons.

[Benmage]

In fact

Vote Strangercoug

-I'm tired of his stubbornness.
-His shitty reads
-His illogical statements
-His counterproductive mentality.

Lets see... he derailed the scum PR lynch of OGML when the two wagons were tied. Congrats.

[Code_X]

Unvote

Will re-read properly before committing.

[StrangerCoug]

Ah here's the post that makes me chuckle at the notion I could be scum... I suggest lynching one scum, and vigging the other.... Yep totally partners... What did SC want, oh yeah 2 town. Me and Hezz.

So who should I target then?

How about Fakegod or OGML...whichever doesn't eat rope. SO we can analyze both competing wagons.

Show where you posted cases on FakeGod and OhGodMyLife. Bussing two scum is perfectly conceivable.

Vote Strangercoug

-I'm tired of his stubbornness.

Stubbornness is not a scumtell.

-His shitty reads

Shitty reads are not themselves scumtells.

-His illogical statements

Show how my statements are illogical.

-His counterproductive mentality.

Show how my mentality is counterproductive.

[Benmage]

Ah here's the post that makes me chuckle at the notion I could be scum... I suggest lynching one scum, and vigging the other.... Yep totally partners... What did SC want, oh yeah 2 town. Me and Hezz.

So who should I target then?

How about Fakegod or OGML...whichever doesn't eat rope. SO we can analyze both competing wagons.

Show where you posted cases on FakeGod and OhGodMyLife. Bussing two scum is perfectly conceivable.

So I show you it... But I could still be scum bussing.. so whats the point? Way to give yourself options. I'll bother later, running out the house to a pool party..

Vote Strangercoug

-I'm tired of his stubbornness.

Stubbornness is not a scumtell.

-Debateable. Regardless I can't afford you endgame with 2 towns as your top reads. And 'forcing' consistency is a scumtell.

-His shitty reads

Shitty reads are not themselves scumtells.

So you agree you have shitty reads?

-His illogical statements

Show how my statements are illogical.

-His counterproductive mentality.

Show how my mentality is counterproductive.

-Stubborness on common practices. I.E. SCUM DO TARGET LURKERS.
--You DERAILED THE SCUM PR TO ATTACK HEZZLUCKY.

(I'm running I'll breakdown more why SC is todays choice)

[StrangerCoug]

So I show you it... But I could still be scum bussing.. so whats the point?

The point is that it's WIFOM. So you nailed two scum. That does not itself make you town.

Way to give yourself options.

So open-mindedness is now a scum tell? You're hilarious.

-Stubborness on common practices. I.E. SCUM DO TARGET LURKERS.

Where did I say they didn't?

--You DERAILED THE SCUM PR TO ATTACK HEZZLUCKY.

The black mark I get from trying to shift the wagon off someone who has since flipped scum to someone whose alignment is still unknown is something with which I have to live. You have to take into account that it could be mitigated if HezLucky flips scum (which I think he will), but any way you slice the bird, there are still worse crimes.

[Psyche]

Well. Benmage is even more definitely not scum. He could've easily taken the OP to rub me out.

[StrangerCoug]

Explain.

[Psyche]

Wait wait wait, lemme get through this first. I'm much more confident than I was when I started that I can find the scum.

I'll have a full explanation of every town and scumread I have on every living player. Null reads shall be avoided.
I shall be somewhat redeemed.

But yeah. From my perspective as a poorly playing townie, it seems clear that I'm the designated lynch for the Day since no one one has any strong scumreads at the moment (ergo, lynch the lurker). I'm an easy mislynch, and scum can comfortably wagon me for good reason without any net loss in cred. Benmage could've easily taken a neutral or negative stance on me and got a mislynch without any harm to his name, but instead he put his neck out.

Thus my townread.

Oh, and that other stuff I haven't paid a sufficient amount of attention to.

[StrangerCoug]

OK, I can see how that works from a town point of view.

[Psyche]

I have it narrowed to two people. I don't think Maxwell is scum because of his antiscum attitudes earlier in the game. But I'll keep an eye out on everyone as I continue.

(/is proud of himself but really concerned that he won't pull it off)