History Mafia Mini Theme - 1358 Game Over!

[Staeg]

Oh, right, I decided not to say it but IG's kinda right - he

could

manipulate it but it's too much risk - very little reward.

I'm sleepy and what this is supposed to mean is "I thought about this as well, but ended up not saying it, cause it's high risk - pretty much no reward".

[IceGuy]

Oh, right, I decided not to say it but IG's kinda right - he

could

manipulate it but it's too much risk - very little reward.

Not obviously manipulate it - just some subtle misinterpretations or strategic omissions are enough, and defensible in case of being called out.

[Vash]

I'm posting the rest later cause I need to finished it, I'm stoned and I'm watching Labyrinth.

[Shamrock]

Not sure I see the point of the CO wagon - he obviously shifted focus between his first two setup-speculation posts and his third post in response to Michel but I have difficulty buying the case that that makes him scummy. I don't post every random thought on the game that passes through my head either.

I still like my Bitmap vote but could be convinced to switch to Staeg, he smells wrong to me too

[Amrun]

So Vash's pbp is quite the recreative history. Are you parodying a history book? I get it!

[DCLXVI]

There are some problems with vash' pbp stuff . On my phone now right now so can't point them all out ATM. I think everyone should go through his posts and see if vash is being accurate in his descriptions of their posts because I know vash was very wrong about at least two of mine.

[DCLXVI]

@amrun

Yes I think it may very well be recreative history , but not in a good way..

[Vash]

Dude, I summed up every post and put my reaction. If you want to feel like anything has been changed be my guest but pics or it didn't happen :p

[Staeg]

DCL, he has the right here; you're basing a lot of RVS stuff that could even be classified as town-tells (but shouldn't be) as a "direction we need to be heading".

Oh and

unvote
vote: DCLXVI

Let's have some fun with paraphrasing these two quotes.

DCL is basing his accusations on stuff that could be town-tells. But wait, they aren't towntells. but what the heck I'm going to vote DCL anyway.

Yeahhhhh
um

no

[Quilford]

Vash's PBPA is terrible. We can lynch him next.

I'll answer ChaosOmega at some point but his latest post is continuing the trend of being ridiculously bad.

[DCLXVI]

but pics or it didn't happen :p

--------
Ok, let's look at your summery of my post #60 & 61

(DCL) Posts 60 & 61, Defends Iceguy, Calls out staeg, Null/Scum

ICEguy is a scumread for me. I have not been defending him at all. Let's look at my posts where I supposedly defend ICEguy.

Pedit: I don't think ICEguy has role related info that could break the game, he is just making stuff up after people went after him for his asking for a massclaim.

How is this defending ICEguy? I'm straight up calling him a liar.

--------

[Staeg]

ohhhh I think I forgot to respond to that.

What I meant with some of my posts was that I didn't think that IG's suggesting that his role can outright break the game with a nameclaim, just that it would help the town out.

[MattP]

[quote="In [url=http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.<a class="inlineAdmedialink" href="#">php</a>?p=4199554#p4199554]post 182[/url], Vash"]Dude, I summed up every post and put my reaction. If you want to feel like anything has been changed be my guest but pics or it didn't happen :p[/quote]
I've never played with you when you were scum, but this post is not your town play, you never joke around as town.

VOTE: Vash

I feel very confidant about this.

[MattP]

Because Quilford's convinced me to such an extent that CO is a stronger scumread?

Other than that, matt's prolly town and currently thinking dany/scooby+CO+bit/dcl

I'll just add vash to your scumlist

So I ask

Hey Staeg, besides everyone but me and you, who else is scum to you?

[Staeg]

You. I did like the rhyme to that would-be riddle.

[Bitmap]

FOS: MattP

It just seems he knows too much for his own good. Other than that, I have no other reason.

[MattP]

FOS: MattP

It just seems he knows too much for his own good. Other than that, I have no other reason.

Sooooo you admit that Staeg and Vash are scum?

[Staeg]

FOS: MattP

It just seems he knows too much for his own good. Other than that, I have no other reason.

This is horrible beyond reason, and it's wrong at that - matt always does this, and I presumed that you would know this, having played with him

[Bitmap]

FOS: MattP

It just seems he knows too much for his own good. Other than that, I have no other reason.

This is horrible beyond reason, and it's wrong at that - matt always does this, and I presumed that you would know this, having played with him

Yes, I've played with him. We were playing chat mafia and mostly screwing around. The rounds were extremely quick.

Anyways, that's why I have the FOS on him and not a vote. And I've never played with him on mafia scum before.

[Staeg]

Okay, yeah, this dude's horrible, but town for now

[Bitmap]

Okay, yeah, this dude's horrible, but town for now

You suck.

[Shamrock]

FOS: MattP

It just seems he knows too much for his own good. Other than that, I have no other reason.

what does this even mean?

[Bitmap]

FOS: MattP

It just seems he knows too much for his own good. Other than that, I have no other reason.

what does this even mean?

I don't know why someone town would auto assume someone else is noobtown so early and basically saying that the player could be in no such instance be scum.

[MattP]

Mattp Aka Shen, is obvtown, i've played with/mod a forum with (Or did rather since he
left the mod team ) I know his meta.

What are my town tells?

[MattP]

Conversely, what are my scum tells?