Mini 1350: Spartacus Blood and Sand Mafia Day 2

[Apple Jack]

D3f wagon is bigger, so I'm here. If drmy gets bigger, I'll hop.

Seriously if after this game you are town, i'm going to yell at you for this post.

I don't think it's good play to lynch the miller claim d1. Let the vig kill him(hopefully we have one)

What the fuck does that mean that you don't think it's "good play"?

How about a deal. If dr is still alive tomorrow will you promise to vote him up?

proper miller play is to claim in the first post. he did that.

I have bigger scum to fry tomorrow depending on how the current day and the night phase goes. he is null to me so I won't be voting a null when I have scum reads i'd rather lynch.

[drmyshotgun]

4) Be courteous to your fellow player. This is just a game - please don't bring personal grudges into the game. Try and keep it civil.

First and only warning

Who is this in reference to? Because I have not insulted Dr as far as I know.

Playing like an ass now?
I'll try not to insult anymore.

Tone change from 365 to 368 should be obvious. I was talking to others and then I started talking to you.

[chesskid3]

4) Be courteous to your fellow player. This is just a game - please don't bring personal grudges into the game. Try and keep it civil.

First and only warning

Who is this in reference to? Because I have not insulted Dr as far as I know.

Drmyshotgun.

[Apple Jack]

truth be told matty, i'd vote you over shotty because out of the 2 of you, you are the one with a higher chance of being scum, especially considering the fact that pine probably replaced out because his scum kryptonite is me. he always gets caught as scum by me and decided to replace out either by requesting privately or pretending to flake.

i'm half tempted to vote you now but I have already caught scum in Fitz and don't see any reason to remove my vote from him.


@ mod - surely some light cursing would be acceptable no? cursing is fun and only nancy pants get mad at cursing.

[MattP]

BLATANT LIE

I've never been a Miller before. How do I know how to make a "good" miller claim?
I get Game Mechanics wrong all the time.

First 5 pages are inexcusable you say?
Was getting voted at for being late.
Was getting voted at for having a role.

I thought it was obvious :/
Thought it fits with the flavor.

I don't know if I'm unlynchable. But the character Crixus was undefeated champion of Capua. :/

ALL of this was in reference to me

[drmyshotgun]

I apologize for cursing until now.
I will gladly get replaced if my further activity offends others.

[MattP]

To be honest, dr's behavior was not bothering me whatsoever

truth be told matty, i'd vote you over shotty because out of the 2 of you, you are the one with a higher chance of being scum, especially considering the fact that pine probably replaced out because his scum kryptonite is me. he always gets caught as scum by me and decided to replace out either by requesting privately or pretending to flake.

i'm half tempted to vote you now but I have already caught scum in Fitz and don't see any reason to remove my vote from him.


@ mod - surely some light cursing would be acceptable no? cursing is fun and only nancy pants get mad at cursing.

He just lied >.< Get over your tunnel vision

[chesskid3]

Light cursing is fine.
Lots of consecutive posts cursing at the same player is not.

[drmyshotgun]

BLATANT LIE

I've never been a Miller before. How do I know how to make a "good" miller claim?
I get Game Mechanics wrong all the time.

First 5 pages are inexcusable you say?
Was getting voted at for being late.
Was getting voted at for having a role.

I thought it was obvious :/
Thought it fits with the flavor.

I don't know if I'm unlynchable. But the character Crixus was undefeated champion of Capua. :/

ALL of this was in reference to me

You said from 365 to 368.
The last one isn't to you.
I thought you weren't such a dick and actually produce cases and was an able player.
This game makes me think of you otherwise.

[MattP]

You said from 365 to 368.
The last one isn't to you.
I thought you weren't such a dick and actually produce cases and was an able player.
This game makes me think of you otherwise.

This reads like you know I'm town.

[MattP]

And that was COMPLETE scummy AtE, what you just said

[Apple Jack]

are you telling me to get over MY tunnel vision? that's rich.

