Newbie 1351: Hyrule's Under Attack.. Interesting..-GAME OVER

[goodmorning]

@Carey: I'd like to hear your answers. Pending reread, my scummiest read is still Fro. My towniest is probably still Mac but

where is everybodyyyyy

[TraceyLyn11]

VOTE COUNT 1.6

[L-4] Fropome: (goodmorning)

[L-4] fferyllt: (Mac)

[L-4] Deras: (CareyHammer)

[L-4] ArcAngel9: (Eye Urn)

[L-5] Mac:

[L-5] Eye Urn:

[L-4] CareyHammer: (Revenus)

[L-5] Revenus:

[L-5] goodmorning:

Not Voting:

4 (ArcAngel9, Deras, fferyllt, Fropome)

• With nine alive, it takes five to lynch.
  
• Day One's deadline: April 18, 2013 CST or in (expired on 2013-04-18 20:45:00).
  
• V/LA: Revenus ((expired on 2013-04-07 18:34:00)), CareyHammer ((expired on 2013-04-07 04:46:00)))

[TraceyLyn11]

ArcAngel9 has been prodded.

[Deras]

Deras is looking towniest to me. So townie it's actually starting to freak me out a little bit, remembering how in my previous newbie game (I was scum) players seriously underestimated me and figured I had to be naive, earnest low-experience town or something.

I'm towniest, fuck me right? lol

I'm not sure if I should be complaining about Carey, he says V/LA then posts 5 times after that wtf?

GM/ffer cooled down way too easily for me. Way, way too easily. I don't like ffer's unvote based on meta, mainly because I have a strong disdain for any meta beyond the kind that Carey shows. The people in this game are self-aware enough to use the knowledge of their meta to their own advantage, and I feel both of these players have been trying to push their metas at us too much. As it stands now after my thorough re-reading, I'm seeing them very strongly as the scum pair. In case they aren't both scum, I'm definitely leaning more towards GM being scum.

This looks interesting considering how GM and ff seem to be wearing matching outfits now, of course, the thread in the last couple of days has been mostly them, but it was that way before except before they were trying to rip each other's eyes out. Not sure if staged or honest yet, but I'd like to throw it out there again for consideration.

I have Eye and Fro as the towniest pending a re-read of their posts as I've probably focused too much on the GM/ff exchanges and Carey's behaviour and AA9 as the highest on my scumdar atm because I don't like the way she tried to push the "I bet an IC/SE is scum" at us then dissappeared when that didn't get any traction. As someone else pointed out, that'd be a great way to push a mislynch if she actually knows no IC/SE is scum.

She is active on the site though, has just been prodded and she posted less than 3 hours ago so it feels like there's a good chance she'll see this:

Vote: ArcAngel9

Rev and Mac should be coming back soon though, I hope they have a new perspective to share with us. There's still 11 days to go, but we probably should pick up the pace.

[fferyllt]

This looks interesting considering how GM and ff seem to be wearing matching outfits now, of course, the thread in the last couple of days has been mostly them, but it was that way before except before they were trying to rip each other's eyes out. Not sure if staged or honest yet, but I'd like to throw it out there again for consideration.

I can't point to a finished game at MS where I have done the same thing, so all I can tell you is that one of the ways I get reads is by provoking reactions - both from the person I'm going after and from other players. If you look back it was clearly me who started things with GM, not the other way around. The downside of doing this is that sometimes the player I sledge winds up putting me in their scum pile while I am deciding they are maybe town.

[Deras]

This looks interesting considering how GM and ff seem to be wearing matching outfits now, of course, the thread in the last couple of days has been mostly them, but it was that way before except before they were trying to rip each other's eyes out. Not sure if staged or honest yet, but I'd like to throw it out there again for consideration.

I can't point to a finished game at MS where I have done the same thing, so all I can tell you is that one of the ways I get reads is by provoking reactions - both from the person I'm going after and from other players. If you look back it was clearly me who started things with GM, not the other way around. The downside of doing this is that sometimes the player I sledge winds up putting me in their scum pile while I am deciding they are maybe town.

Ok time to come clean, other than skimming through Carey's games to check his behaviour, I've yet to read any of you guys's games I should get started on that soon^tm

[Deras]

Oh I also read a bit of that game you (ff) replaced a mafia on day 2 I think it was?

[fferyllt]

I have never replaced into a game at MS. In my first newbie game I was scum.

[Deras]

I have never replaced into a game at MS. In my first newbie game I was scum.

You're right it was GM, sorry it's getting late and being sleepy makes my brain do funny things

[ArcAngel9]

Poke received
Will be catching up in a bit

[fferyllt]

The last few pages have given me pause to wonder about certain things. I'll post some thoughts on it as soon as it's gelled.

Archangel, I don't recall being buddies with revenus. I don't know him. I feel a sense that I may be being buddied up to here and there, however.

Have your thoughts gelled yet?

