Judge, Jury, and Executioner - Over

[Ser Panda]

5

maybe four

actually four makes the most sense.

and yeah I'm totally sure the scum are in Av guile bastion wrathchild SC.

And I like the fact that we've lynched two of them and one more is on the way

Expand on this please. Why are you so sure there is scum in that group?

I have townreads on everyone else

[Ser Panda]

5

maybe four

actually four makes the most sense.

and yeah I'm totally sure the scum are in Av guile bastion wrathchild SC.

And I like the fact that we've lynched two of them and one more is on the way

Expand on this please. Why are you so sure there is scum in that group?

you don't think there's scum in this group?

[WrathChild]

I never said that. I'm asking you to expand.

[Ser Panda]

And I'm asking you If you think there's scum in that list or not.

[WrathChild]

And I'm asking you If you think there's scum in that list or not.

Answer my question first you sidestepping panda!

[Ser Panda]

5

maybe four

actually four makes the most sense.

and yeah I'm totally sure the scum are in Av guile bastion wrathchild SC.

And I like the fact that we've lynched two of them and one more is on the way

Expand on this please. Why are you so sure there is scum in that group?

I have townreads on everyone else

I already did

[Ser Panda]

comeon wrathchild.

you disappeared on me day4 when I asked you about sirbastion.

don't go all quiet on me again.

there are 4 people there excluding you.

How is it that you're always so clueless as to who scum are?

[Sir Bastion]

Can someone explain precisely what the case on Sir Bastion is? Because I haven't seen a whole lot from him that's particularly offensive. Would go for an AVox or a Nocmen lynch if I had any votes left.

Pedit: mostly because of the complete non-entity that is AVox only popping up to make useless posts like the above

No interaction with strangercoug.

As you already had shot yourself in the foot with this because that same logic can be applied to other players in this game (If I remember correctly you pointed out Wrathchild also has no interaction with SC) so really this isnt much.

placed a vote on him when I called for his lynch. I was expecting

one person

to bus strangercoug and this guy was it.

except now you are claiming there were 2 scum bussing him, since guile was also on that wagon. So you might need to rethink the sc wagon. Considering that scum knew they could keep sc alive via exe and that the power roles involved were dead or spent at this point perhaps the traditional notion of bussing is not applicable here.

very little effort for catching scum.

At this point I'm pretty sure you can say the town as a whole is making little effort. I'd like to think I've been consistent, may not be spectacular but everything I have observed I've followed as far as I can. Some may have been regrettably wrong (Quilford) but I have had reasons and logic to all my actions in this game.

got shadow lynched.

fcking misrep of the highest order

Shadow self hammered, no one saw that coming!!! You cannot blame me for that, even if I was scum I would have to be fcking psychic to see that coming.

now is going after another Powerrole.

Yes the claimed power role who seems to be ignoring what his own power role is telling him on the issue of nocmen and you. We have a clear case of different results for 2 players that suppose to have made the same action and instead of coming down on one side or the other (nocmen was pardoned or you are scum) we have had a player that has painfully jumped through hoops to explain away the conflicting results so that he doesnt have to go against the majority or go against you.

And I'm the one scummy for thinking the whole thing is bollocks and blood has just trapped himself in a corner?

His defence boils down to *I dont think it works that way* and we know how much of a steller record he has for knowing how *his* role works.

[Ser Panda]

fcking misrep of the highest order

Shadow self hammered, no one saw that coming!!! You cannot blame me for that, even if I was scum I would have to be fcking psychic to see that coming.

nope you were the reason he got lynched

I made an uproar about you and defender as soon as it happened.

Av saved you that day.

not today.

[Ser Panda]

As you already had shot yourself in the foot with this because that same logic can be applied to other players in this game (If I remember correctly you pointed out Wrathchild also has no interaction with SC) so really this isnt much.

Are you trying to get Wrathchild lynched?

nope.

stop calling the logic crap.

its one of the tells that you're scum.

just because someone else is also ignoring that person you want me to ignore the fact that you're ignoring strangercoug?

And Wrathchilds on the list also btw.

[Ser Panda]

except now you are claiming there were 2 scum bussing him, since guile was also on that wagon. So you might need to rethink the sc wagon. Considering that scum knew they could keep sc alive via exe and that the power roles involved were dead or spent at this point perhaps the traditional notion of bussing is not applicable here.

hmm...

actually I think there were three scum bussing him today.

