Scummer of Love Invitational: Day 4 - The day the music died

[Brandi]

I'm kinda mad that Llama is leaving.

[MattP]

Thanks babe!

[UberNinja]

UN is a big steaming pile of bloody town

hey bra. no shit

wait you're in this game? FUCK yeah

[Vu]

Day 1, Votecount 14 moo

evilpacman18 (5): Gammagooey, BBmolla, Singer is Nachomamma, ChannelDelibird, Axxle

Axxle (3): xRECKONERx, Katsuki, Wyrd
Glork (2): Mastermind of Sin, Panzerjager
UberNinja (1): chamber
Katsuki (1): evilpacman18
Mastermind of Sin (1): MattP
Panzerjager (1): Brandi
Wyrd (1): UberNinja

Not voting

(1): Glork

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch and 8 to no-lynch.

Deadline:

September 3rd, 2012, at 11:04 PM

Countdown to Deadline:

(expired on 2012-09-03 11:04:00)

[Mastermind of Sin]

There was pressure on MoS earlier but it kind of fell off the face of the Earth

MoS is scum because of his conciseness early D1, he’s choked up, and his later longer posts are very carefully constructed and formal / cut down. Then he has his squabble with Llama where he becomes incredibly abrasive, but that's MoS's strong suit so I generally disregard his assholish behavior as a null tell

Wait. You're saying the following about my play:

1) My early D1 posts were concise (aka short)
2) My later longer posts were very "carefully constructed" and "form", as well as "cut down" (aka short) [how can a longer post also be short?]
3) My squabble with Llama is a null tell.

Which parts of 1 and 2 are you saying makes me scum, and why? How do they relate to one another?

There's more but I'm going to let MattP dig his own hole first.

Also, still good with the Glork vote, but this:

Gamma's post 361 seems like a solid, town motivated case, and one I agree with.

VOTE: evilpacman

Unvote, Vote: Axxle

Weren't you just calling Gamma scum earlier?

[MattP]

Ooo MoS is intentionally trying to create an inconsistency in my statement that doesn't exist

Your longer posts were cut down as in concise and devoid of emotion driven language which does not make them not relatively longer than your even earlier posts but don't worry babe I'll post examples when I get my computer tonight

All your early day one posts suck and read as being afraid to jump into the thread. You throw it away by saying you weren't yet interested but thats bullshit

[MattP]

MoS what were you waiting for me to dig a hole with or was that just you trying to discredit my case by throwing it back at me with no basis

[Axxle]

Weren't you just calling Gamma scum earlier?

Yes, yes I did. I also said:

He says he'll post something soon, so that might change things.

My specific read on him was that he was completely void of town, and therefore scum. But that vote felt town enough to me that I didn't feel bad about sheeping it.

I did something similar with Brandi earlier in the day.

In general, my reads are very much flexible on Day 1 anyway.

[Axxle]

Weren't you just calling Gamma scum earlier?

Yes, yes I did. I also said:

He says he'll post something soon, so that might change things.

My specific read on him was that he was completely void of town, and therefore scum. But that vote felt town enough to me that I didn't feel bad about sheeping it.

I did something similar with Brandi earlier in the day.

In general, my reads are very much flexible on Day 1 anyway.[/quote]

[MattP]

Axxle is town

His sloppy flipflopiness is easy for you all to be vultures about but it's a towntell

[Mastermind of Sin]

Ooo MoS is intentionally trying to create an inconsistency in my statement that doesn't exist

Your longer posts were cut down as in concise and devoid of emotion driven language which does not make them not relatively longer than your even earlier posts but don't worry babe I'll post examples when I get my computer tonight

All your early day one posts suck and read as being afraid to jump into the thread. You throw it away by saying you weren't yet interested but thats bullshit

Have you

seen

me play Day 1 in a regular game before?

[MattP]

I'll look up your meta tonight

[MattP]

Also my loaded question regarding you referencing me digging my own hole was a serious one and I expect an answer

[Mastermind of Sin]

MoS what were you waiting for me to dig a hole with or was that just you trying to discredit my case by throwing it back at me with no basis

If you mean your case has no basis and I'm throwing it back at you, then yes.

Weren't you just calling Gamma scum earlier?

Yes, yes I did. I also said:

He says he'll post something soon, so that might change things.

My specific read on him was that he was completely void of town, and therefore scum. But that vote felt town enough to me that I didn't feel bad about sheeping it.

I did something similar with Brandi earlier in the day.

In general, my reads are very much flexible on Day 1 anyway.

Hmm, k.

Unvote, Vote: Glork

[MattP]

Nope has plenty of basis and you have acknowledged it by defending yourself that this is your regular early game play. That means you know I have a point but disagree with it. Therefore you saying I'm digging a hole by saying it is a LIE AND IT MEANS THAT YOU ARE BLASPHEMOUSLY AND WITH NO FOUNDATION TEARING DOWN MY ARGUMENT AND THROWING IT BACK AT ME WHICH IS A MAJOR INCONSISTENCY IN YOUR TONE AND VERIFIES YOU AS FILTHY CHEEKY LYING SCUMBAG

[MattP]

There's nothing more scummy than calling someone's case wrong and calling the case proposer scummy when you don't think that. You're a fucking filthy liar and baselessly tried to tear down a legitimate case on yourself

[Mastermind of Sin]

Where did I call you scummy?

[MattP]

There was the implication and regardless there would still be a gaping inconsistency in your town regarding you disregarding my post by saying it has no basis and you acting as if it did have a basis. It was a shitty scummy tactic to tear down my case and prevent it from holding any weight

[MattP]

Hey mos if you aren't implying my case is scummy by saying I'm digging a hole for myself what are you implying lol

[MattP]

I MEAN I KNOW YOU'RE SCUM BUT LET'S PLAY

[MattP]

In your tone* not town

[Mastermind of Sin]

There was the implication and regardless there would still be a gaping inconsistency in your town regarding you disregarding my post by saying it has no basis and you acting as if it did have a basis. It was a shitty scummy tactic to tear down my case and prevent it from holding any weight

No, acting like your case has a basis would be trying to explain why I did something that could be a scumtell for me as town. I'm saying that your "case" has absolutely no basis in fact because it doesn't at all outline anything that is remotely a scumtell for me.

Hey mos if you aren't implying my case is scummy by saying I'm digging a hole for myself what are you implying lol

You're digging a hole with a shitty case. I'm just enjoying you making yourself look stupid doing it. That doesn't make you scum automatically. I'm allowed to think idiots can be town, because that's a statistically sound conclusion.

[chamber]

MoS actually is scum this game.

[Mastermind of Sin]

[MattP]

I've officially moved past the Appealing to mosscum stage and have moved into the appeal to everyone else to lynch mosScum stage