Gears of War Mafia - ( Game Over! )

[mastin2]

So...

STRONG TOWN

:

Angelic Nero
Slandaar
GuyInFreezer (single-faction)

TOWN

:

Mac
PeregrineV
Piratecat

WEAK TOWN

:

Knight of Cydonia (aka, KoC)

NULL-TOWN

:

bork
The Goat

PURE AMBIVALENT

:

Colonel Guile (UN/guille)
qwints

NULL-SCUM

:

Approximately Normal Guy (aka, ANG)
Bitmap
Jal
MS Marangal

SCUM

?:

AngryPidgeon
Majiffy

SCUM

!

CryoNudist
GuyInFreezer (multiball)
Messiah

NULL

:

Da rest. (looking at the post, as far as I can tell, this is just havingfitz)

[Ms Marangal]

holy cow, give me a sec to catch up

[Majiffy]

No.

[AngryPidgeon]

@mastin: Ok well Im town. And I know me saying that doesn't mean a whole lot since you and I have a hilarious history of being good at AtE. (damn it)

Why are bitmap/MsMarangal a scum read? Majiffy too for that matter.

I would be 100% down with a cryonudist or Messiag wagon right now, but Im acually quite quite happy with my messiah vote. His latest post feels like a way too look opinionated without contributing and dodging current issues.

[Angelious Nero]

I kind of like that Fitz vote.

@Mac: Ok, but if scum are doing it to appear more town then you are admitting that it is something town is also likely to do. Ergo, its a null tell. So why would he be scummy for it exactly?

I don't think town would make that posts though. I think it's pretty obvious Locust's are the bad guys from the flavor.

Mac is a gut feel, not super strong really. But I liked this post. Hes taking a fairly hard stance on this point and locking himself into a scumread on someone over something fairly minor. Just came off a bit strong to be from scum so early.

Except his vote on GIF was RVS and then later he has a reason to call GIF scum but it was brought up by someone else. Distancing maybe?

I don't understand this post. Can you explain that a bit more for me? /slow

Why do I need to explain your post to you? lol I think you’re scum and I have no interest in holding dialogue with scum. I mean its not like I’m going to convince you that you are scum. But I guess for everyone else....Mac put down a RVS vote on GIF in 10. In 49 he heavily implies that GIF is scum. He never really pushes a lynch at all so I’m not sure at all where AP is coming from.


It

I don't think either of us are defending majiffy.

I think he looks scummy

but sweet attempt at trying to discredit my (mollie's) read. /:

Do you even know what discrediting means? Discrediting reads are what AP and Majiffy are doing. My claim that you are defending Majiffy is 'cause you ARE. Maybe not in the traditional sense where you tell us Majiffy is town and lash out at those voting him but you are voting GOAT for something that Majiffy also did and calling the whole Majiffy vs. us thing "scum theater" is silly me thinks and incorrectly attributing the Majiffy wagon to Bork. Just what the hell? Sometimes I feel like you are trying to tie me in with Majiffy so when he flips scum I’d prob be next. I’m not sure if you just don’t want to lynch your boyfriend or if ya’ll are scum together. So why are you not voting Majiffy?

naw. Scum chainsaw town for attacking town too, cred and all.

[AngryPidgeon]

I really do not understand why so many people are suspicious of Majiffy.

[mastin2]

Dammit, that's way too many scumreads for my comfort.

Nero, help me out here. Help me focus in.

AP, though I suspect you, I'm treating you as town for today, so help me. Don't bother defending yourself from me (as I said, it's a waste of space for d1); instead, I want you to point at the rest of the people on my list and tell me where you think I've gone right or wrong. Bouncing ideas off of town-you nets scum a LOT more often than not.

Slandaar, I need you to give me the strength of your CryoNudist scumread. And who else do you suspect? Even if CryoNudist is scum, they have scumbuddies, and I was hoping you could help me shed some light on that.

UN, I know you like to slack off in games, but I could use your help. Come in, actually read the thread, and help get my reads solidified. If nothing else, do something to bump yourself into my town category, please.

Majiffy, like AP, I suspect you, but if you're town, I'll be blunt; you're barking up the wrong tree, here. And you were also on the wrong track for Nero/Angel. So tell me, other than myself (which is beyond stupid) and Nero/Angel (equally dumb), who is it that you suspect? There has to be more than just two or three people you suspect. And who do you think is town? Why? You've given very little actual content this game. Heck, what's your read on Mollie? I realize hydra-play changes meta, but you should still have SOME clue as to Mollie's alignment.

