Open 485: Polygamist Mafia - GAME OVER

[leviathan93]

By the way, Levi, that wasn't a stab at you. That was just a joke about getting some awesome player to replace in as confirmed town.

lol. well, thanks for that. i'm just always a horrible player being confirmed town. =P

[Ms Marangal]

oh, I forgot about KBW, he hasn't left my suspect pool, though my suspicion on him is likely due to his anti-town mindset

Ok. I'm here now. just finished reading the thread.

first i guess i should comment on the fact that marangal outed us. and my response to you marangal is. I'm not trying to get lynched! its never MY fault I get lynched. people never listen to me and decide to lynch me no matter what I say! nothing much i can do there.

maybe think about why people tend to think that you're scummy?

also secondly. i agree with the others that have spoken and that you shouldn't have outed us so soon. i CAN hold my own you know. its not like I TRY to get lynched all the time. now people possibly have the possibility of thinking you are lying. you should have waited in my opinion.

In retrospect, it might have been a good idea to wait, but it was probably my paranoia that got hold of me. what would I have lied about though?

my third bit of information i think is necssary is that Orc is town. his long posts and many posts since he first started posting seem legit and questioningly scum hunting as well as my past games with him he has always been town for the most part and i think its his town meta.

Clarify this point? how is Orc being town necessary?

FF has a possibility of being town to me but i will continue to watch her as the day goes on. Same for the acting method guy. i like his in depth posts but just because i like his posts does not necessarily make him town. i like plenty of scum's posts in the past and been tricked easily by that.

so who are your scum reads then? I can guess the alignments of other people, though yours is the only one I can confirm town so your opinions are like gold.

[orcinus_theoriginal]

M: that was addressed at TAM. And when I said talk to me about my jumpiness, I sort of wanted an explanation of how I've been "jumpy". I don't see what you're trying to get at at all.

Levi was saying that it was necessary information for town. So edited for grammar, his post reads "my third bit of information THAT I think is necessary TO CONVEY is that Orc is town."

I'm seeing how I was being misinterpreted.

Klick: The fact that M posted the ideal scumstrat in thread means that we can no longer look for it. If anything that was a little anti-town. >.<

[fferyllt]

TAM's posts are bugging me a little.

TAM did you ever provide that link to your previous polygamy game that Voodoo Lady asked for?

[fferyllt]

I've been employing one-word pushes like "interesting" on mafia posts that raise my interest for years. I never know what will break loose. This is one of the most lengthy and detailed exchanges I've ever managed to provoke.

[The Acting Method]

I didn't see that she had, I'll get that game soon.


Also, Orc, Please stop discrediting my post of the narrative when I DO have people who made the same interpretation. Call it a gut reaction and interpreting of others posts. Plus having played this game before.

Fact: You have said that you spoke to your partner last night and that you had no idea that you wouldn't get your quick topic during the day?
How did a: That question not come up in the qt? and b: you not think to check and make sure with the mod?
Also, as far as I'm concerned, you could be lying about one or the other of these things, or both.

Fact: Marangal has said she thought you were OMGUSing fferyllt.
Now as you admit it seems a little weak and baseless, HOWEVER, that's why you can use it as an attack on the only person whose willing to question you about it.

Right now Orc, I don't think you are the scummiest player out there, and I'd rather go after a completely silent player... However you are on my radar, and I know how reliable Marangal's reads on me can be.


Also here's the game: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=52&t=22599

[Messiah]

Posting soonish.

[Messiah]

Okay, Marangal/Lev pair is definitely town. My eyes immediately glazed over when the huge idiotic walls started up and I don't have time to deal with that right now. Sheeping Klick until I get more time.

vote: KBW

[fferyllt]

TAM, what are your thoughts about the best timing of a mass claim?

[TraceyLyn11]

VOTE COUNT 1.4

[L-6] Ms Marangal: (FuDuzn)

[L-6] The Acting Method: (orcinus_theoriginal)

[L-7] FuDuzn:

[L-7] JKMatthews:

[L-7] Klick:

[L-5] Keybladewielder: (Klick, Messiah)

[L-6] Messiah: (Keybladewielder)

[L-7] leviathan93:

[L-7] Nekoko:

[L-7] orcinus_theoriginal:

[L-7] fferyllt:

[L-6] Voodoo Lady: (JKMatthews)

Not Voting:

6 (Ms Marangal, The Acting Method, leviathan93, Nekoko, fferyllt, Voodoo Lady)

• With twelve alive, it takes seven to lynch.
  
• Day One's deadline: April 9, 2013 CST or in (expired on 2013-04-09 17:30:00).
  
• V/LA: No one.

"A friend is one that knows you as you are, understands where you have been, accepts what you have become, and still, gently allows you to grow."

