Newbie 1342 - Over

[Catlord]

I am sorry I most have missed something. How exactly did he claim scum?

[Majiffy]

He quoted for truth a post that called him a scumbutt, and requested a vote on himself.

[Catlord]

oh sorry, I forgot what QFT meant. Thanks.
Well in that case

Vote: MadMatter

I belive this brings you to L-1

[DeasVail]

Vote Count 1.06

HadMatter (4)- Majiffy, babushka, Debonair Danny DiPietro, Catlord

[L-1]

JasonWazza (1)- Nero
babushka (1)- JasonWazza
Majiffy (1)- HadMatter

Not Voting: Ms Marangal, korranth

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline

23rd March, 8am AEDT. This is in (expired on 2013-03-22 17:00:00).

[HadMatter]

Finally stuff to analyze. Big post incoming.

[HadMatter]

First off, if anyone quickhammers me, you guys know what to do tomorrow, right?

korranth:

Spoiler:

Major tunneling with Nero for most posts so far.
Responds to questions asked and generates some new content.
Refuses to follow Majiffy's flowchart, but then unvotes Nero anyway.
Overview: Unlike last game I played with him, where he was scum and refused to give major suspicions, he appears to be scum-hunting. Needs to skip the tunneling and do an analysis of all players before I decide whether his reads look right, but for now he's neutral, lean town.

Nero:

Spoiler:

Lots of quick contentless posts.
Over-defensive of votes trying to call things policy lynch.
No real content.
Overview: The initial wagon on him that I jumped on was just a wagon, but his response to it seems super townie. In my experience, newb town freak out the most while newb scum are usually trying to play it cool. Still waiting on him to try to provide content though. Neutral, leaning town.

babushka:

Spoiler:

Random vote seems very much like trying to find a random mechanic to blame the vote on "first alphabetical order".
Sheeping Majiffy.
Lots of contentless short posts.
Overview: Needs to provide content. Very scummy.

Catlord:

Spoiler:

No content besides a vote.
After the wagon formed, I said "QFT" to see reactions to it. Catlord's seems reasonably town, though putting me to L1 where scum can easily quickhammer is not optimal. Neutral - need actual content.

Ms Marangal:

Spoiler:

Admits to wanting to lynch Nero despite not thinking he's scum.
Calls bab out on Sheeping.
For some reason, is waiting to reveal reads.
Overview: Seems level-headed. Would like to see their individual reads quite a lot. Neutral, leaning town for providing more content than most other players.

Majiffy:

Spoiler:

Responded poorly to my QFT.
Has been tunneling without content all game.
Overview: I'll admit I've been acting scummy (because it's early game and I'm lazy until there's enough posts for analysis, and I'm fairly certain I'm not going to be lynched), but that's not an excuse for not doing anything else besides goading people to voting me, even up to L1. Find another target - until you do, scummy.

JasonWazza:

Spoiler:

Annoyed with Nero early.
Some vote swaps later to Deb and bab.
Overview: Not enough content but him spreading the suspicion around looks like not trying to make friends like scum does. Seems to be scum hunting. Townie for now.

DDD:

Spoiler:

Not much content.
Asking some questions, but not moving RVS vote for a while.
Blatant Maj sheeping
Overwiew: Playing the way our scum IC played last time. No real content. No explanations. Scummy.

Scum scores:

Jason Wazza - 3/10
korranth - 4/10
Nero - 4/10
Ms Marangal - 4/10
Catlord - 5/10
babushka - 6/10
Majiffy - 6/10
Deb - 6/10

0/10 is 100% sure player is town. 10/10 is 100% sure player is scum. 1 and 9 is me being unsure only because I suspect insanity or miller/godfather status or some townie might be lying and screwing the game up, but otherwise I'm sure. 2 and 8 are me being overly confident or breadcrumbing an investigation or other result that I'll claim later. 3 and 7 are stronger reads based on gut or reasonable suspicion (of town or scum status). 4 and 6 are slight reads based on gut. 5/10 is no reads either way.

I don't see Deb/Maj as scum together because of Deb's recent sheeping her (could be wine), but I could see either one of them as scum with babushka. Bab plus one of Maj or Deb is my best scum team guess.

Unvote
Vote: babushka

[Nero]

INTENT TO HAMMER

[Nero]

Why do you townread Jason the most?

[babushka]

So you fully admit that your acting scummy. but because we're calling you out on it, and voting for you because of it, that makes all of us scummy. right, that makes sense.

[Nero]

I'm assuming you're claiming vanilla townie btw.

[HadMatter]

I haven't claimed and if you hammer before I do, you will die tomorrow. I'm also fully expecting to not have to claim. I've been having a good time making scum think I'm any easy mislynch, but I assure you that's not going to happen.

[HadMatter]

*an not any

[Majiffy]

180's analysis doesn't fit the final reads whatsoever.

Completely manufactured, actions don't make sense from a town perspective (voting bab is survivalistic in nature because he doesn't want to OMGUS me), also a lot of deflection and empty claims such as his QFT "reaction test" where he says there are good and bad reactions but doesn't elaborate on why each is good or bad, and calling a lot of people on the wagon "contentless" without really pointing out why their posts are void of content...

Yeah, we can give him the hammer.

[Ms Marangal]

Hadmatter's town guys. I would much rather not have him hammered, it's way to early into the game.

Content coming up

[Ms Marangal]

I'll hold on to my reads for now until I have something solid if you don't mind Hatter. I do want catlord to say a bit more, as I had a slight gut read on Metal sonic, though I do admit that a single question shouldn't indicate alignment in any way whatsoever. I do see your point on Deb and Jiffy, though I don't think Jiffy is scum either, not at this point. he is more of a null read

I do find it interesting though that Babu had jumped onto the wagon pretty quickly when Matter "claimed scum" as if it would have been that easy. I also noticed that she seemingly got defensive when Matter had called her out as possibly scummy. more defensive then is actually required.

I would like more from Deb, I can't judge him from his few posts but I'm fairly sure he's a busy man. we can't really judge him for lurking when others are just as bad as he is, and lurking alone isn't indicative of alignment

[Nero]

I haven't claimed and if you hammer before I do, you will die tomorrow. I'm also fully expecting to not have to claim. I've been having a good time making scum think I'm any easy mislynch, but I assure you that's not going to happen.

you're fucking claiming now

[Majiffy]

I really like this fucking Nero guy.

[JasonWazza]

I haven't claimed and if you hammer before I do, you will die tomorrow. I'm also fully expecting to not have to claim. I've been having a good time making scum think I'm any easy mislynch, but I assure you that's not going to happen.

I HATE when people do this

You've been making scum think your an easy mislynch?

You've also made town see you as scummy as fuck, so what exactly is your point?

I second Nero's intent to hammer, so HadMatter you better fucking claim

[HadMatter]

Not gonna claim until I give other people a chance to Unvote and not force me to. I'll be lynching among the people who are forcing me to claim.

[Nero]

Lmao, you'll be dead.

[Nero]

I'm hammering tomorrow if you haven't claim by then.

[HadMatter]

And you'll get lynched D2 for your trouble. Be my guest.

[Majiffy]

Good god someone hammer this retard.

[Nero]

[Majiffy]

He's had enough, do the deed.