Mini 1350: Spartacus Blood and Sand Mafia Day 2

[Pine]

@Mod: I should have declared V/LA quite some time ago. I'll continue to have limited (but not absent) access until the end of this week. I'll be making serious efforts to make at least one significant post per day during this time, hopefully more.

[Apple Jack]

Ok, definitely Pine. He's still voting his "RVS" votes instead of D3f, even though he implies he's got a scum-read in 72. All his other stuff since then is re: death millers (content-free).

UNVOTE: all

VOTE: 2. Pine

I'm sticking with my RVS votes because they both continue to make sense. That's what 72 is referencing, if I recall correctly.

I've been on a bit of a bender this weekend. I'll catch up soonish

hurry up and get back from v/la. You are pretty easy to read so I'm looking forward to more content from you.

[whispersilk]

I'm back, but too tired to post tonight. I'm like Dorothy, back from the land of Oz.

[chesskid3]

Uhm. I will update this with a VC and prods tomorrow when I'm not exhausted. God my job has ridic hours. BUT IT IS AWESOME

[Phillammon]

My apologies for lack of posting, dead laptop charge cable. WIll be getting new one in soonish, posting from kindle in the mean time. As for my play, I'll admit that I haven't been contributing much, but ActionDan's accusations there weren't particularly helpful- the "more bullshit waffle", you'll note, was a response to a specific request for clarification. As that must therefore have been taken out of context, what was it that made you look at my ISO specifically, Dan?

[Code_X]

Dan - I've played with millers before. I'm happy to keep Shotgun alive if he appears pro-town. However, there is though the nagging thought of scum Shotgun claiming miller and then being allowed to slide all the way to endgame.

Phil - You have ignored my question again.

[mafia-n00b]

It seems like half the playerlist is V/LA or lurking.

@Pine: 72 implies a scumread on D3f... am I missing something?

[havingfitz]

Well....

UNVOTE: Mafia noob...for now.

[Phillammon]

My apologies. In all honesty, If I say someone feels off, 9 times out of 10 it's gut. In this case, it's gut with an added dose off strangely worded replies.

[whispersilk]

Not much seems to have happened since friday with lots of people on VLA. What I don't understand is why no one else has voted the active lurker posting complete fluff. Can we get some more votes on D3f3nd3r please - at the very least it will put him under some pressure to contribute.

[mafia-n00b]

Not much seems to have happened since friday with lots of people on VLA. What I don't understand is why no one else has voted the active lurker posting complete fluff. Can we get some more votes on D3f3nd3r please - at the very least it will put him under some pressure to contribute.

I can hop on board. Unfortunately, I'll be using V1.

VOTE: 1. D3f3nd3r

[Matias]

I'm back. I haven't read basically all of this; I'm going to tackle it tonight. Apologies for the late start.

[ActionDan]

If that were to be the duel, that would be Crixus vs Doctore, for reference.

I could live with those as the lynches, but I'm still not fully convinced, really.

You gave that opinion without being coerced. So when you say:

My apologies for lack of posting, dead laptop charge cable. WIll be getting new one in soonish, posting from kindle in the mean time. As for my play, I'll admit that I haven't been contributing much, but ActionDan's accusations there weren't particularly helpful- the "more bullshit waffle", you'll note,

was a response to a specific request for clarification.

As that must therefore have been taken out of context, what was it that made you look at my ISO specifically, Dan?

Pics or GTFO. (FYI I was rereading at first when I saw that post. Then I did an ISO)

@Code_X. If you played with millers before, why were you looking at the wiki for millers? (never mind getting confused with death millers [even though if you played with millers before I'm not sure how you didn't realize you were barking up the wrong tree immediately])

Guys, there is fluff and there is scummy fluff. Give Def. a chance to say something with some kind of opinion.

[Apple Jack]

I am just going to say it's too bad we aren't allowed to talk about on-going games and leave it at that.

My Vote on Code is staying until I see something of value come from him.

My vote on perengine stays and I have issues with 198

Meh. Yours was the first get-out-of-RVS vote. And I'll keep you in the suspicious-may-be-sleeping-with-Lucretia column.

And I was getting this Pine confused with another game Pine, until I read his ISO.

And I never showed any suspicion of Matais either, but am now voting him (also after his Iso, and after I got good town-vobes from noob)

1. I'm not buying the first part. When you actually ask someone to go provide game links to support their stance on something, this means you legitimately believe what i did is scummy. It looks like you dropped it because some people seem to have a town read on me and you know you will have a harder time pushing it.

2. what specifically about pine do you have an issue with? you still have not provided an explanation

3. Why exactly are you voting Matias anyway?

4. and can you please point out what posts make you have a town read on mafia n00b, once you do that i will show you why I have a "not so town" read on him.


See the issue I have with you is you don't provide reasoning for your votes, how on earth can we determine if your actions are town or scum motivated if we don't know why you are voting?

so I am good with my vote on you also until you can actually explain yourself.

[PeregrineV]

I am just going to say it's too bad we aren't allowed to talk about on-going games and leave it at that.

My Vote on Code is staying until I see something of value come from him.

