Open 485: Polygamist Mafia - GAME OVER

[Ms Marangal]

IDK, I mean that plan doesn't really apply to me since I already outed my partner but doing it in the way you are doing it will just cause Scum to be that much more cautious, and it would also help scum to figure out who to push. I mean, I can see the benifits of it, but I'm not entirely sure it will be greater then the back lashes it will have

[Ms Marangal]

oh, and I could give you a run down of what happened, but it wouldn't be as good as your own PoV of what's going on since mine is probably a bit different from yours

[Svenskt Stål]

Thats what interests me.

[Klick]

Appreciate the thought, but it's much more beneficial to do this in late D1/early D2 so that each player can make their own impression before being paired up.

I like your entrance into the game, though. Keep it up.

[leviathan93]

Interesting entrance Sven. =P liked the picture.

don't really understand how outing everyone will work. as someone mentioned that scum probably paired up or something. also who could we trust and who could we not trust?

i mean if people don't really believe me and marangal are town even though we claimed together already, well, more her then me. =P cuz she is worried about my town play since i'm not the best townie ever apparently, then who is to say that when everyone does it that won't happen?

[Klick]

Actually, I feel pretty good about my reads at this point. I wouldn't have a problem myself with claiming now, but I think we should all feel pretty good about at least a few singular reads before we do.

Right now, I think I have scum pegged between TAM, FuDuzn, KBW, Messiah, and Nekoko.

[Klick]

Scratch that, I was wrong about something.

[Klick]

Yeah, actually, I want to see a few claims now.

[leviathan93]

then lets vote. who WANTS CLAIMS!?

[orcinus_theoriginal]

I have TAM, Nekoko, and maybe the lurkers with Fudu as town...

[Klick]

Everyone who wants claims now, say, "Aye."

Aye.

[orcinus_theoriginal]

sqrt(-1)

[fferyllt]

Hi Svenskt.

Appreciate the thought, but it's much more beneficial to do this in late D1/early D2 so that each player can make their own impression before being paired up.

I like your entrance into the game, though. Keep it up.

Late day 1 was what I was thinking. I would kinda like to see some substance from KBW and more substance from Nekoko, VL and Messiah before we claim.

But, I do understand the interest in some pairs on the table. Depending on the pairs, there is a chance we could take some folks out of the frame and narrow down the suspect list dramatically.

I'll go along with my partner on this one. If they want some pairs to out now, I'll agree.

[Voodoo Lady]

Rereading Ms M's ISO... that first post is still a bit odd to me, but she's been very active and questioning while not making any scumslips or anything.

Levi on the other hand is a bit more suspicious. You haven't really explained why you think Fferyllt might be scum, and your argument for TAM being scum is that he seems too town.

But most suspicious of all right now is Fuduzn, whose playstyle is aggressive with zero substance. I think he's the most likely to be scum out of everyone here.

VOTE: Fuduzn

[FuDuzn]

So you don't think being overly aggressive right out of the gate is a good thing? As I said scum can't buss in this game, being aggressive towards certain people to gain others reactions seems like a viable tool here.

Or do you just think I could be an easy target?

[Voodoo Lady]

no, but I do have a problem with with people who place their votes without giving it a second thought, especially in this set-up. I'm not protecting him, I had already stated that he is one of my biggest suspects in this game

So you don't think being overly aggressive right out of the gate is a good thing? As I said scum can't buss in this game, being aggressive towards certain people to gain others reactions seems like a viable tool here.

Or do you just think I could be an easy target?

I don't mind aggression in a game like this. But your posts don't have any substance to them beyond "vote this guy, they're obvscum."

[leviathan93]

Rereading Ms M's ISO... that first post is still a bit odd to me, but she's been very active and questioning while not making any scumslips or anything.

Levi on the other hand is a bit more suspicious. You haven't really explained why you think Fferyllt might be scum, and your argument for TAM being scum is that he seems too town.

But most suspicious of all right now is Fuduzn, whose playstyle is aggressive with zero substance. I think he's the most likely to be scum out of everyone here.

VOTE: Fuduzn

wait is that at me about fferyllt being scum? i never said that. nor did I have an argument about TAM at all.

[TraceyLyn11]

VOTE COUNT 1.7

[L-7] Ms Marangal:

[L-6] The Acting Method: (orcinus_theoriginal)

[L-6] FuDuzn: (Voodoo Lady)

[L-7]

JKMatthews

Svenskt Stål:

[L-7] Klick:

[L-5] Keybladewielder: (Klick, Messiah)

[L-6] Messiah: (Keybladewielder)

[L-7] leviathan93:

[L-7] Nekoko:

[L-4] orcinus_theoriginal: (FuDuzn, The Acting Method, Nekoko)

[L-7] fferyllt:

[L-6] Voodoo Lady: (Svenskt Stål)

Not Voting:

3 (Ms Marangal, leviathan93, fferyllt)

• With twelve alive, it takes seven to lynch.
  
• Day One's deadline: April 9, 2013 CST or in (expired on 2013-04-09 17:30:00).
  
• V/LA: Keybladewielder ((expired on 2013-03-24 00:00:00))
  
• Svenskt Stål has replaced JKMatthews.

"A wise man is he who does not grieve for the thing which he has not, but rejoices for those which he has."

-Epictetus

[fferyllt]

I thought KBW is on V/LA?

Oops. Fixed!

[FuDuzn]

I am not trying to over compicate things, I am applying pressure for reactions. Stop trying to look for, or demand, deeper meaning.

[orcinus_theoriginal]

Your pressure has been applied to me: what have you learned about my alignment?

[orcinus_theoriginal]

Voodoo and Fudu, are you ignoring the poll for claims for a reason or what

[fferyllt]

Hi Svenskt.

Appreciate the thought, but it's much more beneficial to do this in late D1/early D2 so that each player can make their own impression before being paired up.

I like your entrance into the game, though. Keep it up.

Late day 1 was what I was thinking. I would kinda like to see some substance from KBW and more substance from Nekoko, VL and Messiah before we claim.

But, I do understand the interest in some pairs on the table. Depending on the pairs, there is a chance we could take some folks out of the frame and narrow down the suspect list dramatically.

I'll go along with my partner on this one. If they want some pairs to out now, I'll agree.

Thinking on this some more, I have some enthusiasm for a mass claim. Right now, all of town (except possibly/probably Ms Marinel and Leviathan) is hiding something. And that vibe could be obscuring traces of scum. It may be depressing people's posting rate, too, along with uncertainty about how this game design shapes town and scum behavior. At least I have some uncertainty about it.

So, Aye.

[orcinus_theoriginal]

Hey FF, why don't you put your vote somewhere? You've praised some people for aggressiveness, yet you've been maybe the most passive active poster in the game.

[Ms Marangal]

Can noone get my name right? :/

and I can see the uses of a mass claim atm... I highly doubt I will get my vote placed until I know who's with who anyway, given one lover may just be scummy as fuck, and town while the other is actually town Eg, if TAM and FF ended up being lovers, I might take my scum-read on TAM back

Sven, so far I had claimed Levi is my lover, voiced suspicion towards Orci, TAM, Fuduzn, and FF, questioned Klick's town read on me, and took back my scum read on FF and Orci for the time being