Gears of War Mafia - ( Game Over! )

[Piratecat]

.. How could evidence not lead to that conclusion? Slandaar hardcored tunneled us. Slandaar tried to put a fake guilty on us to lynch us during Day 2. Messiah CC'd that result and we were CC'ing way before Messiah came into play.

Aren't y'all the ones who originally suggested mutli-ball? I could totally see scum-Slandaar faking a guilty on a player he thought was scum on the other side.

no, it was either gif or ang who was asking about it.

I know you guys never read my posts but I said that it looked like a shout out yesterday. and yes I think that slaandar was banking on that we were scum. lol, we aren't.

[buldermar]

Only reason I was holding out on Bulder yesterday because it looked like he may have hinted at being cop. He obviously isn't and probably not a PR in general either.

Anyone else think Jal tracked Buldemar N1 and got no result?

This is a good catch. Doesn't clear him by any stretch though.

[buldermar]

@Buld:

Can you paraphrase your flavour without breaking mod rules?

Sure why not.

[Messiah]

Is anyone else feeling how terrible Mac's unvote of PC is? And that he didn't even put a vote on anyone else until a little later? I feel like I'm in some bizzarro universe.

Mac, you were suspicious of PC because of the 2 scum team thing, and you're suspicious of Viomi because of the lack of content? Do you have any real scumreads based on anything substantial?

[Messiah]

Can we discuss that all day yesterday Buldermar was trying to downtalk my analysis of the wagons and the gamestate, and trying to weaken any attempt at building a Slandaar wagon again? Yeah? Lets not forget that really obvious bit.

Links?

[buldermar]

I'm Captain Quentin Michaelson and I'm the leader of something called the COG Navy.

[Piratecat]

PirateCat, Goat,

Slandaar

, havingfitz, Buldermar

I'm feeling town on Goat.

Still up in the air on PC, so that probably means scum

.

If you idiots aren't willing to lynch Buldermar, can we settle for Fitz? He's a little scumbutt too.

and this is why I think

you

are scum cos town majiffy would have figured it out by now!

eta: buldey stop ninja-ing me!

[buldermar]

OMG FUCK.

Not allied to the COG. ^

What?

[buldermar]

Can we discuss that all day yesterday Buldermar was trying to downtalk my analysis of the wagons and the gamestate, and trying to weaken any attempt at building a Slandaar wagon again? Yeah? Lets not forget that really obvious bit.

Were you attempting to build a Slandaar wagon? Because that would change my opinion of you entirely.

[buldermar]

Actually I take that back - two teams possibility and all.

[Piratecat]

...because of the chance of 2 scum teams? or have we just completely forgotten about that? I know there was only one kill n2 but surely that's hinting at doc protection of some sort?

it begs the question: why would Slandaar (scum) tunnel so fucking hard on townPC if he didn't suspect that a) there was another scum team and b) PC was scum? and then fakeclaim some shit that put PC is jeopardy until Messiah disproved it. Slandaar, as much as his cases may not make sense, is not an idiot.

@Messiah: I read back, there are more scummier people. I still have doubts about them though.

Viomi has offered absolutely zero content in her posts so far. The only town like thing she has done was vote Slandaar. Which makes me lean towards an AN vote.

VOTE: AN

amazing...

this is what I said at the end of d2 and yet you still came into the game and voted us! lol

[Mac]

Is anyone else feeling how terrible Mac's unvote of PC is? And that he didn't even put a vote on anyone else until a little later? I feel like I'm in some bizzarro universe.

Mac, you were suspicious of PC because of the 2 scum team thing, and you're suspicious of Viomi because of the lack of content? Do you have any real scumreads based on anything substantial?

and you're suspicious of me because... Oh wait. I tore it apart and you ignored it.

Are you missing the part where I vote AN? Because that's a pretty substantial scumread.

[buldermar]

buldey I hate it when we fight too but the kiss but make up afterwards will be great!

supposedly you were reading the game close ennough to form a terribad terri terri terribad meta case on me on d1 but only finding mala's scummy did you forget about all this already

I don't have any overriding scum or town feelings towards Buldermar, but I sure as hell know I don't want him near endgame with the amount of circuituous, highly flawed logic her brings to this game.
Sadly, the alternative to taking him there is taking one of our many lurkers.

I don't understand what you are saying here could you plz rephrase it

I actually did forget about that.

