History Mafia Mini Theme - 1358 Game Over!

[MattP]

aaaalso this is kinda wrong

[MattP]

From my extensive meta I just performed on you in the past five minutes, MSH, you are more aggressive in your town meta than you're being here

[MattP]

This game is getting too laggy

Everyone top three scumreads now.

Vash
Staeg
Shamrock/chaos/MSH I can't decide

[Bitmap]

Chaos
Vash
DCI/Staeg

[DCLXVI]

scumreads:
iceguy
vash
staeg
amrun

[scooby]

yep, I was right from the beginning, I don't like the polite tone.

VOte: MSH

Top other reads include Amrunscum and probably one of (Vash, Idany, or Shamrock)

[Amrun]

Amrun wagon doesn't seem to be moving any time soon so I'm willing to pressure Vash.

UNVOTE: Amrun
VOTE: Vash

SUPER SCUMMY POST

Why am I the only one voting here?

[scooby]

Why is it scummy?

[Amrun]

This is the entirety of what he's said about Vash:

I also agree that Vash's "analysis" is pretty worthless. I mean, hell, I might not be contributing all that much but at least I'm not writing pages full of nothing in order to make it look like I am.

This was in the midst of the post I called so scummy, in which he called every major wagon scummy but somehow fencesat on them all, a true feat.

I predicted that he crafted this post in order to leave his options open to join any major wagon - and lo and behold, that prediction is coming true. He joined the wagon that was getting some heat at the time (me) with no original reasons of his own, and now that that wagon has fallen off, he's joining Vash wagon with no reasons at ALL. Note that he's never once even called Vash scum! He's said he's posting badly, and that he's okay with pressuring Vash. And he's all, "Oh, shucks, no Amrun wagon?" when he hasn't done anything to push it besides regurgitate YOUR points and it hasn't even been a page yet. He doesn't TRULY believe I'm scum, or that Vash is scum. He's trying to fit in and achieve a mislynch.

[Amrun]

So yeah I'm even LESS keen on the Vash wagon now.

[Shamrock]

He joined the wagon that was getting some heat at the time (me) with no original reasons of his own, and now that that wagon has fallen off, he's joining Vash wagon with no reasons at ALL.

Scooby was the only person voting you when I voted you and I don't recall anyone else attacking you at the time (could be wrong here, correct me if I am).

Amrun then Vash then CO for me but would still like to see more actual content from CO. Mostly just trusting MattP's read on Vash.

[ChaosOmega]

Vash
Amrun
Bitmap/MichelSableheart

Mod: prod for Vash

Amrun: why refuse to post a top 3 scumlist? And you supported the Vash wagon before Shamrock jumped on it. Did Shamrock's vote change your read on Vash?

[Bitmap]

So yeah I'm even LESS keen on the Vash wagon now.

Can we start the CO wagon?

[Vash]

I am around, I just haven't had the time lately. I'm off the next 2 days so I can hopefully devote more tie to this.

[Amrun]

Okay, Shamscum, let's review the sequence of events:

scooby makes a case on me and votes for me in post 224.

In post 226, Bitmap expresses suspicion of me.

post 228, Bitmap votes for me.

MattP at first says I'm a town read, but then retracts that and says I am null.

Then, Quilford posts this:

Amrun was the only one out of the active players who I was getting a scumread on, so I can support a lynch on her.

But I want to catch up first/

And THEN, in post 255, you vote for me, regurgitating scooby's case.

You were clearly riding the momentum towards a bandwagon on me, but you give up as soon as a wagon on Vash crops up. I see only scum motivation in that.

@CO: I didn't "refuse;" I've already posted one far before this, and my top suspicions are extremely obvious. You haven't read the game because you are scum, so you wouldn't know.

[Nexus]

'When the past no longer illuminates the future, the spirit walks in darkness'. - Alexis de Tocqueville

Votecount 1.7:

Vash (5): MattP, Bitmap, Staeg, Shamrock, ChaosOmega
ChaosOmega (3): MichelSableheart, Quilford, IceGuy
MichelSableheart (1): scooby
Amrun (1): DCLXVI
Shamrock (1): Amrun
scooby (1): iDanyboy

Not voting (1): Vash

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch. Deadline is 8am (BST) on the 30th July

iDanyboy has been prodded.

[MattP]

I really hope Vash gets to responding tomorrow.

It's holding the game up since we're on page 15 and he still has no reads really >.>

[Amrun]

MATTP

WHY NOT SHAMROCK

WHYYY

[MattP]

Vash isn't getting off with this play.

[Amrun]

WHAT ABOUT SHAMROCK

[Quilford]

ChaosOmega
iDanyboy
Vash

Less sure on Vash now. Don't like the wagon on him.

[Staeg]

666
Dany
Vash

[MichelSableheart]

@Mod: you're missing Scooby's vote for me in your votecount, and have listed iDany for Scooby twice.

Top suspects:
ChaosOmega
Staeg
DCLXVI

From my extensive meta I just performed on you in the past five minutes, MSH, you are more aggressive in your town meta than you're being here

The extensive meta you performed in five minutes... And you feel that's a better indication then the estimation of a player who observed behaviour for a lifetime? If you had taken the time to come up with some evidence, I might take you more seriously, but this is a completely unfounded statement.

@Scooby: mind explaining why you believe a polite tone is more likely to come from scum then from town?

@Bitmap: If you want a CO wagon, start voting him. There are already 3 others there, so it's not like you would have to build a wagon from scratch.

Can't agree with Amrun's assesment of Shamrock. Post #255 does not look like fencesitting to me. Rather, it expresses clear opinions: a lessened suspicion on Bitmap, strong suspicion towards Amrun, and a clear accusation towards Vash (pretending activity). He accompanied all this with a vote. True, his switch to Vash comes when that bandwagon is gaining speed, but there's nothing wrong with changing your vote to one of your other suspects when there's a bandwagon there.

[iDanyboy]

Requesting replacement

[Nexus]

Fixed the votecount, and searching for a replacement for iDanyboy