NY 160: Terrible Melodrama Mafia (Game Over)

[DeasVail]

Vote Count 1.08

JacobSavage (6)- Plan B, DoomYoshi, Toon Fighter, theamatuer, PiggyGal15, RedCoyote
PiggyGal15 (5)- Cletus+Brandine, Untrod Tripod, adorkable, 4nxi3ty, Demon Core
Cletus+Brandine (2) JacobSavage, N
Senjai (1)- Nero Cain

Not voting: Senjai

With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.

Prods

theamatuer

V/LA

Half of adorkable- Until the 8th

Deadline

14th November, 6am AEDT

[Demon Core]

Who on his wagon is scum then? Yes it's possible, but it could very well be poor scum play as well, I wouldn't count that out.

Piggygal, Red Coyote, and possibly amateur.

Even without amateur, that 1/3 of the wagon. 1/3

Compare to the piggywagon which has... maybe one questionable character (adorkable). I like the piggy wagon composition a lot better, and it baffles me that you're arguing the opposite, Senjai.

N why don't you have a vote on JS or Piggy? They have the consensus that at least one of them are scum. Are you trying to take attention away from them?

Nah, it's because he's scum and he's avoiding wagons altogether.

Reads for posterity:

Town: anxiety, cletus, sanjai, toonfighter, plan b, jacob
Scum: Piggy, Red Coyote, N, Nero Cain
Everyone else on the spectrum of null

[adorkable]

had a busy weekend, more content tonight or tomorrow (probably tomorrow)

other head still isn't caught up (as previously stated) but at least she's been skimming

[Cletus+Brandine]

Catching up...

So piggy finally reappears and still has a bunch of weak sauce nullish reads. When challenged, she suddenly comes up with a really strong scum read on jacob (the other large wagon).

Lolkay

That was ridiculously opportunistic and does not fit with any of her other behavior.

[Cletus+Brandine]

Hi RC. As senjai, I'm expecting good reasons for moving my vote to piggy. But, for what I've seen so far, I'd be happy to put my vote on her..

Plus, what is the reasoning for the mini Cletus wagon?

I blame Jacob. He's the source... so, ya know.

[Cletus+Brandine]

Red Coyote entrance: his analysis didn't ping my scumdar.

[Senjai]

I'm not disagreeing with you at all DC. I believe both are scum. I however just think if it were my choice, I'd lynch JSscum over Piggyscum that's all. I was simply trying to understand yours and everybody elses thoughts as to why piggy would be a larger and more important target than JS. What about C+B along with adorkable? They were considered by some to be opportunistic as well.

[Senjai]

It can be possible JS is VI. I'll be satisfied I guess at what a Piggy lynch would tell us.

VOTE: Piggy[/b]

[Senjai]

EBWOP: VOTE: Piggy EPIC FAIL... its 4:45 am here at this time.. lol.

[Senjai]

I wanna hear more from UT, PB, and my favorite (theoneandonly Nero Cain) before a lynch happens though.

[Plan B]

I'm back from V/LA, but not up to speed.

Later today I'll get caught up.

[theamatuer]

prodded.
Will reread the thread. Still think Js> piggy

[DoomYoshi]

Also, we find out a lot about C+B.

Let's just say for a second you are 100% correct. Lynching JS lets us know about Nero.
However, by that same logic, lynching piggy lets us know about C+B, but also (to a lesser extent) JS.

What would we find out about C+B by lynching Piggy?

We would find some clues to answer this question:

C+B, why are you trying to tie piggy to jacob before a flip?

prodded.
Will reread the thread. Still think Js> piggy

Is this before or after reread? Are you caught up to date? Curious all-around answer.

Thanks for making me recall UT Senjai. I did an ISO. Not good.

With this vote, piggy is at

L-1

.
UNVOTE:
VOTE: Piggy

The Anxiety scumread gets dropped entirely (town tend to at least address gut reads, they don't tend to ignore them).

I didn't even notice that. Curious.

[PiggyGal15]

You know, typically when someone does a re-read, especially when the first time reading they weren't paying attention at all, their reads are going to change. I was reading Anxiety's posts with the wrong feeling to them, which made me feel they were scummy, re-reading, I read them... properly I suppose ? and didn't get that same scummy feeling from them.

Demon, look at what that "scumslip" is. How did I "invent" it? It's not like I put words into Jacob's mouth.

For god's sake, no one hammer me without stating intent first -_-' if you do, and you're town, I will blacklist your ass for life. Cause that's just ridiculous.

[4nxi3ty]

piggy i suggest you claim or give last reads.

if i die tonight i would suspect doom yoshi.

[Toon Fighter]

intent to hammer piggy. claim now or die in obscurity

[Cletus+Brandine]

I really don't get this scumslip business that piggy is talking about...

[PiggyGal15]

Mkay, I'm a watcher.

Quote of first post removed.
-DV

[PiggyGal15]

O.o what just happened? That, my friends, is why you don't post on your phone xD

Mod, mind fixing my last post?

[JacobSavage]

I for one actually believe piggy's claim, I mean she will probably be dead by the morning but she might have something interesting to tell us if she survives.

[Demon Core]

Mkay, I'm a watcher.

X

Wrong answer.

Hammer this fool, jacob.

[Demon Core]

Red Coyote entrance: his analysis didn't ping my scumdar.

It should've.

"I'm not ouching this piggy wagon even though it objectively looks better, so I'm going for mislynch bait JacobSavage and make up a bunch of crap reasons for joining his wagon."

[DeasVail]

Prodding Nero Cain.

[Toon Fighter]

meh, willing to believe for today. if she's telling the truth, she's likely dead tomorrow, if she's still alive, we'll evaluate her investigation and proceed from there. Now, anyone want to lynch JS?

[PiggyGal15]

Mkay, I'm a watcher.

X

Wrong answer.

Hammer this fool, jacob.

If people start lynch claimed PRs, with no counterclaims, I'm honestly going to stop playing mafia.