But that day your vote was the obvious bus

[Ser Panda]

Yes the claimed power role who seems to be ignoring what his own power role is telling him on the issue of nocmen and you. We have a clear case of different results for 2 players that suppose to have made the same action and instead of coming down on one side or the other (nocmen was pardoned or you are scum) we have had a player that has painfully jumped through hoops to explain away the conflicting results so that he doesnt have to go against the majority or go against you.

And I'm the one scummy for thinking the whole thing is bollocks and blood has just trapped himself in a corner?

His defence boils down to *I dont think it works that way* and we know how much of a steller record he has for knowing how *his* role works.

Hes so fucking obviously town.

Do you really believe that blood as scum pulled off a ballsy gambit like that to get me lynched and then backed out in the end?

[Ser Panda]

If not blood then who Sirbastion.

give me some more names.

or do you think strangercoug and blood are the only scum in the game?

[DoomYoshi]

Uh, Sir Bastion... you know that scum aren't supposed to rigorously defend themselves late game?

I would give you another vote, but that brings to L-1

[StrangerCoug]

I'm sorry. I missed the memo. Why is Nocmen scum again?

haha
this scumbag trying to get you guys to lynch nocmen

This is backwards. Asking for a case on someone is in no way pushing for that person's lynch; in fact, I can't be doing the pushing until I have my answer.

Scum can only save one scum, the other has to die. So if we get two scum as defendants we get at least one dead scum.

OK, that's where I'm messing up. I was reading "should" as a suggestion to the deciders instead of as "probably will".

yeah sure. That was your intention. I believe you.

No. Seriously. Why does it make any sense at all to conclude from my posts that I want Nocmen dead?

Can someone explain precisely what the case on Sir Bastion is? Because I haven't seen a whole lot from him that's particularly offensive.

Sir Bastion's case on BloodCovenant is crap. I get more that SB views BC as a threat than legitimately scummy.

[IceGuy]

Vote Count

Sir Bastion (5): StrangerCoug, Ser Panda, AurorusVox, Axelrod, DoomYoshi

Nocmen (3): AurorusVox, AurorusVox, WrathChild
Ser Panda (3): Nocmen, guille2015, guille2015
AurorusVox (1): Axelrod
BloodCovenent (1): Sir Bastion
DCLXVI (1): DoomYoshi
DoomYoshi (1): Axelrod

7

votes are currently not on a player.

guille2015 (7): BloodCovenent, BloodCovenent, Ser Panda, Knight of Cydonia, Knight of Cydonia, StrangerCoug, StrangerCoug
StrangerCoug (7): Sir Bastion, Sir Bastion, BloodCovenent, guille2015, Ser Panda, Knight of Cydonia, DCLXVI

Every player has

3

votes.
With

12

alive, it's

7

to hammer.
There are

36

votes in play,

14

of which are frozen, leaving

22

votes active.

Deadline is October 9th, 10 a.m. CEST.

[AurorusVox]

Doom why don't you want a scumread of yours at l-1?

[DoomYoshi]

I want to play out the deadline. I realize all the scummies are trying to slow the pace to a crawl, but if the townies counteract by making the day as long as possible, we will get the same amount of discussion.

[AurorusVox]

Slow, long, drawn-out games are detrimental to town as they actually make it harder to keep track of reads over a lengthy time frame, fracture discussion as people only rock up to post once in a while, and increase player apathy.

[Knight of Cydonia]

I think we need to get more posting done before we settle on the last lynch. Too many people who haven't voted today and haven't contributed enough either.

[StrangerCoug]

I want to play out the deadline. I realize all the scummies are trying to slow the pace to a crawl, but if the townies counteract by making the day as long as possible, we will get the same amount of discussion.

This sounds completely counter-intuitive. Wouldn't the scum slowing down the pace already be making the day longer?

[IceGuy]

BloodCovenent and Nocmen have been prodded.

[AurorusVox]

Unvote: Nocmen x2

Vote: DarthYoshi x2

This is what you have all been waiting for.

[DoomYoshi]

I'm not darth. And this isn't what I have been waiting for.

[BloodCovenent]

Didn't realize it's been that long since i've posted, i'll get something up real fast.