Meta Playstyle Mafia(Game Over, Town Wins!)

[Nachomamma8]

well toog and maestro and lurker are pretty much conf. town.

[MattP]

matt, if chk rolls in and explicitly claims a guilty, then i'll explain
otherwise, there's no need

You have to explain before he does because:

A) his role is obv more important
B) You should be locked into a claim over him so you cant tailor your claim

CHKFLIP, DONT RESPOND TO NACHO'S EXPLANATION WITH A CLAIM. IF HIS CLAIM COVERS FOR YOUR INFO SAY SO, IF IT DOESNT THEN SAY SO, BUT DONT ACTUALLY CLAIM

matt, if chk rolls in and explicitly claims a guilty, then i'll explain
otherwise, there's no need

You have to explain before he does because:

A) his role is obv more important
B) You should be locked into a claim over him so you cant tailor your claim

Matt, If you're on right now, can you give a quick catchup/highlight?

I'm about to head to sleep, but in a nutshell:

Day 1 Events

1) We start with a lot of meta talk about who would be town who would be scum. Mehdi and I start leading town for the most part
*) Forgot this point so I'm adding it after the fact. I claimed 1-shot lightning rod, able to absorb all actions for one night in the game. I have yet to use it
2) Bitmap claims miller
3) I start tunneling Mehdi. Bitmap and Om join the wagon, followed by Venmar and Toog
4) Lurker CCs miller
5) We all pretty much agree Trollie is scum, trollie fence sits on a Mehdi lynch and pretty much cant make a single post that doesn't seem scummy and like blatant buddying to Mehdi
6) Mehdi is at L-1 and claims 2-shot daycop
7) We all argue over who Mehdi should daycop. Nacho immediately suggests Trollie, which I call him out for because Trollie is obvscum and is a much weaker scum player than Mehdi, so scum would love to throw Trollie under the bus to save Mehdi, seemed like opportunistic crap that was a shitty, nonsensical way to utilize a daycop from town perspective. Interestingly, Nacho has ignored any future discussion about this matter
8) Toog claims his role would confirm wether or not Mehdi is a daycop if Mehdi targets him
9) Mehdi says he will but he is hammered even though only 10 votes were on him (11 were needed)
10) Day 1 ends

~~~~~

Day 2 Events

Here's when a lot of confirmed roles start popping up

1) Chkflip immediately votes Nacho D2, implementing that he has info that Nacho is scum
2) We all start piling on Nacho and Trollie
3) Trollie continues lol'ing up the thread
4) Maestro claims 2-shot oracle, that asked how many millers there are in-game. There is only one, showing that either Lurker or Bitmap is lying
5) Bitmap takes back his claim admitting he is a DV'ing Survivor (this practically confirms Maestro as town and absolutely confirms Lurker as town)
6) Maestro asks his second question, which is how many anti-town factions there are in the game. He receives the answer, "two", meaning there is only one scumteam and Bitmap.
7) Om insists we have to kill Bitmap because Om is a role that can take over the role of another player that is dead IF two anti-town players are lynched in a row and Bitmap is confirmed non-town
8) Toog claims essentially an innocent child and even quotes his PM, confirming him as town
9) Roflcopter is only posting votes and fos's insinuating a post restriction
10) VM has claimed a post restriction too, look in his ISO
11) Maenera has been very scummy too, look her up
12) GNR fence sat a lot on Mehdi D1, look that up, pretty scummy
13) Nacho is now claiming he may have an explanation for chk's info on him

My reads if you want some directions

1. ArcAngel9 -town

2. Maestro -conftown

3. Guy_Named_Riggs -scummy

4. Bitmap -3rd party

5. PeregrineV –null, hi

6. Roflcopter –scummy

, possibly faking post restriction because his restriction is bastard since it doesn’t allow him to post content

7. TAM- null-town

but people think he's scum so you should look at him yourself

8. Lurker -conftown

9. MattP -town

10. Maenara -scum

11. Elmo TeH Anz -town
12. Om of the Nom -town

13. SoraAdvent –null and should be replaced/prodded (MOD)

14. Chkflip -town

15. TheTrollie -scum

16. Voidedmafia -town
18. Venmar -town

19. Nero Cain -scummy

20. Toogeloo -conftown

21. Nachomamma8 -scum

[MattP]

i know that he is lying for another reason that has nothing to do with my role
i'm not asking him to claim. all he has to say is "yes. i am claiming investigative role."

"i'm not asking him to claim. all he has to say is "yes. i am claiming..."

LOL

Listen

If the info you have regarding why he may have a fake guilty on you is info that wouldn't

GREATLY

damage town, then you refusing to claim it now is a SCUMCLAIM

[Nachomamma8]

chkflip neighborized me last night
he's not a cop of any flavor
and he's town

We all argue over who Mehdi should daycop. Nacho immediately suggests Trollie, which I call him out for because Trollie is obvscum and is a much weaker scum player than Mehdi, so scum would love to throw Trollie under the bus to save Mehdi, seemed like opportunistic crap that was a shitty, nonsensical way to utilize a daycop from town perspective. Interestingly, Nacho has ignored any future discussion about this matter

i suggested trollie because two-shot day cop is a broken combination with lightning rod, and scum-medhi was going to claim guilty regardless of who he targetted, which made his investigation useless, so the only thing it would be useful for is seeing who had the better scum pr
and then medhi ignored my suggestion completely, which tells me it was a pretty good suggestion
then i got excited because i thought toog was an unlimited PGO
also never ignored discussion. i didn't respond to you because i wanted venmar to respond before you did

[PeregrineV]

chkflip neighborized me last night
he's not a cop of any flavor
and he's town