[Angelious Nero]

vote: Mac

I think the whole "we aren't going to vote Majiffy on d1 'cause he might actually be useful. He's scum plain and simple and delaying his lynch is stupid. Aparently being an asshole makes people not want to lynch you so meh, I'll just vig him instead. But since there's like no support lets go with my 2nd scum read.

[mastin2]

Scum Heap

Messiah
Knight of Cydonia
Approximately Normal Guy
-----------------
PirateCat
qwints
CryoNudist* (mainly sheeping Slandaar's suspicion here)

Everyone else:

havingfitz
GuyinFreezer

Why is fitz in null (everyone else) when you liked his post(s) before?
Why don't you have a read on GIF?
What puts Piratecat into the (weak) scum pile?
Why is CryoNudist only in the (weak) scum pile, not higher?

[Angelious Nero]

@mastin: Ok well Im town. And I know me saying that doesn't mean a whole lot since you and I have a hilarious history of being good at AtE. (damn it)

Why are bitmap/MsMarangal a scum read? Majiffy too for that matter.

I would be 100% down with a cryonudist or Messiag wagon right now, but Im acually quite quite happy with my messiah vote. His latest post feels like a way too look opinionated without contributing and dodging current issues.

AP – I don’t know how serious you’re about this post..

You seriously don’t read Bitmap and MsMarangal as scum?
Look at the Bitmap, he had only 3 posts… I really doubt being town, a player like BITMAP would sit back and miss a game like this. He is leaning scum for sure..
And MsMarangal pretty much giving dodgy reasons for not having a readable posts by saying.. oops give me a sec to catch up (EX: 401 post)
And not to forgot, how she tried to turn over GOAT’s RVS vote into scummy. She is leaning scum for me too..

I have played with Cryo before, Town cryo is more vocal and there is a good chance he could be scum. I have seen him has scum and pretty much laid low to detent attention from crowd.

~A

[Ms Marangal]

Mac, I'm hardly forming a case against Goat, Mollie's the one who formed a case against him I'm just totally averse to being associated with him. don't ask me why, I just am. I really hadn't made a case against anyone yet, the game is moving way to fast for me to solidify on my read :/

out of curiosity, out of everyone here who has, and is attacking goats, why single me out?

is Malak me? what about Mollie's wall looks scummy? I'm not seeing it

Mastin is alarming, IDK why he outright stated he was town. just makes him more suspicious IMO

I could vote for him due to his comment about GIF, was that a scumslip?

Pedit: so many posts...

[Ms Marangal]

Mac, I'm hardly forming a case against Goat, Mollie's the one who formed a case against him I'm just totally averse to being associated with him. don't ask me why, I just am. I really hadn't made a case against anyone yet, the game is moving way to fast for me to solidify on my read :/

out of curiosity, out of everyone here who has, and is attacking goats, why single me out?

is Malak me? what about Mollie's wall looks scummy? I'm not seeing it

Mastin is alarming, IDK why he outright stated he was town. just makes him more suspicious IMO

I could vote for him due to his comment about GIF, was that a scumslip?

Pedit: so many posts...

[Ms Marangal]

Mac, I'm hardly forming a case against Goat, Mollie's the one who formed a case against him I'm just totally averse to being associated with him. don't ask me why, I just am. I really hadn't made a case against anyone yet, the game is moving way to fast for me to solidify on my read :/

out of curiosity, out of everyone here who has, and is attacking goats, why single me out?

is Malak me? what about Mollie's wall looks scummy? I'm not seeing it

Mastin is alarming, IDK why he outright stated he was town. just makes him more suspicious IMO

I could vote for him due to his comment about GIF, was that a scumslip?

Pedit: so many posts...

[Angelious Nero]

Triple post???

[Angelious Nero]

She's scum

[Majiffy]

Majiffy, like AP, I suspect you, but if you're town, I'll be blunt; you're barking up the wrong tree, here. And you were also on the wrong track for Nero/Angel. So tell me, other than myself (which is beyond stupid) and Nero/Angel (equally dumb), who is it that you suspect? There has to be more than just two or three people you suspect. And who do you think is town? Why? You've given very little actual content this game. Heck, what's your read on Mollie? I realize hydra-play changes meta, but you should still have SOME clue as to Mollie's alignment.

RE other suspects: I'm working on it, give me some time.
RE mollie: She's acting different than any other time I've played with her, and I've seen her as town, scum, and 3rd party. I blame the Mala.

Best way to discern Mollie is to make her flip out about something.

[Ms Marangal]

Shaddup Jiffy

and Mollie did that, not me.. or well, Mollie started to bring up Goats RV out of RVS scummy point, I just enforced it. and it was way out of RVS, so why isn't it scummy?

also, if I'm scum, why are you voting Mac?