My vote on perengine stays and I have issues with 198

Meh. Yours was the first get-out-of-RVS vote. And I'll keep you in the suspicious-may-be-sleeping-with-Lucretia column.

And I was getting this Pine confused with another game Pine, until I read his ISO.

And I never showed any suspicion of Matais either, but am now voting him (also after his Iso, and after I got good town-vobes from noob)

1. I'm not buying the first part. When you actually ask someone to go provide game links to support their stance on something, this means you legitimately believe what i did is scummy. It looks like you dropped it because some people seem to have a town read on me and you know you will have a harder time pushing it.

2. what specifically about pine do you have an issue with? you still have not provided an explanation

3. Why exactly are you voting Matias anyway?

4. and can you please point out what posts make you have a town read on mafia n00b, once you do that i will show you why I have a "not so town" read on him.


See the issue I have with you is you don't provide reasoning for your votes, how on earth can we determine if your actions are town or scum motivated if we don't know why you are voting?

so I am good with my vote on you also until you can actually explain yourself.

In the end, while I will vote scummy, time waits for no pony. I, as of right now, don't want to see you lynched today. I also don't want to see inte
lynched today, although I keeping an eye on him for flavor reasons.

I already explained Pine, but here's more if this helps you

Pine ISO

1-RVS vote
2-Derpy, Shotgun, Defender are scum (keeps RVS vote)
3-mafia definition (no death miller)
4-no death miller
5-flavor/fluff
6-catchup
7-VLA

To me, that's a better reason to vote someone.

Matias has posted half as much as Pine, in both number and content.

My town expectations of them are not currently being met. So I vote them.

Mafia-noob is engaging in conversation with me and other players. Since I think you determine alignments through conversation, he gets town points. If you want numbers, I guess 58, 86, 133, 140, 166 are some.

[havingfitz]

I'll be focusing more attention on this game. Other game requirements have relaxed for the moment so I should be able to catch up // get in gear.

Looks like a close race between inte and Phil for vote 1 honors (both L-3) and Pine leading the vote 2 pack at L-4.

[mafia-n00b]

@mod

: Prod request on inte, d3f, and drmy if not already sent.

[D3f3nd3r]

Prod dodge (btw, I haven't been prodded). I know I'm lurking.

UNVOTE ALL

Because RVS is long gone.


I've played multiple games of Mafia before, but I'm not great with strategy. I have had many games as town where I made a scumslip and was lynched after. I want to avoid these mistakes. I know that lurking is scummy, but less than some of the scumslips I've had when not lurking.

[chesskid3]

Sorry. I know I am being bad. I am super fucking busy at my job. Prods/VC/Search for co-mod all happenining in like 6 hours.

[drmyshotgun]

My apologies. In all honesty, If I say someone feels off, 9 times out of 10 it's gut. In this case, it's gut with an added dose off strangely worded replies.

For example??

D3f3nd3r's ISO looks pretty bad. He is staying out of all discussions, and just popping in small bits of info that is not very useful here and there. He seemed to want to get on Derpy, Shotgun wagon by asking others for reasons to get on them.

ActionDan's ISO is equal in numbers and he looks pretty detached too.

Derpy is Town I think because her argument with Inte looks Town on Town.

Sorry for being absent. Although I must say, there hasn't been much.

[drmyshotgun]

Matias doesn't look like he's in this game except that the player list proves otherwise.

Whisper is Town because she's most active and push on D3f3nd looks Town imo.

Mafia-n00b's jump on D3f3nd wagon looks too easy but I think him requesting prod on others are good sign.

[ActionDan]

D3f3nd3r's ISO looks pretty bad. He is staying out of all discussions, and just popping in small bits of info that is not very useful here and there. He seemed to want to get on Derpy, Shotgun wagon by asking others for reasons to get on them.

ActionDan's ISO is equal in numbers and he looks pretty detached too.

Wat?

[Pine]

@Pine: 72 implies a scumread on D3f... am I missing something?

No. There was no implication. I was flat-out stating a moderate-strength scumread of Defender.

Getting irritated that people are bitching about me keeping my RVS votes. They were both on people I now find genuinely scummy, so I kept them. Deal with it.

[chesskid3]

Votecount 8.1:

Inte: Derpy Hooves, havingfitz, Phillammon, whispersilk (L-3)
Phillammon: Code_X, inte, ActionDan, drmyshotgun (L-3)
Derpy Hooves: Matias, Pine (L-5)
D3f3nd3r: mafia-n00b
Pine: PeregrineV

Not voting (1): D3f3nd3r

Votecount 8.2:

Matias: Code_X, PeregrineV (L-4)
mafia-n00b: havingfitz, inte (L-5)
drmyshotgun: Matias, Pine (L-5)
Pine: drmyshotgun, mafia-n00b (L-5)
Derpy Hooves: Phillammon (L-6)
havingfitz: ActionDan (L-6)
D3f3nd3r: whispersilk (L-6)
PeregrineV: Derpy Hooves (L-6)

Not voting (1): D3f3nd3r

Deadline is 6PM EST on July 12th

Massprod time.

[inte]

I like ActionDan's posts