I don't have tunnel vision, I have posted good reasoning why someone was scum and that person still continues to do it.

you are pushing shotty for horrible reasoning and he is calling you out on it.

besides I don't see the lie he made, what did he lie about?

p.edit - seriously if you try to imply AtE is scummy I am going to push a policy lynch on you. AtE isn't scummy and it surely isn't a scumtell.

[MattP]

AtE CAN be scummy and it CAN be towny, and this was scummy

Do you not realize that Dr just used a strawman too?

I said his tone to me has changed drastically and randomly.

He said that the first posts were not directed at me

I pointed out they were meaning he lied

He countered stating that the last post was not and that's what he meant

THAT DOESNT CHANGE THAT HIS TONE TOWARDS ME HAS CHANGED DRASTICALLY

[MattP]

You're bissfully ignoring anything scummy he says because of a scumread on Pine. That's more offensive tunnel vision than mine. My townread on you just went byebye

[havingfitz]

I have already caught scum in Fitz and don't see any reason to remove my vote from him.

You haven't caught scum. You're talking (and scumhunting) out your arse. I'll devote more time to you tomorrow to explain why zzzzzzzzzzzz.

In the meantime why don't you answer my questions to you in this post.

[drmyshotgun]

And that was COMPLETE scummy AtE, what you just said

Lol, you are building up your non-existent case with each of my responses.
"Oh look, he's lying!"
"Oh look, AtE!'

That's professionalism for you.

[drmyshotgun]

Tone change from 365 to 368 should be obvious. I was talking to others and then I started talking to you.

Which part of this is a lie?
You asked from 365 to 368.
Not prior to those.

[MattP]

And that was COMPLETE scummy AtE, what you just said

Lol, you are building up your non-existent case with each of my responses.
"Oh look, he's lying!"
"Oh look, AtE!'

That's professionalism for you.

Maybe because all your posts are scummy as fuck

I now know your scumplay is transparent and that any games in the future with you will be smooth sailing, perfect

[drmyshotgun]

I can only stare with awe at how more wrong you can be.

[Apple Jack]

You're bissfully ignoring anything scummy he says because of a scumread on Pine. That's more offensive tunnel vision than mine. My townread on you just went byebye

actually pine was a null leaning scum, not a full blown scum read so your theory was just blown out of the water. Pine was tunneling ME not the other way around, way to just make yourself look even more stupid.

Truth be told, your push on shotty doesn't look town to me, I can't even see the town motivation behind it. Shotty did exactly what a miller is supposed to do and you don't ever lynch a miller claim day 1.

Now you just keep reaching trying to throw dirt on shotty and the things you say either aren't true (the lying) or aren't scummy (the AtE)

Shotty could be scum, but he isn't a D1 lynch. if anything your reaching is more egregious than anything shotty has done so far.


@ fitz, I have not finished my re-read and have not made it to that page. When i get back to my PC and have time to finish re-reading I will. Right now I am on my phone cause the wifi in my hotel isn't free.

p.edit - matty calls shotty's posts scumy? pot meet kettle is all I have to say about that...

[mafia-n00b]

And holy shit did mafia n00b just say he will bandwagon whichever wagon grows the largest? I mean how can we have 6 or 7 obviously scummy people but there is no way we can have 6-7 scum.

There are some really fucking dumb town in this game.

You need to work on your reading comprehension, brony...

I would to see either d3f or drmy get the second slot. I'm obviously not willing to join "whichever" wagon grows largest since fitz's wagon is currently the biggest, and you'll note I haven't hopped there. What the hell is anti-town about having two scumreads amongst the non-Phil players???

[MattP]

You're bissfully ignoring anything scummy he says because of a scumread on Pine. That's more offensive tunnel vision than mine. My townread on you just went byebye

actually pine was a null leaning scum, not a full blown scum read so your theory was just blown out of the water. Pine was tunneling ME not the other way around, way to just make yourself look even more stupid.

Truth be told, your push on shotty doesn't look town to me, I can't even see the town motivation behind it. Shotty did exactly what a miller is supposed to do and you don't ever lynch a miller claim day 1.

Now you just keep reaching trying to throw dirt on shotty and the things you say either aren't true (the lying) or aren't scummy (the AtE)

Shotty could be scum, but he isn't a D1 lynch. if anything your reaching is more egregious than anything shotty has done so far.


