Mini 1344: Murder on the HMS Regalia - Game Over

[VisMaior]

And for the record, the quarintine vote is for who we believe to be the scum RB, correct?

Are we sure its a RB? Where did this come from? Just cos trollie claims to have been RBd?

[VisMaior]

It is possible, depending on the answer, that I can clear or condemn certain players, which would make thing earlier.

I can clear BK to some extent. I am inclined to believe his claim.

[drmyshotgun]

It is possible, depending on the answer, that I can clear or condemn certain players, which would make thing earlier.

I can clear BK to some extent. I am inclined to believe his claim.

Sure you're his partner.

[RichardGHP]

Fifth Vote Count of Day 3

Lynch:

[2] BK201 - [Malakittens, Espeonage]
[4] drmyshotgun - [BK201, guille2015, image, drmyshotgun]

[3] Not Voting - [Salamence20, Phillammon, TheTrollie]

Quarantine:

[1] guille2015 - [drmyshotgun]
[1] Salamence20 - [BK201]
[1] TheTrollie - [Malakittens]
[1] BK201 - [image]

[5] Not Voting - [Espeonage, TheTrollie, Salamence20, Phillammon, guille2015]

With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch and 5 votes to quarantine. Deadline for this day is in (expired on 2012-07-25 17:30:00).

[VisMaior]

I dont think a trollie quarantien is any good. We can see wether he claims to have watched the Nk again.

quarantine Salamence20

is better IMHO.

[drmyshotgun]

I dont think a trollie quarantien is any good. We can see wether he claims to have watched the Nk again.

quarantine Salamence20

is better IMHO.

Yeah so you gonna just ignore me?
Let's see who's on Salamance Quarantine wagon...oh! What a surprise. BurgerKing.

[Malakittens]

Sorry half asleep. Here's my Q vote.

Unquarantine:
Quarantine:Bk

Still waiting for Sal to post reads and I'll look over Vais in the mOrning

[VisMaior]

I dont think a BK quarantine is any good. He should instead openly state where he will hide.
This way if scum kills him, we have 2 confirmed towns in guille and malak. If they dont, then he can supply another innocent, or possibly die and get a scum result to us (eg 2 deaths).

[guille2015]

I dont think a BK quarantine is any good. He should instead openly state where he will hide.
This way if scum kills him, we have 2 confirmed towns in guille and malak. If they dont, then he can supply another innocent, or possibly die and get a scum result to us (eg 2 deaths).

Let's check the numbers. There are 9 players, If we mislynch today, then tomorrow is Lylo. If BK dies by Hidding, then we will still be in LyLo, with a better idea as to who is mafia. The problem is that if BK chooses a town player to hide behind, then mafia will target that player and kill two birds with one shot. This has to be done very carefully. BK would have to willingly try to hide behind mafia. If the person is town, he is likely to be a suspicious town folk (One that mafia is trying to keep alive). BK would be clearing that person for Lylo. If the person is scum, then we would know. The draw backs to this, is if mafia has any power to redirect.

[guille2015]

Yeah,

Quarantine Salamance

Sounds like a good idea.

[Malakittens]

unquarantine:
Quarantine: Sal

[image]

I dont think a BK quarantine is any good. He should instead openly state where he will hide.
This way if scum kills him, we have 2 confirmed towns in guille and malak. If they dont, then he can supply another innocent, or possibly die and get a scum result to us (eg 2 deaths).

Bad idea. Bad. Don't do this. guille, you got your numbers messed up.

Assuming we lynch today, there will be 8 alive at the start of the night. If BK announces where he is going to hide, there are two cases. If the target is town, the mafia will kill that person for a double kill. If his target is mafia, he will die, and the mafia will make a kill as normal. Either way, we have two deaths leaving us with 6 alive tomorrow morning. If there are three scum, as seems likely with a game of this size, this is a scum win.

BK, hide if you want, but by no means let mafia figure out ahead of time who you are going to target.

[VisMaior]

It only works if we dont mislynch.

[image]

Ah, right. I was thinking worst-case scenarios.

[guille2015]

Do'H yeah, my bad. I was thinking worst case scenario, while I did the math for the best case scenario.

It really would depend on what BK thinks of this.

[TheTrollie]

Trollie, Were your results from the last two days different?

nope. both no result

[BK201]

I'd prefer not to hide, at this point dying ain't so bad since it confirms two slots. I think I'm gonna review image, espe, and maybe nab/sal tonight so don't hammer.

[Malakittens]

Well Sal promised us reads and hasnt returned with them. The second replacement posted his before her. I'm still waiting on them, but if they don't appear soonish I'm thinking possible scum tbh :/

[Salamence20]

Well Sal promised us reads and hasnt returned with them. The second replacement posted his before her. I'm still waiting on them, but if they don't appear soonish I'm thinking possible scum tbh :/

Im sorry!!!

I know i keep saying that but i swear you will see a post TONIGHT! Promise

[Malakittens]

Mmk.

[Salamence20]

Ok, I am going to post about everything I see, it probably will be answered within looking the whole game, but here goes...

Why did Espeonage claim vanilla early??
Post #102 and #86 doesn't make sense.
Currently at #118 and don't see why Esepeonage is still alive at this moment.
Post #135 seems more of a guess more than a slip, I am not that experienced in Mafia, but I would guess there would have to be some kind of mafia PR.
I disagree with #172
Brundibar sucks at posting
#252 Proves this point

Mod edit ~ Redacted. Do not talk about ongoing games!

WTF #298?
#306 sounds odd, I don't see why Espe is dropping his own quarentine, seems alittle scummy.
#310 is my excuse
Someone please explain where the SAD quarentine began?
Esepeonage seems VI over scum.
#329 isn't tunneling a scumtell?
Agree with #344
#376 breadcrumming?
#422 and #424 why is Shotgun claiming and Psyche defending?
#441 Why isn't SAD involved???
#450 makes Espe seem scummy, #454 doesn't help
Why did everyone decide on a VT quarintine?
#522, hard to really do that I think.
#524 worries me...
Not sure about Mala VT, don't really like Espe defense.
#577 doesn't make sense since Mala isn't new...
#593... I'm wondering about my read...
#615 reason por favor?
As I think about it, could Trollie be lying scum who targeted SAD as scum???
#647 what role???
#651, #652, and #654 make me want to kill shotgun
#660 AtE?
#674 I don't see how that is scummy
#678 Die
#714 is sheeping a scumtell???
#734 again!?!?!?
#748 WTF!?!?!?!?!?!
#760 sure thing buddy /sarcasm
#770 not sure what to say about it.
#781 not sure where the quarintine is comming from, go ahead, but I don't know how I would be scum RB.
#790 Why quarentine a PR? he maybe useless but it is still a PR.

Vote: Shotgun

Not sure who to quarintine, go ahead and do it to me if you want, do I have to claim before that? Any questions please ask

Also, I did this at midnight so I am tired.

[Salamence20]

SHIT!!! Didn't see L-1!!!

Quarintine: Salamence20

[Salamence20]

@Mod: if it is a shotgun lynch, can you please honor my quarantine vote as well if it is majority, like I said I am very tired reading 34 pages and need some sleep please.

[Espeonage]

Well see you guys in lylo.

[BK201]

Well see you guys in lylo.

Are you pretending you don't know drm's alignment?