History Mafia Mini Theme - 1358 Game Over!

[IceGuy]

I just can't see anything that could offset that risk.

What possible benefit could counter out that risk?

The answer is none,

which is why I just can't see you as town right now.

The answer is so simple I can't believe a town player would miss it: the mass name claim going through.

And even now that it failed, a doctor could be protecting me, or a watcher watching me.

[Shamrock]

OK, I get that you are saying it is a benefit risk decision.

The risk is obvious, the fact that you have claimed being a pr means you will be dead or role blocked tomorrow, I would be shocked if neither of those things happened.

I just can't see anything that could offset that risk.

What possible benefit could counter out that risk?

The answer is none,

which is why I just can't see you as town right now.

Perhaps IceGuy's role is useless without knowing multiple rolenames. In this case, he has little to lose. Is it really that hard for you to imagine a role which requires knowledge of rolenames in order to be of reasonable utility?

[Shamrock]

N.B. I still think a mass claim is a bad idea, I'm just saying that IceGuy's line of reasoning seems pretty clear.

[Staeg]

Jesus fuck, this thread imploded with stupidity.

If I had a double-dayvig that would kill me and not go through if even one of my targets were town, I'd shoot stabby and 666 in the face and probably live, too.
Stab's posts sound hilariously fake, he replaced vash and his argument vs IG is like 666's except there's more of the same.

So, I could easily be swayed to switch over to stabby.

[DCLXVI]

Jesus fuck, this thread imploded with stupidity.

The paragraph that follows this quote isn't exactly doing much to improve the situation either.

[DeasVail]

IceGuy:

Thoughts on McStab?

[DeasVail]

DCL:

What do you think of MattP?

[IceGuy]

IceGuy:

Thoughts on McStab?

Null so far.

[DeasVail]

Ack, it's actually really close to deadline.

I really want to lynch either Shamrock or Michel. Anyone interested in joining me on one of those two?

[IceGuy]

What do you think about a DCLXVI lynch?

[DeasVail]

I don't think it's terrible because I do think I could be wrong about him and he does seem less reasonable than when I've seen him before. The confidence of his play still seems like town to me though. Is anyone familiar with his scumgame?

[MattP]

I am flailing like a bitch.

I know Vash's meta and I have to keep reminding myself he was scum. Mcstab hasn't exactly been spectacular in play either.

Deas, Mcstab lynch today and DCL tomorrow good plan amirite? I'm pretty damn confident about Vash looking back at his tone.

[DeasVail]

How are you flailing?

Also, why do no I not see any Shamrock or Michel in your post? D:

[MattP]

How are you flailing?

Also, why do no I not see any Shamrock or Michel in your post? D:

I can't decide on a lynch target.

Vash is confscum. Trust me. I should've stuck to my gut initially.

[MattP]

VOTE: Vash

This vote is permaparked til D1 ends.

[MattP]

VOTE: McStab

[DeasVail]

McStab is an ok lynch, but I don't like compromising on lynches

[Amrun]

Too tired to catch up tonight. Tomorrow.

[Shamrock]

I would still prefer an Amrun lynch, obviously, but I feel pretty good about a McStab lynch too - I'm willing to trust MattP's read on Vash, and I really dislike the opportunistic way McStab jumped on the IceGuy wagon who still really doesn't look scummy to me. I'll leave my vote on Amrun for now on the off-chance we can get that wagon going again, but I can switch back to McStab tomorrow if we need it for a majority.

PSA: Remember, deadline is at 8 AM British summer time on July 30, NOT at the end of the day. So we have <29 hours at this point.

[Quilford]

Hi.

VOTE: McStab

^ beautiful lynch

[Quilford]

Okay so we'll wait for Vash to do his post by post analysis because those things are a *goldmine* for fast alignment determination.

Hint: if he ends up not posting one OR he posts a shitty one, he's scum. Nevertheless I itch to vote him because offering a post by post is just typical scum appeasement for lurking.

Then they put the analysis off forever and ask for replacement under the guise of not being able to keep up with the pace of the game.

I get that most people think the analysis sucks, but I am going to finish it. I'll try to be less descriptive.

I am around, I just haven't had the time lately. I'm off the next 2 days so I can hopefully devote more tie to this.

If it hasn't happened already, please replace me. I'm really sorry I haven't had the time for this guys. I kept thinking there would be time later but I've been too tied up.

BAM MOTHERFUCKERS

"Those who do not know history's mistakes are doomed to repeat them." -- George Santayana

okay it's not the exact quote but it's the most game-relevant paraphrase out there

You can thank me later.

[DeasVail]

Why does no one seem to care about Chaos anymore?

[Quilford]

Because he's not here.

Vote McStab if you're not already doing so.

[Bitmap]

Because he's not here.

Vote McStab if you're not already doing so.

Vash was scummy.
McStab just seems to narrow on IceGuy.

I have no problem with this.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: McStab

[DeasVail]

I'd support a mcstab lynch at this stage too.

McStab

Obviously you're today's lynch target so please claim.