History Mafia Mini Theme - 1358 Game Over!

[DeasVail]

And I obviously mean in this game by the way, not outside of this game.

[Staeg]

Umm, I've already claimed

, but

male

just because I'm such a nice townie.

Popcorn Shamrock

What I want to know is, why didn't Michel start things off he wanted it?

Also, I'll ask again, can we please lynch Shamrock instead of me? I'll offer you all special in-game favours?

Where was this?

[DeasVail]

Interesting stuff:

-No one really expressed suspicion of me Day 1 (Scooby was the only one I think?)
-Beginning of Day 2, Shamrock mentions my weak stance on McStab without really trying to push it or attack me. It's merely "Does this look sketchy as fuck to anyone else?" and that's it for his next few posts. No actual effort to try and read me and an example of his cautious (likely) scum play.
-This doesn't actually stick, and it's not until Jarvis comes in that people actually start expressing suspicion of me.

I don't really know what to make of everyone suddenly suspecting me. I feel like there's something significant to learn from it, but I really don't know.

Also, I'm Otto Von Bismark, VT

[Staeg]

Ah, I see - I knew that happened but that didn't have the word "claim" in it so it didn't turn up to my searches :>

[Shamrock]

Sure, ok.

Male, popcorn Bitmap.

[Shamrock]

Actually no that's dumb,

popcorn ChaosOmega

.

[Staeg]

Actually no that's dumb,

popcorn ChaosOmega

.

this is even more dumb as he has already claimed

[Shamrock]

... Right.

Okay,

Bitmap

should go next after all.

[Jarvis]

Still not displaying any genius.

How about you just do the right thing and popcorn Michel?

You know, it's sensible.

[Shamrock]

Well he obviously knows what's being looked for here considering he asked for it.

[Jarvis]

Read his advocacy of it, #993 specifically. Does that look like someone looking for something in particular to you?

(nope)

[Bitmap]

So am I claiming my gender or wat?

[Jarvis]

Yes.

[Bitmap]

Male.

Popcorn to Micheal

Wait... I see where this is actually going...

[MichelSableheart]

Male

Popcorn to MattP

@DV: The wagon on you seems to me to be happening rather mindless, without people actually thinking the situation through. Which is why I'm trying to discuss the more important questions which should be answered first. Deciding who we're going to lynch should only happen after we have actually figured out what's going on.

[MattP]

Male

This is the dumbest popcorn ever. As soon as IceGuy flipped it was obvious that females were bad.

Popcorn to Staeg

[Nexus]

'Horror is the natural reaction to the last 5,000 years of history.' - Robert Anton Wilson

Votecount 3.1:

DeasVail (3): ChaosOmega, Jarvis, MattP
Shamrock (1): DeasVail
ChaosOmega (1): MichelSableheart

Not voting (3): Bitmap, Shamrock, Staeg

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Day 3 ends at 8am on August 28th 2012..

[Bitmap]

I wish we would of listened to IceGuy in the beginning. We could of nailed this game by day 1. I presume Nexus gave all the scum fake role PMs.

[MattP]

I wish we would of listened to IceGuy in the beginning. We could of nailed this game by day 1. I presume Nexus gave all the scum fake role PMs.

I have a wild feeling that scum know that females are mafia. Iceguy did nothing effective but claim cop D1. It was a terrible move and probably worse than the miller fakeclaim.

[Staeg]

I'm male, too.
I'm reasonably sure that the scumteam is 2 females 1 male, but uhh, fakeclaims and all.

[Shamrock]

Well that was a pointless diversion.

Since CO can't suicide, what's the plan?

[MichelSableheart]

Not entirely pointless, it confirms the suspicion of a (mostly) female mafia group.

The plan ought to be to lynch CO.

As for the third member, I think it's either DeasVail or Jarvis.
Shamrock scum with CO and Vash/McStab is unlikely given votecount #334. Both scum bussing by voting immediately after each other without giving any reasoning is a bit farfetched, IMO. Bitmap is a bit of a blind spot for me, but gut town read. Staeg was consistently part of the Vash/McStab attacks, but not in a way that's drawing attention as bussing mafia would do. MattP pulling of a claiming gambit to bus a buddy seems a bit over the top. That leaves Jarvis (Scooby was eerily silent wrt Vash/McStab) and DeasVail (his behaviour wrt McStab could come as easily from scum as from town). Shamrock would be a reasonable candidate for an SK role. Since we can't afford to miss today, CO should be the play, though.

[Staeg]

Let's assume the worst case scenario - He's town. We lynch CO today, get no extra kill tonight and are in 4-2 tomorrow (pretty fucked).
Now, let's assume that he's mafia and lives for today. We lynch someone that could be mafia or SK; worst case, we lynch town. Mafia kill something, SK kills something; worst case, both are town. We are 2-2-1 tomorrow. We lynch CO. It's now 2-1-1 prisoner's dilemma; not too bad.
If he's SK and lives, worst case scenarios (town lynch, double town deaths), it's 2-2-1 and it's gg at that point cause he dies by rope. So, by short, SK-him have to comply and cooperate, shooting whomever we want.
TLDR don't lynch CO today.

These are all worst case scenarios, mind you; it's highly unlikely that all 3 of the deaths will be town.

[Staeg]

The case with him-town surviving is the same as him-SK surviving, btw.

[Shamrock]

Uhhhh if it's 2-2-1 doesn't the mafia win when he is lynched? Am I missing something?