-William Shakespeare

[leviathan93]

oh, I forgot about KBW, he hasn't left my suspect pool, though my suspicion on him is likely due to his anti-town mindset

Ok. I'm here now. just finished reading the thread.

first i guess i should comment on the fact that marangal outed us. and my response to you marangal is. I'm not trying to get lynched! its never MY fault I get lynched. people never listen to me and decide to lynch me no matter what I say! nothing much i can do there.

maybe think about why people tend to think that you're scummy?

also secondly. i agree with the others that have spoken and that you shouldn't have outed us so soon. i CAN hold my own you know. its not like I TRY to get lynched all the time. now people possibly have the possibility of thinking you are lying. you should have waited in my opinion.

In retrospect, it might have been a good idea to wait, but it was probably my paranoia that got hold of me. what would I have lied about though?

my third bit of information i think is necssary is that Orc is town. his long posts and many posts since he first started posting seem legit and questioningly scum hunting as well as my past games with him he has always been town for the most part and i think its his town meta.

Clarify this point? how is Orc being town necessary?

FF has a possibility of being town to me but i will continue to watch her as the day goes on. Same for the acting method guy. i like his in depth posts but just because i like his posts does not necessarily make him town. i like plenty of scum's posts in the past and been tricked easily by that.

so who are your scum reads then? I can guess the alignments of other people, though yours is the only one I can confirm town so your opinions are like gold.

I have no idea why people think i'm scummy. i just play how i want to play.

and fine paranoia accepted. and i meant that your claiming and outing us could have been taken worse and then lynched a town faction and only having one more chance of survival for town. just a worse case scenario.

and orc got what i meant. to say that he was town because of his posts and my past meta experiences with him. its not necessary. my bad. lazy with my wording.

and i don't have them at the moment because i feel finding town would be easier then finding scum. i only have possibilities of scum. TAM and FF.

[Messiah]

Okay, VL and ffery are guaranteed to not be scum together for posts 36 and 37.

I like fferyllt for town for post #21. Can't really explain why, but it feels really town-motivated.

Can you try to quantify this for me? I actually got the exact opposite feeling from it. I know that's a shitty thing to try to explain, but if you can that'd be cool.

[Messiah]

Levi, vote KBW.

[Messiah]

Actually, I'm pretty confident ffery is town now. Never mind.

[leviathan93]

Levi, vote KBW.

i don't do sheeping.

and haven't gotten as much info and reads on him as i would like before I vote someone. especially in this set up where every vote is crucial.

[fferyllt]

TAM and I were scum together in my first game here. It ended last week. I feel cautious about assuming that I see his scum game again here. I was watching "from the back of the house" in that game. One thing I didn't experience playing with him was any of those face-palm moments when you think your scum buddy just made a huge slip. But, his posts in this thread do strike me as a little passive aggressive, as someone else mentioned earlier.

Reading through parts of the old game, I see why he was grumpy about town gambits in his first post. But, it was entirely his choice to play this format again, so. Given what was going down in that game, he was pretty collected and handled himself well even though he was leading the lynch at LYLO. I was hoping to get some insights into his play here. Maybe it's growth/experience based changes I'm seeing between the two games.

[Messiah]

Orcinus seems to be behaving in a way that is much more likely to gather the attention and ire of other players than he did in the game I played with him as scum from what I remember, so he can be town for now. I'll go back and check on that sometime to make sure I'm remembering correctly though.

JKM and TAM could be scum.

Still conspicuously not reading the walls.

[Messiah]

Nekoko

totally

needs to post.

VL is probably my second pick for scum at the moment.

[Ms Marangal]

is he the only one who hasn't posted yet? I would also like to hear more from KBW and VL as well.

and TAM, I have tagged you as scum several times over

[Voodoo Lady]

When scum make incriminating comments, they frequently try to back out of the statement with a comment along the lines of "Obviously that was a joke!" Orcinus is doing this right now w/r/t his vote on Fferyllt sans explanation.

Plus I find your stated reasoning for the vote kind of flimsy... if you wanted to start a conversation with Fferyllt in real time, wouldn't you try to ask her a question or something instead of just voting for her with no explanation?

I personally read Marangal's OMGUS comment as being directed at Fferyllt, TAM.

Nekoko: I would very much like to see you post sometime in the near future!

[fferyllt]

When scum make incriminating comments, they frequently try to back out of the statement with a comment along the lines of "Obviously that was a joke!" Orcinus is doing this right now w/r/t his vote on Fferyllt sans explanation.

Plus I find your stated reasoning for the vote kind of flimsy... if you wanted to start a conversation with Fferyllt in real time, wouldn't you try to ask her a question or something instead of just voting for her with no explanation?

I personally read Marangal's OMGUS comment as being directed at Fferyllt, TAM.

Nekoko: I would very much like to see you post sometime in the near future!

Didn't Marangal say it was directed at orcinus?

[orcinus_theoriginal]

I personally read Marangal's OMGUS comment as being directed at Fferyllt, TAM.

I PERSONALKY READ IT AS

I'm seeing how I was being misinterpreted.

[FuDuzn]

VOTE: orcinus

Why isn't everybody voting this guy right now?

[Keybladewielder]

@Mod:

I apologize but I must replace out. It was either this or another game, and I apologize, but 6 games at once is too much for me.

[Keybladewielder]

Actually scratch that never mind