History Mafia Mini Theme - 1358 Game Over!

[Staeg]

If MSH does die and one of DV/MSH have flipped mafia, you can consider lynching someone other than CO. If both are town, lynch CO.

[MattP]

I didn't mean to let them coordinate. Fucking fail.

MY POINT IS THAT EITHER CO IS ANTI TOWN OR I HAVE A NEGATIVE UTILITY ROLE

CO SHOULD BE LYNCHED TODAY, IT'S COMMON FUCKING SENSE.

[MattP]

My mind is set. If you want a DV lynch you are:

A) Dumb
B) Going to have to find the vote elsewhere because I'm not idiotically knowingly throwing the game.

That is all.

[ChaosOmega]

Then you're gonna look mighty foolish if I'm lynched.

And why is it so out of the realm of possibility that the gunsmith is negative utility? You're a JOAT, so all your abilities aren't negative utility.

[MattP]

I have never ever not in the 50 or so mafia games I've played on all my forums received a negative utility role.

[ChaosOmega]

So that means they don't exist?

[MattP]

No, it means you're asking me to trust you when you say that pigs are flying

[MattP]

You should have claimed a non kill role. It's kind of absolutely laughably coincidental that I RBd you the night you didn't have a kill and then you claim a kill role that would imply I have a negative utility role. Really fucking laughable.

[ChaosOmega]

Not really the same, since negative utility roles aren't as absurd as pigs flying. Hell, DCLXVI fakeclaimed one earlier.

What is your worst-case scenario that you see for leaving me alive today? That I'm mafia, I go against killing MSH to kill an obvtown player, and we're at 2-2-1 tomorrow? Then you string me up, it's 2-1-1 going into night, and you put mafia/SK in a tough spot, as they both want to cross-kill but have the other faction kill a townie.

I don't really give a shit what you think or how funny it is to you. I claimed what I claimed because it's my role. The only other person who thinks it's a good idea to lynch me today is MSH, so there's some perspective on how good your idea is.

[MattP]

Of course MSH is chasing you, because MSH is in the opposite anti town faction of you and chasing an anti-town role is the only semblance of authentic scumhunting he can do. I'll let him do that for now, no problem.

I think you're anti-town so why would I pull off? You're trying to throw blinds over the ridiculousness of a situation in which you would be town and it's not going to work.

[MattP]

CO - SK or scum, opposite of MSH

MSH - SK or scum, opposite of CO

DV - scum

Done. Case closed.

[ChaosOmega]

Have you noticed it's hard to type with your head so firmly up your own ass?

[Staeg]

DV - scum

So why not lynch him today on the off-chance that CO is in fact town or SK?

The thing is, we're on even numbers. Even if CO is SK, we want to get odd numbers. So we leave him alive for lynching tomorrow, instead lynching DV. What's the problem here?

[DeasVail]

My mind is set. If you want a DV lynch you are:

A) Dumb

So true.

Why not Shamrock anymore, Matt?

[MattP]

DV - scum

So why not lynch him today on the off-chance that CO is in fact town or SK?

The thing is, we're on even numbers. Even if CO is SK, we want to get odd numbers. So we leave him alive for lynching tomorrow, instead lynching DV. What's the problem here?

Because CO is confirmed anti town unless I have a negative utility role >.< DV is behavior based

My mind is set. If you want a DV lynch you are:

A) Dumb

So true.

Why not Shamrock anymore, Matt?

MSH wins the "trying too hard to be town" award and the "pushing vehemently for an anti-town lynch to feign scumhunting" award and that beats Shamrock, who was pretty town with his reactions to the Vash wagon.

[MattP]

DV, if you actually want to live through the day your wisest move would be to vote CO just sayin

[Staeg]

Matt, read the second paragraph

[MattP]

Because we want odd numbers in a town-scum setup, not in a town-scum-SK setup

[ChaosOmega]

Which this setup isn't, but you go right on ahead and think that.

[Staeg]

No; that only works in case CO is mafia, because if he's SK, he'll work with us anyway.

If he's mafia and we lynch him, we don't get rid of a nightkill, and in any case we get rid of CO-mafia tomorrow if we don't.

[MattP]

It's really funny that you all are trusting a SK to worth with town when he can sway it to a scum or town win. Very fucking funny.

[Bitmap]

Fuck, just fuck.

Leave CO alone and lynch DV or MS or Sham and have CO kill the other guy. We can lynch him tomorrow.

I really don't think MattP is scum for claiming his role like that. Scum points to MS. What motivation would scum have to claim that when that person apparently found a "guilty"?

I pray that Jarvis is town.

[MattP]

GOOD BOY KEEP MIRRORING MY READS ALL YOU HAVE TO DO NOW IS STOP BEING A STUBBORN ASS AND VOTE CO

[Jarvis]

dint worry im town bro

[MattP]

Jarvis, CO vote, use your head