PEdit: STOP POSTING FUCK

[mastin2]

Already, I feel like my list needs revision.
MS's post is basically a whole lot of parroting, by saying Mollie looks town (no duh) and attacking me for the same BS reasoning that Majiffy did. As a start.

Also, I feel like bumping both the ambivalents into a town category. Probably null-town. And I feel like bork probably deserves higher than that, into weak town.

[qwints]

I'm still a bit lost by Angelious Nero's mac vote. Care to explain?

I'd also still like to hear what goat/ANG think of mac now.

I agree on the Slandaar town read. I've also got AP and bork as pretty town.

[Angelious Nero]

Shaddup Jiffy

and Mollie did that, not me.. or well, Mollie started to bring up Goats RV out of RVS scummy point, I just enforced it. and it was way out of RVS, so why isn't it scummy?

also, if I'm scum, why are you voting Mac?

PEdit: STOP POSTING FUCK

Depends when you think it is way out of RVS, but that's not all worrying me. If you think that is a scummy movie, why didn't you vote him? Unlike pirate cate? you just raised your voice on mollie's suspicion and stayed quiet. It's like you trying to be part of a discussion which you actually don't believe it. That is scummy.

~

[Angelious Nero]

NULL-SCUM:

Approximately Normal Guy (aka, ANG)
Bitmap
Jal
MS Marangal
SCUM?:
AngryPidgeon
Majiffy
SCUM!
CryoNudist
GuyInFreezer (multiball)
Messiah

I need to reread Messiah but off the top of my head he’s kinda scummy. AP and Jiffy should be on there. Don’t really like Cyro. GIF is ok...might be getting bussed by Mac. ANG, Jal and MS aren’t suspicious to me. Bitmap is meh....I actully disagree with Slan. It was along time ago but I played with Slandar and he looks diffrent and I don’t like his misplaced vote on Cyro so....if we add Mac and Slandar that list looks much better.


Messiah
AP
Jiffy
GIF
Mac
Slandaar

[AngryPidgeon]

I want you to point at the rest of the people on my list and tell me where you think I've gone right or wrong

Why are bitmap/MsMarangal a scum read? Majiffy too for that matter.

Bitmap is flaking hardcore. Which is a pretty null tell for him (if not a really light town tell). But I mean really he has 2 posts. One is a RV and one is no content. I don't see how anyone could have anything there.

though I don't get why Pidgeon is role-fishing someone who had already outed their role...

You mean my question to mastin? I was dead serious about that and I still do want some flavor from him. I do have a reason for that. Why is asking for flavor to accompany a roleclaim odd? Is it not normal in themes to claim flavor when you claim?

Mastin: I'll cede my Marangal townlean. She doesn't look that good in ISO.

P-EDIT:
I liked Fitz's vote on Molliekittens. Not really indicative of his alignment, but I was feeling lightly suspicious of them at that point and was interested that Fitz apparently was as well.
Who is GIF? If I had to guess, I'd say null-town for his flavor spec. He hasn't posted much that stood out to me. His last post to ANG looked weird and possibly scum/scum.
I want to ISO Molliekittens when I have time and try not to be biased on it. I've been moderately certain they were scum since Mollie's first wall and her response to me after it. I guess thats mostly a gut feel. Mollie just feels weird this game and I don't know why Malak was so interested in discussing Mollie's post with people. (She knows mollie's alignment, why care what someone finds scummy about it? Surely whoever said it was scummy isn't just going to implode on being asked why)
I need to reread Cryo as well. He is another player that snuck by me this game (like I forgot PV was in the game, I kinda forgot he was in it as well). I like you for town though and we both seem to think Slandaar looks town and I liked Slandaar's post about Cryo - it just caught my eye. But I need to ISO cryo in a bit.

@Arcangel: I maintain that Bitmap flaking is not a scumtell. I've seen him flake before. I'll admit that Marangal doesn't look that good after an ISO. In fact I really dislike her saying Mollie is town for caring about an RV.

PPedit: I can't respond to all that, sec.

[Majiffy]

GIF = GuyInFreezer, another complete non-entity in this game along with this Mac fellow.

[Angelious Nero]

also, if I'm scum, why are you voting Mac?

I was kidding.

@Qwints, I have like 2 or 3 posts explaining why I find Mac scummy. You should like read.

[Angelious Nero]

also, if I'm scum, why are you voting Mac?

I was kidding.

@Qwints, I have like 2 or 3 posts explaining why I find Mac scummy. You should like read.