Gay Mafia II: RIDE THE LIGHTNING (Game Over)

[Iecerint]

Also, I convinced myself that OneDirection had possibly-maybe crumbed an SK-innocent on her.

[Iecerint]

The highlight for me was when Faraday sang to Thunderhog.

[zoraster]

DGB had BP anyway, iec. best you could get would be a draw redirecting dgb at herself over and over and over.

[xRECKONERx]

Iece, your play was damn impressive. You lost due to some wonky mechanics stuff, but your play was great.

[kanyeknowsbest]

P.s. strongly feel nuwen and fate should have been modkilled for the quicktopic thing. Didn't really matter in the end, but still.

Nuwen didn't break any specific rules by posting a link to a website in which she set up the feed from the Quicktopic to run through a separate website. I debated the matter for a while with UT, and we didn't feel it was fair to modkill someone who didn't break a rule. We did talk to Nuwen about it though and ask her to take down the site. In our mind, people could have just quoted whatever was said in the QT anyway, so it didn't fuck up the game or cause any big problems. If it had compromised game integrity, then yes, a modkill would've been the only option.

as someone who was on the same team as wyrd i was pretty not okay with them not being modkilled. especially since i had sent you guys pms clarifying that it was against the rules and letting you know they were going to do it and urging you to cut it off at the pass, but instead you sat back and let it happen. pretty much killed any desire i had to be in the game. the only reason i didnt replace out was because matt still wanted to continue. and bullshit it didnt compromise the game integrity: they posted word for word what was in the hydra qt in a way that made it obvious they were telling the truth. it derailed the fuck out of his wagon and led directly to my lynch by letting dw counterclaim me since there was no longer any reason for the hydras to keep my role confidential.

[kanyeknowsbest]

also agree that your play at the end was pretty nice iece. think drams play should have made it obvious he wasnt the sk to you but you still did gr8 : ]

[zoraster]

how would that have made it obvious? most obvious solution to his idiocy was that he was BP SK so hammering me made sense.

[Iecerint]

Yeah, I was pretty sure dram wasn't the SK, but I HATED the idea of losing to dram and hearing people say BUT YOU REDIRECTED HIM TO TROLLIE WTFBBQ

[Iecerint]

neway thx i guess.

I was surprised no one asked why I didn't empower Trollie D1.

[Iecerint]

He also CLAIMED SCUM.

And I had thought OD had maybe jossed DGB-SK, but I guess not.

Meh.

[kanyeknowsbest]

how would that have made it obvious? most obvious solution to his idiocy was that he was BP SK so hammering me made sense.

he redirected dram to the trollie, but drams play like he knew something about you strongly implied that he did not know he was redirected until iece said something. if he had a kill he would have known he had been redirected.

[xRECKONERx]

P.s. strongly feel nuwen and fate should have been modkilled for the quicktopic thing. Didn't really matter in the end, but still.

Nuwen didn't break any specific rules by posting a link to a website in which she set up the feed from the Quicktopic to run through a separate website. I debated the matter for a while with UT, and we didn't feel it was fair to modkill someone who didn't break a rule. We did talk to Nuwen about it though and ask her to take down the site. In our mind, people could have just quoted whatever was said in the QT anyway, so it didn't fuck up the game or cause any big problems. If it had compromised game integrity, then yes, a modkill would've been the only option.

as someone who was on the same team as wyrd i was pretty not okay with them not being modkilled. especially since i had sent you guys pms clarifying that it was against the rules and letting you know they were going to do it and urging you to cut it off at the pass, but instead you sat back and let it happen. pretty much killed any desire i had to be in the game. the only reason i didnt replace out was because matt still wanted to continue. and bullshit it didnt compromise the game integrity: they posted word for word what was in the hydra qt in a way that made it obvious they were telling the truth. it derailed the fuck out of his wagon and led directly to my lynch by letting dw counterclaim me since there was no longer any reason for the hydras to keep my role confidential.

Thank you for your input, I will take it under advisement with my council.

[kanyeknowsbest]

yw : ]

[Om of the Nom]

This game was great and I'm glad I was a part of it :D
This also marks the first Large game that I've seen through till I died.
Congrats to DGB and also Iece who I definitely didn't suspect at all.

[Iecerint]

It was hard to understand why dram would lynch zora as a town player, and also why he would encourage DGB to cross-kill with him. That's the kind of thing you do and say as a bulletproof SK.

Not that DGB wasn't obvSK herself, what with going into panic-mode when she was up for the lynch. I wish I'd just voted her outright, but I wanted to wait until zora got his ducks in a row. <_<

[DrippingGoofball]

I've ripped my Master's degree out of the frame, and I'm putting this game in!

[DrippingGoofball]

3. Good game DGB. Did you actually believe I was scum or were you playing the "DGB is always super nuts" card?

As soon as my name came up as a possible lynch that last day, I lunged for the "easy" target;

the confirmed townie with a perfect scum-voting record

. I thought if I massaged the game enough, the other scum would hammer, or see that I would hammer, and let them put in the first vote.

When Iecerint said that dram had targeted Trollie (THE GUY *I* KILLED), I knew he was scum. When I saw that you were an Informed Townie enabler, I knew dramonic was 100% town and I was hoping that Iece wouldn't pick up on it, and shoot dramonic.

[zoraster]

3. Good game DGB. Did you actually believe I was scum or were you playing the "DGB is always super nuts" card?

As soon as my name came up as a possible lynch that last day, I lunged for the "easy" target;

the confirmed townie with a perfect scum-voting record

. I thought if I massaged the game enough, the other scum would hammer, or see that I would hammer, and let them put in the first vote.

When Iecerint said that dram had targeted Trollie (THE GUY *I* KILLED), I knew he was scum. When I saw that you were an Informed Townie enabler, I knew dramonic was 100% town and I was hoping that Iece wouldn't pick up on it, and shoot dramonic.

to be fair, I did once vote for JS. But yes, I see what you mean. Get the scum to go after me too. But you had what is easily one of the top 5 stupidest plays in mafia from dramonic.

[DrippingGoofball]

Iece, your play was damn impressive. You lost due to some wonky mechanics stuff, but your play was great.

What and I get no compliments from the mod?

My ego needs stroking like everybody else!

[Untrod Tripod]

we both nominated you for the best 3rd party scummie

[DrippingGoofball]

we both nominated you for the best 3rd party scummie

OMG OMG OMG

[Nachomamma8]

The highlight for me was when Faraday sang to Thunderhog.

fara... day...?

[Iecerint]

i'm insecure
don't know what for
i like my reads and stuff just walked through a door
don't need empire
to cover up
my posts contain some fluff
everyone else in the room can see it
everyone else but meeeee
thunder you light up my life like nobody else
prove gamma wrong and be town and stuff
you don't know you're beautifulll

[Zoidberg]

DGB had BP anyway, iec. best you could get would be a draw redirecting dgb at herself over and over and over.

I defintely would have gone hard at DGB had the game lasted another day. I had a p strong scumread on her ever since that completely-bullshit statistics crap she tried to push on us. So Iece might have been able to eke out a win in that case because I thought no way in hell Iece was scum.



Anyways: I would like some feedback/constructive criticism on my play. This game was one of my worst games in terms of quality. I found the sheer volume of data to wade through made it incredibly difficult to get anything useful out of it.

At the same time, I feel like there's a whole 2nd level of play happening above my head. I got/get a lot of criticism in the form of "Zoidberg is just skimming off the top, not being deep" or whatever, and a lot of the things that people found scummy, I didn't really comprehend why that was the case.

[DrippingGoofball]

that completely-bullshit statistics crap

That was an honest attempt to find scum, actually.