@ fitz, I have not finished my re-read and have not made it to that page. When i get back to my PC and have time to finish re-reading I will. Right now I am on my phone cause the wifi in my hotel isn't free.

p.edit - matty calls shotty's posts scumy? pot meet kettle is all I have to say about that...

HOW IS ME HAVING A STRONG GUT SCUMREAD ON SOMEONE AND TRYING TO GET THEM LYNCHED BECAUSE OF IT NOT TOWN

I started out with mainly meta reasoning and one false reason for my push and then shotty reinforced my read of him with his behavior

I am done arguing with both of you until other people get on because clearly nothing I saw will resonate with you

pedit: Mafia-noob, what do you think of my points on dr and his recent posting?

[mafia-n00b]

Mafia-noob, what do you think of my points on dr and his recent posting?

drmy is going off reservation, but that's not a scumtell for him. I've seen him do it as town, so "rage" doesn't really make me think he's scum. Heck, I'm not even sure it's genuine. His playstyle aside, his contributions and tactics seem unlike the last game I played with him (he was town) and that worries me. He's totally ignoring all other people who are voting him or have expressed suspicion of him while seemingly focused entirely on discrediting your read on him... as if that was the only problem he has. The whole thing feels forced to me.

[MattP]

Mafia-noob, what do you think of my points on dr and his recent posting?

drmy is going off reservation, but that's not a scumtell for him. I've seen him do it as town, so "rage" doesn't really make me think he's scum. Heck, I'm not even sure it's genuine. His playstyle aside, his contributions and tactics seem unlike the last game I played with him (he was town) and that worries me. He's totally ignoring all other people who are voting him or have expressed suspicion of him while seemingly focused entirely on discrediting your read on him... as if that was the only problem he has. The whole thing feels forced to me.

Yeah, I feel the same way comparing his town games to this.

[Apple Jack]

You're bissfully ignoring anything scummy he says because of a scumread on Pine. That's more offensive tunnel vision than mine. My townread on you just went byebye

actually pine was a null leaning scum, not a full blown scum read so your theory was just blown out of the water. Pine was tunneling ME not the other way around, way to just make yourself look even more stupid.

Truth be told, your push on shotty doesn't look town to me, I can't even see the town motivation behind it. Shotty did exactly what a miller is supposed to do and you don't ever lynch a miller claim day 1.

Now you just keep reaching trying to throw dirt on shotty and the things you say either aren't true (the lying) or aren't scummy (the AtE)

Shotty could be scum, but he isn't a D1 lynch. if anything your reaching is more egregious than anything shotty has done so far.


@ fitz, I have not finished my re-read and have not made it to that page. When i get back to my PC and have time to finish re-reading I will. Right now I am on my phone cause the wifi in my hotel isn't free.

p.edit - matty calls shotty's posts scumy? pot meet kettle is all I have to say about that...

HOW IS ME HAVING A STRONG GUT SCUMREAD ON SOMEONE AND TRYING TO GET THEM LYNCHED BECAUSE OF IT NOT TOWN

I started out with mainly meta reasoning and one false reason for my push and then shotty reinforced my read of him with his behavior

I am done arguing with both of you until other people get on because clearly nothing I saw will resonate with you

pedit: Mafia-noob, what do you think of my points on dr and his recent posting?

1. because it is something that scum can do also. Scum can claim they have a gut scum read on someone and push a lynch and than say OMG look it's town of me to do this...

2. meta reasoning and a lie.... yeah town would not need to make up a false reason to lynch someone, but scum would... plus shotty used to be (maybe still is) one of the worst VI's in the history of mafiascum. his meta is probably crap and he has probably had his fair share of mis-lynches cause he is that easy to mis-lynch.


@ mafia-n00b - my compehension is just fine.

this is what you said

D3f wagon is bigger, so I'm here. If drmy gets bigger, I'll hop.

this basically means you will hop on whichever wagon grows stronger.
did you make a case on defender? if so link to it

did you make a case on shotty? if so link to it.

if you did not make cases on either than you are stupid stupid moronic town or you are scum.