Open 459: There is a New Scum in Town. Game Over Town Wins!

[the director]

Majiffy give me one good reason why penguin isn't scum.

[Majiffy]

Because his role PM doesn't say scum.

[the director]

That's what I thought.

[Majiffy]

Well if that's what you thought, then why are you willing to hammer him?

[Majiffy]

Logical conclusion: You're scum.

[Nachomamma8]

Logical conclusion: You're scum.

"that's what he thought" as in he figured you didn't have a good reason for thinking penguin wasn't scum.

[the director]

Wow. You weren't able to come up with a real reason why penguin is town, you call her "him", and you attempt to spin it into me being scum. Conclusion, you are drunk. Noted.

[the director]

PEDIT dammit nacho stop trying to steal thunder.

[Majiffy]

Wow. You weren't able to come up with a real reason why penguin is town, you call her "him", and you attempt to spin it into me being scum. Conclusion, you are drunk. Noted.

1) It is a real reason.
2) Everyone is a guy on the internet.
3) You are scum.
4) Sober, but ok.

Logical conclusion: You're scum.

"that's what he thought" as in he figured you didn't have a good reason for thinking penguin wasn't scum.

Oh wow I couldn't figure that out myself thanks for clearing that up.

[the director]

Majiffy finally showing his true colors ladies and gentlemen. Let's give him a round of applause.

Son, unless you get your brain out of neutral, you are going to be lynched. Give a reason why penguin isn't scum. It is that simple.

[Majiffy]

His role pm doesn't say scum. That is a reason, and it is real.

[the director]

Yeah so sad that penguin is now the wagon I'm going to push with all my fury since you can't formulate a defense for your buddy. Let's hear from penguin:

*crickets*

*crickets*

Oh.

[Majiffy]

Yes I am scum and instead of just bussing my partners like I always do I'm going to defend him with "his role pm isn't scum".

Bravo. You, sir, are the greatest and best scumhunter in all the land.

[the director]

I'm actually just wasting time until the field comes around to lynching you. Let's follow the meta here broski ... long bus the weakest link, then no kill, then parley that into future town lynches. What step are we at again?

Until town gets their shit in order and keeps pretending they actually have a voice, the real battle is between whether we lynch me or Majiffy. The war starts now. Today's lynch will be either me or Majiffy. Place your bets, folks.

[Majiffy]

What "meta" exactly are you talking about?

[the director]

last game we played together.

[Majiffy]

448?

[penguin_alien]

Nachomamma8, I'm not seeing where my vote on Fe came at a time when a Fe lynch was inevitable. Looking over the thread, between when I voted and when the hammer was placed, ten days passed. Even at the hammer vote, there were still votes on Fizz, which meant some people thought he was more likely to be scum than Fe. Just because Fe ended up as my top scum read doesn't mean I can't find anyone else scummy. And what if we'd been wrong, and Fe had been town playing badly? Why not attempt to elicit information? In the meantime, there was Fizz, whose posts improved just enough for people to stop voting him, and then he vanishes? Go look at his ISO, and then read the reactions to his last content-containing post, and tell me this is an inaccurate characterization of the situation. At the time there was no way to know he'd (as far as I can tell as of now) gone away completely.

In #407, there wasn't much of anything to comment on WRT Fe since my vote post in #389, as activity had died off in the three days that passed between those two points. I had no further arguments against Fe at the time that were new from what I'd made or what other people had said. And in #467, do you really think I was trying to derail the Fe wagon when he was at L-1 and had claimed, and someone was ready to hammer at the time and was only waiting to see if Fe posted final reads?

Kmd4390, my post was my attempt to sort out what reasons people have for voting you. Same goes for my take on uctriton00. I see some scummy activity from your slot, but there's nothing that gels together to make me want to lynch you more than Nobody Special. WRT that, if someone wants to tell me what their counter-argument is to my scum read on Nobody Special is, I'm all ears.

the director, yes, I posted a few hours after you hammered Lastsurvivor. So? That's when I happened to be on the computer and able to catch up on this game--I'd been planning on checking if/what Lastsurvivor's response to my previous post was, and I'll admit to being irritated to find it rendered moot in a way that gave the town minimal information. And I am not seeing at all where I 'appeared out of thin air' after you mentioned me this day phase. If you're talking about me posting my V/LA, for what very little it's worth, I finished my holiday preparations, signed on, and posted my V/LA message for the holiday in all my active games (see completed game Newbie 1304 for a reference point I'm allowed to cite under the site rules; sorry about mentioning Newbie 1292 earlier; I thought it was OK to point there for my personal meta since I'd died, but mea culpa; will not make that mistake in the future). I will cop to clicking 'First unread post' in this game, since I hadn't been on since the day phase opened and would have felt pretty dumb telling people I was V/LA when I was actually dead.

[buldermar]

I think the kmd lynch would be a good idea. I think that uct is probably town cos of how petulant he sounded cos kmd is addressing me and ignoring him. I think penguin is town.

majiffy is a hardcore busser. I think he attempted to bus kmd from the get go in order to gain town cred on finding scum amongst a really good player. how do I know this? cos he has said this and he bussed me and got caught out in the recent tr game which only implicated himself. he switched to fe when kmd showed resistance and he is not giving a read on kmd now he is merely wanting to vote him based off of that 1 post. majiffy screams about cases but wants kmd lynched with not remembering why he had him as scum in the first place.

I think a scumkmd will directly point to majiffy.

That game is still ongoing, so you probably should not talk about it.

I agree with you, though.

no, it had just ended when I posted this. our last scum begged the gm to kill her off. raven has been wanting to catch me out as scum forever and she never could until now. grrrrr......

I apologize. Yeah, raven was a God in that game.

[Majiffy]

I don't want to talk about it. It never happened.

[buldermar]

in combination with him defending viable counterwagons (Maenara) and pushing counterwagons that really aren't viable (bork)

Which posts do you have in mind?

Two of them should be obvious.

Alright. I wasn't trying to be obnoxious, I just don't have much time available and the way you phrased it sounded like you had specific posts in mind.

[buldermar]

2) That's great, you're also wrong a lot.

So are you.

[Majiffy]

2) That's great, you're also wrong a lot.

So are you.

Yeah, but when I'm right, I'm

really

right.

[buldermar]

2) That's great, you're also wrong a lot.

So are you.

Yeah, but when I'm right, I'm

really

right.

You're truely adorable when you're in your obtuse corner.

[buldermar]

Majiffy, why is my alignment related to that of uct?