Ahh yes you wanted my reads, sure
KOC is town based on the events of last night it seems. It takes me back to my thoughts on day 2 which is that KOC was chosen to be exec because scum might have been worried that one of the two claimed trackers was at risk at checking them night 1 so I'm gonna go back and look over that when I get a chance. Prior to last night he was still mostly town with me, the only way he could be scum is if he was with wrathchild and it was an intended bus for distancing and also making yesterday incredibly repetitive. But I think theshadow flip clears that train of thought.
Strangecoug: for much the same reason is obvious scum based on the events of last night. Prior to last night he didnt jump to the top of my scum lists, I understood the case on him enough to put a vote down but I really was there for pressure and honestly stranger's air of *meh* during yesterday rubbed a small personal gut feel of mine (scum find it easier to play the unconcerned focus of a wagon imo.) not to mention he probably knew well in advance that his buddies were going to bail him out, which raises too many questions.
Quilford: Has been rubbing me wrong the whole game mostly because it constantly feels like he is testing the water to see if he can get a wagon on me, cause he makes a point places a vote and then drops it without follow up when it clearly isnt sticking, I'm annoyed that he went to lynch without getting a chance to defend himself against my questions yesterday. But he had been given ample time to defend himself and hasnt but instead pretty much dug himself deeper, also his attempt to get a judge claim after being hammered looks incredibly dodgy and makes me think that perhaps he got lucky with a guess for the scum power role? (seeing as the judge couldnt be on the jury you can narrow it down)
Ser Panda: Occums razor makes me think town, you've stuck to your guns on not being complicated which makes sense as town, you had a big f*ck up day 1 with your part in the thor debacle, but you've been consistent day 2 & 3 simple pure and dogged. Though you've had a terrible start today, you are trying to draw connections by how little people cross but you are already running into the problem with doing that in a large game. You say I could be linked to strangercoug because we never really crossed (except when he voted me day 1 of course) but then you use the same logic for wrathchild and strangercoug. But me and wrathchild have butted heads so if you are tying all 3 of us together whats the reason we have both avoided strangercoug but not wrathchild and myself? That's faulty logic there. I'd say you are town probably, but it's the faulty logic
DCLXVI: plays like ser panda without the ego or drama, straight simple and dogged so clearly town
Aurorusvox: I like you better now that it's just you and not the hydra, you are much more consistent and much like DCLXVI is one of my more sure town reads
Nocmen: Mostly null, clearly MOS trusted him (and MOS was my third clear town read of the game) and I will continue to trust his judgement. But wrathchild's most recent post is an interesting theory. But a theory at best.
Wrathchild: null, though his stubborness leans me town. His new theory is a fine line between clever scum ploy to lynch a townie cleared by the judge or genius working out how scum are rigging the system. I'll need to watch things to see where the penny drops.
Gooner/Bloodcovenent: Oh this one is so close to scummy, constantly playing a ignorance card and claiming it as a reaction test or some garbage, only the fact that bloodcovenent is going through the whole game pulls me back. I'll like to see bloodcovenents full thoughts before I act on this slot.
Doomyoshi: Maybe it's the similar post number and post sizes etc, but doomyoshi hits a straight null with me because his posting/thought process is so close to mine, I wouldnt say there is anything that screams town to me, but he seems to be asorbing everything the same way as me. My only issue with him is some of his wagon choices seem very questionable (thor day 1 and nocmen day 2)
Axelrod: Null slight scum lean, this is one of those crafty players where you think he could be scum because of how well he seems to be able to read the events of the game and digest them, really hints at being in the know more then your average player. I originally thought it was because of his power role, but it coming out as a dud makes me question it and the slot.
Vijayassassin/Greyice: blah mostly, Grey ice is stirring things up which is nice, vijay I've played with a few times so I know he can be a low poster even as town so I'm gonna say null.
My only problem with Grey Ice is his position on Guile
Cause Guile is probably as of today my strongest town read just for consistent playing (Aurorusvox and DCLXVI being my other 2)
So from towniest to scummiest:
Guile
DCLXVI
Ausorusvox
KOC
Nocmen
Ser Panda
wrathchild
Vijayassassin/Greyice
Doomyoshi
Axelrod
Gooner/Bloodcovenent
Quilford
Strangecoug
Will post my votes in a later post tonight (or tomorrow morning) after I think a bit more about where best to put them to use.
