Mini 1436 ~ Mafia Through a Puppy's Eyes (Game Over.)

[Sixty]

~Mini Vote Count (6)

IceGuy (L-3)

~ sword_of_omens, kanyeknowsbest, implosion

Cheery Dog (L-3)

~ Parama, SpyreX, Panzerjager

sword_of_omens (L-5)

~ Maxous

Panzerjager (L-5)

~ Cheery Dog

Not Voting:

IceGuy, Lady Lambdadelta, Messiah

--With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Battery power:

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

(75%)

[IceGuy]

So, does anybody have any reasoning for their vote on CD?

is this really all you have for us?

Yeah.

[PJ.]

vig or replacement plz.

[IceGuy]

Just because you don't agree with my playstyle? Not making up reads like the others?

[implosion]

Ignoring things that have been directed at you is not a "playstyle."

It's more like... oh, i don't know, a bad habit. One over which I am absolutely willing to policy vote because categorically not responding to things directed at you makes you more difficult to read than others.

[implosion]

When i say more difficult to read than others, i mean intrinsically so - as in, you are "cheating the system" and I'm fundamentally unwilling to play a game of mafia with you if you aren't willing to play a game of mafia with me.

[IceGuy]

I have answered all questions directed at me. Nobody so far has answered the question asked by me.

[implosion]

Incidentally i'm not sure why i called cheery scum before and am too lazy to check, but his reaction to the LM wagon is bad.

Two other things: i'm not convinced that parama is town (see: the question that i called terrible), and what the hell is Iceguy's post 90? How do you hope that a vote is a fake hammer when the vote is literally in front of you as, you know, a vote?

I'm pretttty sure Ice was the hero protecting scum while not looking outside the box

I'd like to hear from the midrange lots more (LLD, implosion, Panzer)

I and my 13 posts really don't like being lumped in with LLD and her 2 posts and Panzer and his 3 posts :\. Even if you don't think I have "done" anything (read: i have) it's still strange, and I find it interesting that I'm the one who hasn't "done" anything as opposed to LLD and Panzer.

Also, Iceguy, respond to 142.

incidentally, iceguy also still needs to respond to 142.

[IceGuy]

Why bother saying "I hope that's a fake hammer" when you can see right in front of your eyes that it isn't"? Why bother with that commentary?

Why not? I wasn't exactly thinking a lot when I made that post.

Already answered.

I also don't see how this is in any way relevant.

[implosion]

mm. i somehow missed that post.

Unvote

VOTE: Cheery Dog

[sword_of_omens]

sorry guys,
today was busier than i expected (coming back from the holidays and whatnot)
i'll be back at full speed on the morrow....

[Parama]

proddodge
holidays and then break ending, will try to get back to this soon

[Sixty]

~Vote Count Vi

Cheery Dog (L-2)

~ Parama, SpyreX, Panzerjager, implosion

IceGuy (L-4)

~ sword_of_omens, kanyeknowsbest,

(implosion)

sword_of_omens (L-5)

~ Maxous

Panzerjager (L-5)

~ Cheery Dog

Not Voting:

IceGuy, Lady Lambdadelta, Messiah

-You ain't nothin' but a hound prod ♪
-Lady Lambdadelta is being prodded...

--With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Battery power:

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||

(67%)

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Vote: IceGuy

Sorry >.>

[SpyreX]

Guys,

Please dont make me pull out a giant ball of words about this.

IceGuy is being THAT GUY. That doesn't make him scum. He's been far too abrasive about it. He does get a trip to the noose factory but today isn't the time for it. Cheery has way waaay more of a chance of being scum - just go reread the 5 whole pages of D1 and you can feel the wiggling.

I'm all for murderbridge, but lets start wanton slaughter after we have enough of a lead that we're not pissing it away on silly things.

If need be I'll totally unvote and I absolutely 100% promise I wont hammer immediately if Cheery gets to hammertime. Promise.

[PJ.]

IceGuy is being THAT GUY. That doesn't make him scum. He's been far too abrasive about it. He does get a trip to the noose factory but today isn't the time for it. Cheery has way waaay more of a chance of being scum - just go reread the 5 whole pages of D1 and you can feel the wiggling.

qft

[implosion]

i copied those two lines and was about to quote them and say "this." Then i saw that panzer already posted. Now i'm sad.

[Cheery Dog]

Cheery has way waaay more of a chance of being scum - just go reread the 5 whole pages of D1 and you can feel the wiggling.

What iceguy has negative chance of being scum?

[implosion]

Cheery has way waaay more of a chance of being scum - just go reread the 5 whole pages of D1 and you can feel the wiggling.

What iceguy has negative chance of being scum?

Sarcastically acting like you're above suspicion does not make you above suspicion

[Cheery Dog]

The only reason I'm suspicious if that I didn't know how to deal with the situation of what at the time was what I thought might be caught scum, but not expecting them to be that easy.

And maybe where my votes have gone today, but other people having town reads based on things I consider possibly scummy mean nothing to me.

[kanyeknowsbest]

I can see why people have him as a scumread, but I'm not sure if that's the case or not.
I'm not currently reading him as town anyway (still null), so if someone decides he should be an early lynch I'm not going to stop them.

The only reason I'm suspicious if that I didn't know how to deal with the situation of what at the time was what I thought might be caught scum, but not expecting them to be that easy.

And maybe where my votes have gone today, but other people having town reads based on things I consider possibly scummy mean nothing to me.

not seeing where you thought he was caught scum.

[sword_of_omens]

Alright…
Re-reading Cheery, he did seem to try and ignore the Mhork debacle on D1.
Even to go so far as to drop another RSV on Safety after Safety pointed out Mhork’s exaggeration..
He conveniently had Mhork as “Null” at L-1 until after the hammer, where he graduated to “felt like town made the right decision”
Funny that he almost mirrors iceguy….

I still prefer Ice, but I will settle for Cheery if I can’t get him.

[Cheery Dog]

@kkb, top line of first quote, then because I wasn't expecting him to be caught that easily I didn't follow with actually making him a scum read though I could see why he had the wagon.

[Sixty]

~Vote Count VII

Cheery Dog (L-2)

~ Parama, SpyreX, Panzerjager, implosion

IceGuy (L-3)

~ sword_of_omens, kanyeknowsbest, Lady Lambdadelta

sword_of_omens (L-5)

~ Maxous

Panzerjager (L-5)

~ Cheery Dog

Not Voting:

IceGuy,

(Lady Lambdadelta,)

Messiah

-You're The Man now, prod!
-Maxous is being prodded...

--With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Battery power:

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

|||

(58%)

[Maxous]

vig or replacement plz.

Panzer is likely town for this

unless he's scumbuddies with Ice Guy

I beleive lynching Cheery is a mistake but work away if you must, we can lynch implosion afterwards.

Ice guy I dunno. I find it hard to believe after a scum lynch that he literally has no reads, even gut reads. As in his whole 'have no reads' does sound forced?
I would take 'I have a couple of slight reads but i'm not confident in them' as quite more plausible.
On the other hand if Ice Guy is gambiting scum here, it's ridiculously risky, to the point of why the hell would he do it?

Why did'nt LLD follow up her defence of Cheery?