Well, you can just be called confirmed town, simply because it's N1, scum have no knowledge of the setup, and from the look of it, it's most likely a newb/newb scum team, so I doubt they'd no-kill.
↑ JohnnyFarrar wrote:I'm a VT.
I'm going to wait to make judgement until the rest of the claims happen. A wagon on the guy who's been everyone's constant throbbing townread makes me raise an eyebrow.
Thing is, everyone's constant throbbing townread can just as easily be scum. Here's my previous newbie game, which I think shows that pretty clearly: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=22634. I even read in another topic that someone who read along was just as sold on the fact that I was town as the players in the game. I already got a creeping feeling yesterday that that was the case with Dog too, and Pasch's claim only confirms that for me.
Where did this suddenly come from? You don't seem like you're buying Pasch's reasoning on Dog, so why vote him now, putting him at L-1?
Jason wrote:
nhammen wrote:
Note: this means that our Doc is confirmed town. Also, his protects are pseudo-confirmed (for us to not be confirmed, scum had to have intentionally chosen to no-kill even with no knowledge of a Doc in the setup).
I honestly don't think we should totally confirm the doc saves just in case there was a no kill, assuming that they attempted a kill N1 (which is most likely tbh) they may have risked being the doc's protect N2 for the WIFOM to seem confirmed.
This just makes you look like scum most likely being caught by a PR-claim and trying to talk your way out of it, by discrediting the claim as much as possible. Nhammen is confirmed for me at least, because of reasons given above. Rudi is a bit more debatable, but I'm getting a good feeling about him being confirmed as well.
VOTE: JasonWazza
Your whole reaction to Pasch's claim is looking terrible so far.
↑ Cheery Dog wrote:looking near the end of day 1, I see I followed Jason onto the counter wagon to ewo of Wiibox, and then as Rudi was replacing in I was attacking city and changed to that counter-counter wagon which died.
I realise this is going back to probability again, however I am seriously doubting that both members of the scum team would be able to avoid votes outside of the early stages of a newbie game.
Why are you doubting that?
Cheery Dog wrote:
Today is the first time I have been voted.
Johnny & Jason were only voted by ewo after they had replaced in. (one of which was by mistake).
This leaves me to suspect City is on the scumteam since she gathered some votes under her own stream.
VOTE: CityElectric
and since I know I am town, this game is a instant win by lynching city, jason and johnny in any order.
And that's bullshit. Because I gathered votes on D1, I'm scum? Also, you may know you're town, but we don't. And you're not exactly convincing me right now. Of course this game is an instant win if you lynch all the non-comfirmed players, but for who is it an instant win? I know I'm town too and that if I lynch you, Jason and Johnny, I'll win. Simple. However, if I were scum, and lying about my townieness, lynching you, Jason and Johnny in any order, would also be an instant win, especially if you're trying for a mis-lynch today.