We all argue over who Mehdi should daycop. Nacho immediately suggests Trollie, which I call him out for because Trollie is obvscum and is a much weaker scum player than Mehdi, so scum would love to throw Trollie under the bus to save Mehdi, seemed like opportunistic crap that was a shitty, nonsensical way to utilize a daycop from town perspective. Interestingly, Nacho has ignored any future discussion about this matter

i suggested trollie because two-shot day cop is a broken combination with lightning rod, and scum-medhi was going to claim guilty regardless of who he targetted, which made his investigation useless, so the only thing it would be useful for is seeing who had the better scum pr
and then medhi ignored my suggestion completely, which tells me it was a pretty good suggestion
then i got excited because i thought toog was an unlimited PGO
also never ignored discussion. i didn't respond to you because i wanted venmar to respond before you did

What happened in the QT that made chkflip come out with a scum read on you?

[Nachomamma8]

didn't post much in the qt even though he recruited me to prove my towniness to him/help him with reads

[PeregrineV]

@Toog- would your death by nightkill be considered a "result"? It may be stretching the rules and definitions of results, but would be badass if you get to be BP as well.

[Nachomamma8]

@Toog- would your death by nightkill be considered a "result"? It may be stretching the rules and definitions of results, but would be badass if you get to be BP as well.

probably better if scum don't know if he's bp or not, don't you think?

[PeregrineV]

didn't post much in the qt even though he recruited me to prove my towniness to him/help him with reads

So did he call you scum at any point in there? You don't really seem surprised by his accusation today.

[PeregrineV]

@Toog- would your death by nightkill be considered a "result"? It may be stretching the rules and definitions of results, but would be badass if you get to be BP as well.

probably better if scum don't know if he's bp or not, don't you think?

Actually, I expect he'll ask the mod, get a answer, and then say whatever would WIFOM the scum the most.

[Toogeloo]

@Toog- would your death by nightkill be considered a "result"? It may be stretching the rules and definitions of results, but would be badass if you get to be BP as well.

My role PM specifically says anyone who targets me will get my role PM instead of a result... could be a very interesting loophole!

@Nacho: I quoted my actual role PM. It's pretty evident what's what with my role, though maybe I should pester Monkey about not being killable since the Killer would just receive my Role PM instead of kill me lol!

[Nachomamma8]

didn't post much in the qt even though he recruited me to prove my towniness to him/help him with reads

So did he call you scum at any point in there? You don't really seem surprised by his accusation today.

not explicitly.
i was less surprised, more impressed.

the Killer would just receive my Role PM instead of kill me lol!

monkey would probably become my favorite moderator if this was the case

[PeregrineV]

didn't post much in the qt even though he recruited me to prove my towniness to him/help him with reads

So did he call you scum at any point in there? You don't really seem surprised by his accusation today.

not explicitly.
i was less surprised, more impressed.

Why would you be impressed, esp. if he is wrong?

[Nachomamma8]

he's having trouble reading me
he's doing something about it
in a recently finished game, he let me coast for a really long time, didn't really pursue his suspicion of me
this is an improvement

[MonkeyMan576]

Guy_Named_Riggs and SoraAdvent have been prodded.

[Guy_Named_Riggs]

I'm here. Can't do a whole lot of commenting at the moment however.

First off, rofl's PR is fake. When asked to prove it's real, he FoS someone else, not the actual person

Second, so was Bitmap actually shot (and lost BP)

Third, I'll get to more later

[chkflip]

Well there went my Godfather status in this game.

Nacho is still scum. Nobody claims for somebody else as town.

[MonkeyMan576]

JacobSavage is replacing SoraAdvent. He will receive a unique role to his own playstyle, he will not have SoraAdvents role.

[Om of the Nom]

Well there went my Godfather status in this game.

Nacho is still scum. Nobody claims for somebody else as town.

just get the fuck on bitmap

[JacobSavage]

Hi all. I think I've played with just under half of you before so that's quite good. Been reading along, so have a couple of thoughts.
1. Chkflip: what is the nature of your scum read on Nacho is it just that he hasn't been helpful in the QT or something that happened yesterday?
2. Roflcopter needs to go, he can't post content (somebody's already said that I know)
3. On the subject of Om's claim: I'd be willing to lynch Bitmap even if it means he wins (game ending Jesters are bastard in my opinion) and I'm interested in what'll happen.
VOTE: Bitmap
Will do more later.

[Nero Cain]

Jacob he is

NOT

a Jester. He's a third party troll and needs to die so OM can get dv/role cop.

[MonkeyMan576]

Vote Count 2.2
11 required to lynch
The Trollie - ArcAngel9(L-10)
Venmar - TheTrollie(L-10)
nachomamma8 - chkflip, MattP, Maenara, Venmar(L-7)
The Acting Method - Bitmap(L-10)
Bitmap - Om of the Nom, nero cain, Voided Mafia, Nachomamma8, jacobsavage(L-6)

Not Voting: Guy_Named_Riggs, maestro, PeregrineV,The Acting Method, Lurker, Elmo TeH Anz, Toogeloo

[Maestro]

VOTE: Bitmap

@chkflip: did you just claim Godfather? I'm confused.

[JacobSavage]

Jacob he is

NOT

a Jester. He's a third party troll and needs to die so OM can get dv/role cop.

I realised but quite a few players seem to think he is.

Also Om won't get either as he's said. He'll get a random protown ability.

[chkflip]

VOTE: Bitmap

@chkflip: did you just claim Godfather? I'm confused.

/:

People were treating me better. I think even Toog said something about wanting my say-so about the lynch target switching. Godfather status.

My vote isn't moving. I'll post my suspicions when I don't have a fussy baby to deal with.