History Mafia Mini Theme - 1358 Game Over!

[IceGuy]

It's not that I don't think you have a good reason. It's just that what's good for you isn't good for town.

[Nexus]

MattP, settle down. One and only warning. If I have to warn you again, you're being force replaced.

[MattP]

MattP, settle down. One and only warning. If I have to warn you again, you're being force replaced.

What specifically should I settle down with? Insulting people?

It's not that I don't think you have a good reason. It's just that what's good for you isn't good for town.

You don't even know what my reasoning is, you're just flailing now

[IceGuy]

You don't even know what my reasoning is, you're just flailing now

You're rolefishing scum.

Clear enough?

[Nexus]

MattP, settle down. One and only warning. If I have to warn you again, you're being force replaced.

What specifically should I settle down with? Insulting people?

Read Rule 0. Calling someone an idiot and "literally retarded" is not acceptable behaviour.

[MattP]

You don't even know what my reasoning is, you're just flailing now

You're rolefishing scum.

Clear enough?

OMGUS

Here are the reasons IceGuy is scum

1) He doesn't even know why I'm asking him to roleclaim

2) I as scum would never be bad enough to rolefish and would never do it as town unless I had a damn reason

3) He just flailed from a townread on me to a scumread for doubting his crappy semi-roleclaim

[DCLXVI]

VOTE: ICEguy

I'm not sure why I ever took my vote off him, but this is the lynch that needs to happen.

If you don't think ICEguy is scum then scan quickly through his ISO, that should convince you.

[MattP]

Do you KNOW you are looking for a specific thing in the nameclaim or do you NOT KNOW what you are looking for?

^This question is to be answered and the longer you wait to answer it IceGuy the more shit you're going to get for it.

[Shamrock]

You don't even know what my reasoning is, you're just flailing now

You're rolefishing scum.

Clear enough?

Do you have a reason for thinking this or is this just OMGUS?

[IceGuy]

1) He doesn't even know why I'm asking him to roleclaim

2) I as scum would never be bad enough to rolefish and would never do it as town unless I had a damn reason

So basically, your argument is, "I'm not scum. For reals."

3) He just flailed from a townread on me to a scumread for doubting his crappy semi-roleclaim

Or, you know, I changed my read due to game happenings. In that case, you suddenly deciding you need a fullclaim for basically no reason at all.

^This question is to be answered and the longer you wait to answer it IceGuy the more shit you're going to get for it.

As I said, not revealing anything. I can live with scum voting me for not fullclaiming on Day 1 without a good reason.

Do you have a reason for thinking this or is this just OMGUS?

Yes. The fact that he demanded a fullclaim, on Day 1, out of the blue, without a reason.

---

scumreads:
iceguy
vash
staeg
amrun

DCL: Why did you place Amrun at the bottom of your suspect list?

Because I always put the scummiest people at the bottom when I do reads.

VOTE: ICEguy

I'm not sure why I ever took my vote off him, but this is the lynch that needs to happen.

Explanation?

[MattP]

Or, you know, I changed my read due to game happenings. In that case, you suddenly deciding you need a fullclaim

for basically no reason at all.

WHAT?

[IceGuy]

Or, you know, I changed my read due to game happenings. In that case, you suddenly deciding you need a fullclaim

for basically no reason at all.

WHAT?

I said, FOR BASICALLY NO REASON AT ALL!

[MattP]

You don't know my reasoning yet it's for no reason at all??

[IceGuy]

You don't know my reasoning yet it's for no reason at all??

Well, I know your reasoning. It's something along the lines of "let's see if IceGuy has a PR worth NKing".

[DCLXVI]

Explanation?

Is one really needed?

I had you as a scumread. Your posting in the last 1-2 pages was scummy enough to warrant me moving my vote to you.

[IceGuy]

Is one really needed?

Yes.

I had you as a scumread. Your posting in the last 1-2 pages was scummy enough to warrant me moving my vote to you.

Explain what was scummy about it.

[DCLXVI]

I'm not going to explain why ICE is scummy, his posts are doing that for himself.

[IceGuy]

Unfortunately (for scum), they don't.

[MattP]

Well, I know your reasoning. It's something along the lines of "let's see if IceGuy has a PR worth NKing".

How does answering my question reveal much more about your role? That's really all I need you to answer to figure out what's concerning me.

[IceGuy]

How does answering my question reveal much more about your role? That's really all I need you to answer to figure out what's concerning me.

Giving a comprehensive/correct answer to that question would be equivalent to a fullclaim.

[Staeg]

IG, that was a yes/no question.

[Bitmap]

Ehhh, I'm not so sure if IceGuy is scum to move my vote.

[Amrun]

IceGuy is playing poorly right now, but it's not necessarily indicative of being scum. I've seen him be this intractable as town before.

[Vash]

If it hasn't happened already, please replace me. I'm really sorry I haven't had the time for this guys. I kept thinking there would be time later but I've been too tied up.

[Nexus]

McStab replaces Vash. Thanks to him!