Open 459: There is a New Scum in Town. Game Over Town Wins!

[RachMarie]

Like NS I too am sick Though I am still up in Hayward. I will use the cattle prod on the ones who are not posting. Thank you Mala for posting an unofficial count, I will in the morning post an official one.

[Majiffy]

That's what you get for kissing sick people.

[Nobody Special]

I never kissed... oh, wait.

[Majiffy]

HA

Spoiler:

!

[Fe]

I'm back sorry been a little busy over the past free days
firstly, Vote counts = easy and quick , analysis =hard and long.

Secondly those were my notes, why do I have to be serious. If it seems to not make sense then its probably not intentionally serious. e.g. why would being familiar with the songs of Seal be a town tell....

[Kmd4390]

so did deadline already pass or was it extended at some point?

[RachMarie]

Vote Count 1.7


Fe (5) the director, uctriton00, Majiffy, penguin_alien, Nobody Special
Number Six (2) Breakfast, Fe
Fizz (6) Number Six, Kmd4390, Lastsuvivor, Malakittens, Borkjerfkin, pirate mollie (L-2)


Not Voting

Fizz





With 14 it takes 8 to lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2012-12-01 16:09:23)

With the possibility of having to replace 2 players I will consider a deadline extension. I have given them the ol Cattle Prod we will see if they respond or not. Plus I have fallen behind on VCs with being on V/LA

I want to give you all Kudos for doing so well on keeping track of things ♥ Rach

[Majiffy]

Secondly those were my notes, why do I have to be serious.

Kill it with fire.

[Lastsurvivor]

I'm back sorry been a little busy over the past free days
firstly, Vote counts = easy and quick , analysis =hard and long.

Secondly those were my notes, why do I have to be serious. If it seems to not make sense then its probably not intentionally serious. e.g. why would being familiar with the songs of Seal be a town tell....

Not every post in the game is a novel. Analysis is not "hard and long." My next two statements are analysis. I do not believe your rationale for making that VC was that it was quicker than analysis. I think you did it because you wanted to look like you were contributing something.

See. It's not so hard, and took maybe twenty seconds.

Secondly, I agree with that it's quite strange that you called that a town tell. So why did you do it? Why didn't you say "Ohoho, u so funny/clever for decoding those lyrics #6"? Why did you give him town points?

Oh, and you've still ignored my request to synthesize and give some reads.

Considering switching my vote but I really don't wanna let Fizz off the hook. <_<

[Majiffy]

Vote Fe and I'll look at Fizz tomorrow. We have scummier scum to lynch.

[pirate mollie]

Secondly those were my notes, why do I have to be serious.

Kill it with fire.

fine.

VOTE: fe

[Antihero]

Hello. I'm your back-up mod. I'll do a vote count on every new page if Rach doesn't beat me to it, and if I see a lynch, I'll post a flip.

-Antihero

[uctriton00]

randomly ISOing borker and saw a question addressed to me:

Requesting to replace out is a chance to get away from your scum games. Basically when you get into a future game, someone can say "can you link me to a completed game where you were scum", you can plausibly not even link to the replaced-out game since they said "completed game".

[Kmd4390]

^that's kind of BS and very cheap play if someone is really doing that.

Also, once the game is completed, it is still a completed game.

[borkjerfkin]

randomly ISOing borker and saw a question addressed to me:

Requesting to replace out is a chance to get away from your scum games. Basically when you get into a future game, someone can say "can you link me to a completed game where you were scum", you can plausibly not even link to the replaced-out game since they said "completed game".

Replacing out as scum so they'll not have a chance to be meta'd as scum in the future? This makes no sense to me, because you're suggesting that someone would both 1) replace out purely because they rolled scum and 2) not replace out of every scum game for this reason, just some of them.

I'm not sure where your head is at here.

[borkjerfkin]

You get town points for answering the question at all, honestly, since I think it's pretty evident I'd forgotten I even asked it.

[Kmd4390]

Why is that town points?

Think about it. You are scum and have someone's ISO up. You see a question directed at you. Is your first instinct not "oh shit I never answered that."?

The fact that he answered is pretty null really.

[borkjerfkin]

*shrug* I asked that question almost two weeks ago and never followed up on it once it didn't get answered. I think that's a pretty safe indicator for him to have ignored it if he had desired to.

[Kmd4390]

Not if you were doing some kind of re-read and noticed it before him.

[borkjerfkin]

Point noted. Not worth arguing about.

[Kmd4390]

K.

[pirate mollie]

(((kmd)))

[borkjerfkin]

?

[Nobody Special]

I like my vote where it is, but will switch near deadline if necessary.

[Lastsurvivor]

Vote Fe and I'll look at Fizz tomorrow. We have scummier scum to lynch.

Huh. Alright.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Fe

THIS IS L-1

------

Uct, by the logic of #437, when someone dies in a game, they can't link to it because they died before its completion?