Mini 1344: Murder on the HMS Regalia - Game Over

[RichardGHP]

Phillammon has been quarantined. No further quarantine votes will be accepted today.

[BK201]

It might be good for watcher to watch me now...

[drmyshotgun]

VOTE: Psyche

[drmyshotgun]

God I'm terrible.

[image]

@drmyshotgun:

Yeah, you really are. You just hopped on to the next highest wagon because you don't want to be on the BK wagon, without having mentioned Psyche once in your ISO. (Although you did quote him in #446 to apologize.) That's enough for me to switch my vote again. Still not liking Psyche's play, though.

I'll try to continue being around close to deadline. I could switch back to Psyche or to BK, but I think drmyshotgun is a better choice.

Unvote: Psyche

Vote: drmyshotgun

[drmyshotgun]

Oh actually, I was forgetting about you.
VOTE: image

[guille2015]

I'll be unofficially V/LA until Monday. (since you can't submit less than 3 days).

I've had some suspicions on Shotgun. I am willing to Lynch Shotgun or Psych. I'll follow Image's latest BW. If this one fails, I'd be convince that I should follow the opposite BW of Image.

Vote drmyShotgun

[Phillammon]

BK: Really? Because given we have two PR claims at the minute, one of which is the watcher, that's not too useful.

I could live with a shotgun lynch today, and given time left, and that we've had the quarantine, we may as well. VOTE: Shotgun

[Psyche]

@Mod: Please replace me. I've already been incapable of playing fully and my internet access is now being constricted. I am sorry for the inconvenience.

[image]

Well, that at least solves the Psyche problem.

@guille2015:

Isn't it better to agree or disagree with wagons based more on the case than who is behind them? Are you saying that if drmyshotgun flips town, you think I'm scum?

[guille2015]

That is true. In fact, I am voting based on my suspicions in general against shotgun. Mostly his erratic posting and a couple more things that others have mentioned.

As for you, image, that comment was a bit of failed humor on my part. Just saying that I should not trust you BW if he flips town.

[drmyshotgun]

I should have been lynched yesterday. :/

[TheTrollie]

after an ISO, guile is now on my scumlist

Claim: basically a vanilla townie.

I found this post odd.

And all that about Zombies? What's that about?

not much commitment here. points out a post as odd, as if he wants to see if he can get others to bite the bait of drilling into espe.

If you think it's odd, why isn't your vote there? I mean, RVS is for when you don't find anything suspicious, but the first second you do, your vote should be jumping there, even for whatever little reason. You won't be pressuring anyone by throwing a completely random vote in the air, and then calling other behavior 'odd' and not acting on it, so why didn't you vote?

I did not think it merited a vote. I pointed it out so that everyone was aware of it.

However, I was told on my first game to vote more often. I guess I could have voted for espionage and it would have added pressure to him. I guess the chance is gone now.

says he doesnt think it merited a vote, then backtracks saying that maybe it did because he has been told he needs to vote more.

We should still use the quarantine on the second most suspicious player. I don't like the idea that some of you are putting out that we not use the quarantine.

no reasoning, this is a post that looks town but really is devoid of any helpful content

No we're not, at least know [it's likely].

d3f3nd3r's situational analysis did not take into account that

scum has PR

. I am basing my argument on this post #94. You are in agreement with this, which makes you part of the "we".

It would be a pretty messed up game to have a communal jailkeep and not have mafia power roles, js. Yes there are most probably three, unless we have two scumteams, in which case there are probably four scum. That's a pretty big assumption.

I agree.

while i do not think that talking about the hypothetical existance of scum PRs is scummy, this post does not phrase it hypothetically, guile says that town

has

PRs.

@players with plenty of games played.
What is considered normal, that the faction kill can be used by any mafia member regardless of them using their PR (i.e. as in the 2of4 newbie games) or faction kills can only be performed by scum not using their powers?

---

It's good to know that some of you are in agreement with me, but being in disagreement does not merit a lynch on Espeonage.

I am suspicious of Espeonage, but not because he disagrees with me, but from a couple of reads I got in our discussion.

FOS Espionage

until I get the question above answered by a few players.

and

UNVOTE: PeregrineV

---

Mod ~ Edited in guille2015's 125 which had disappeared.

this post screams scum to me. its a ton of fluff, a bunch of nonsense about agreeing with him making it seem like his arguments have been agreeable, but it really says nothing

VOTE: guile

[RichardGHP]

Ninth Vote Count of Day 2

Lynch:

[1] TheTrollie - [NabakovNabakov]
[1] Psyche - [BK201]
[3] BK201 - [Espeonage, Malakittens, sword_of_omens]
[1] image - [drmyshotgun]
[3] drmyshotgun - [image, guille2015, Phillammon]
[1] guille2015 - [TheTrollie]

[1] Not Voting - [Psyche]

Quarantine:

[1] drmyshotgun - [image]

[6] Phillammon - [guille2015, BK201, sword_of_omens, Malakittens, NabakovNabakov]

[1] sword_of_omens - [TheTrollie]

[4] Not Voting - [Psyche, Phillammon, Espeonage]

V/LA:

• Espeonage, until July 9
  sword_of_omens, until July 9
  Malakittens, until July 15

Searching for a replacement for Psyche.

As the replacement queue is at an unprecedented saturation level, please make replacement a last resort.

With 11 alive, it takes 6 votes to lynch and 6 votes to quarantine. Deadline for this day is July 9, 1630h UTC+12. You have just over a day.

[BK201]

I've played with him in 3 or 4 games where he was town and the only game that compares to this one is 404 where he was scum who replaced out day 1.

Can we please get some more votes on Psyche?

[Malakittens]

Can someone give me a quick recap on why Shotty's has 3 votes on him? Just either posts #'s or something..

[drmyshotgun]

^We should have lynched Phillammon since he's scum.
If you want to see where the votes were placed, this is the page you read.
If you want to see their reasonings through the words I've said. Well, they don't have one. There's no case on me except the fact that I'm useless.

Psyche asked replacement huh? Lol. As Town, he's the kind of player that sticks around tentatively.
VOTE: Psyche

[BK201]

This is all too similar to how he played 404. I'm not saying he always plays this way as scum, but his town games are much more involved.

[Malakittens]

Honestly I haven't had the time to read into the Psyche meta on different games. Maybe I'll find the time sometime tommorow.

[RichardGHP]

Bitmap replaces Psyche effective immediately. Thanks!

[Bitmap]

Hey guys,

Let me have some time to read over this thread and then I'll make a real post later.

[Bitmap]

9 hours left...

Alright, At first I thought it was BK but when he claimed to have a PR, it just doesn't seem right lynching him right now mostly cause his arguments have been null.

I believe that dms is bussing Phil since everyone seems intent that Phil is scum which makes me hint towards the face that dms perhaps might be scum. And biggest bandwagoner yet?

VOTE: drmyshotgun

[image]

@Bitmap:

What makes you think drmyshotgun is bussing Phil? He quarantined Phil, but never voted for him.

[Bitmap]

@Bitmap:

What makes you think drmyshotgun is bussing Phil?

He quarantined Phil

, but never voted for him.

In this case, quarantine is like a small bus. I think DMS is just trying to stay away from Phil but if he was to do a large bus, people might suspect him.

[TheTrollie]

I'm confused. everyone thinks phil is scum? do people really think that because I have a solid town read on him right now.