[Deras]

yay 12 hours without posts, that's a thread record I think

[fferyllt]

I am hoping that it is a weekend thing. Would like to see answers to some of my questions by sometime tomorrow. If not I'll vote based on the information I currently have.

[CareyHammer]

I agree. Who is the towniest player right now? And the scummiest?

What are your answers to these questions?

Good question. Catching up.....

[CareyHammer]

@Carey: I'd like to hear your answers. Pending reread, my scummiest read is still Fro. My towniest is probably still Mac but

where is everybodyyyyy

Is that just because Fro is voting for you?

[CareyHammer]

I'm not sure if I should be complaining about Carey, he says V/LA then posts 5 times after that wtf?

I was on my way out the door friday....

[Revenus]

hey guys, just got back from Sichuan, I'm exhausted, have had about 30 minutes of sleep on the 17 hour train ride.

I did a quick skim, and I saw some people were ignoring or annoiting CH as town; this disturbs me.
It also makes me wonder if I'm right about my read on CH: it would be easy for scum to keep him around as the LYLO candidate for this game; if he's still contributing the same as he's been at LYLO, then we're fucked because then scum can easily push for his mislynch then.


Anyways, if someone could summarzie what's happened in the week I've been gone, that'd be awesome, otherwise I have like 10 pages to read.

[CareyHammer]

I'm disturbed by your disturbance.
Plus you are still voting for me.

OMGUS!

Unvote Vote Revenus.

People, please vote. It's fun. It gives info. It's the right thing to do. Vote early and often, that's my motto.

Vote tags fixed.

[CareyHammer]

Mod, please fix that.

[Revenus]

You know what would be better Carey? If you actually played the game. I can't believe people think you're town.

[Revenus]

I'm disturbed by your disturbance.
Plus you are still voting for me.

OMGUS!

Unvote Vote Revenus.[\b]


People, please vote. It's fun. It gives info. It's the right thing to do. Vote early and often, that's my motto.

The more I look at this post the more terrible it gets.

[Revenus]

Deras is looking towniest to me. So townie it's actually starting to freak me out a little bit, remembering how in my previous newbie game (I was scum) players seriously underestimated me and figured I had to be naive, earnest low-experience town or something.

Scummiest is a dead heat at the moment between Mac and ArcAngel. Both of them need to post more.

Just want to highlight again that ArcAngel in her post with her reads referred to all the new players in the third person, and all the SE/IC players as "you". With one exception: Eye.

This is actually also a really bad post.

It's like you're setting yourself up to vote Deras later. If EVERYONE thought Deras was towny, that'd be one thing, but if you alone think that he's towny, then you shouldn't be thinking this way.

Still have a townread on you, but it's back to null/town. Really bad post.

[CareyHammer]

[...]

Revenus

– I really didn’t like the way he went on with Carey, Being an SE and knowing this site meta and how things usually works here, he should been knowing already that lurking is common here.. So Just only reasoning lurking for accusing Carey as scum is not good, Leaning scum.

[...]

And to look at this game in a strategic way..
There will be 2 scums in a 9 player game.

And I am positive that there is one scum between SE’s & IC
I feel GM is town, Carey is null. Revenus would be my choice for this day’s lynch, if everyone wants to move this directly.
And there would one more scum in the rest of you.

I agree with Angel's read on Revenus. All he as done is get on my case about my play, not really posting much original content himself.

[Revenus]

[...]

Revenus

– I really didn’t like the way he went on with Carey, Being an SE and knowing this site meta and how things usually works here, he should been knowing already that lurking is common here.. So Just only reasoning lurking for accusing Carey as scum is not good, Leaning scum.

[...]

And to look at this game in a strategic way..
There will be 2 scums in a 9 player game.

And I am positive that there is one scum between SE’s & IC
I feel GM is town, Carey is null. Revenus would be my choice for this day’s lynch, if everyone wants to move this directly.
And there would one more scum in the rest of you.

I agree with Angel's read on Revenus. All he as done is get on my case about my play, not really posting much original content himself.

So I'm scum for trying to get my scumread lynched by making a case on him.


Excuse me if I don't take your OMGUS very seriously.

[fferyllt]

Deras is looking towniest to me. So townie it's actually starting to freak me out a little bit, remembering how in my previous newbie game (I was scum) players seriously underestimated me and figured I had to be naive, earnest low-experience town or something.

Scummiest is a dead heat at the moment between Mac and ArcAngel. Both of them need to post more.

Just want to highlight again that ArcAngel in her post with her reads referred to all the new players in the third person, and all the SE/IC players as "you". With one exception: Eye.

This is actually also a really bad post.

It's like you're setting yourself up to vote Deras later. If EVERYONE thought Deras was towny, that'd be one thing, but if you alone think that he's towny, then you shouldn't be thinking this way.

Still have a townread on you, but it's back to null/town. Really bad post.

My paranoia is legendary.