[buldermar]

PirateCat, Goat,

Slandaar

, havingfitz, Buldermar

I'm feeling town on Goat. Still up in the air on PC, so that probably means scum.

If you idiots aren't willing to lynch Buldermar, can we settle for Fitz? He's a little scumbutt too.

What's wrong with mac?

[Piratecat]

Is anyone else feeling how terrible Mac's unvote of PC is? And that he didn't even put a vote on anyone else until a little later? I feel like I'm in some bizzarro universe.

Mac, you were suspicious of PC because of the 2 scum team thing, and you're suspicious of Viomi because of the lack of content? Do you have any real scumreads based on anything substantial?

no! it is terrible! this is why I am good with either a mac OR buldey lynch

[buldermar]

Buldermar's logic and approach to this game, while not indicative of his alignment necessarily, detracts from scumhunting as he draws attention onto himself by flailing at anyone who holds an opinion contrary to his. While it is not necessarily scummy, it is anti-town in that it muddies the waters, and therefore I would prefer not to take him to endgame.

I've just been playing poorly and being lazy in this game specifically - it's not my general approach.

[buldermar]

doesn't mean he isn't scum though

Fucking vote him then!

You just want her for yourself.

[Messiah]

Is anyone else feeling how terrible Mac's unvote of PC is? And that he didn't even put a vote on anyone else until a little later? I feel like I'm in some bizzarro universe.

Mac, you were suspicious of PC because of the 2 scum team thing, and you're suspicious of Viomi because of the lack of content? Do you have any real scumreads based on anything substantial?

and you're suspicious of me because... Oh wait. I tore it apart and you ignored it.

Are you missing the part where I vote AN? Because that's a pretty substantial scumread.

I ignored it because it was bullshit, you keep doing scummier and scummier things so I always have something fresh to comment on. You've never explained your AN read as far as I can tell, and I summed up the two that I know you've explained. Feel free to tell us why AN is a substantial scumread.

[buldermar]

Is anyone else feeling how terrible Mac's unvote of PC is? And that he didn't even put a vote on anyone else until a little later? I feel like I'm in some bizzarro universe.

Mac, you were suspicious of PC because of the 2 scum team thing, and you're suspicious of Viomi because of the lack of content? Do you have any real scumreads based on anything substantial?

I trust that you're town, and I know that you're reading this game carefully by virtue of you figuring out that I was telling the truth regarding the supposed breadcrumb, so I'm happy just sheeping you for now.

[buldermar]

PirateCat, Goat,

Slandaar

, havingfitz, Buldermar

I'm feeling town on Goat.

Still up in the air on PC, so that probably means scum

.

If you idiots aren't willing to lynch Buldermar, can we settle for Fitz? He's a little scumbutt too.

and this is why I think

you

are scum cos town majiffy would have figured it out by now!

eta: buldey stop ninja-ing me!

Well he also thinks I'm scum so...

[Mac]

...because of the chance of 2 scum teams? or have we just completely forgotten about that? I know there was only one kill n2 but surely that's hinting at doc protection of some sort?

it begs the question: why would Slandaar (scum) tunnel so fucking hard on townPC if he didn't suspect that a) there was another scum team and b) PC was scum? and then fakeclaim some shit that put PC is jeopardy until Messiah disproved it. Slandaar, as much as his cases may not make sense, is not an idiot.

@Messiah: I read back, there are more scummier people. I still have doubts about them though.

Viomi has offered absolutely zero content in her posts so far. The only town like thing she has done was vote Slandaar. Which makes me lean towards an AN vote.

VOTE: AN

amazing...

this is what I said at the end of d2 and yet you still came into the game and voted us! lol

Yeah but you also tried to set me up for being lynched. You picked up on a typo that suggested me and Jal were scum on different teams trying to work together which was bullshit.

you two seriously need to get your heads together. Mollie comes in with suggestions for multi-ball and then Mala says "Slandaar tunnelled us, we are definitely town."

[buldermar]

Is anyone else feeling how terrible Mac's unvote of PC is? And that he didn't even put a vote on anyone else until a little later? I feel like I'm in some bizzarro universe.

Mac, you were suspicious of PC because of the 2 scum team thing, and you're suspicious of Viomi because of the lack of content? Do you have any real scumreads based on anything substantial?

no! it is terrible! this is why I am good with only a mac lynch

Fixed it.

[Mac]

Is anyone else feeling how terrible Mac's unvote of PC is? And that he didn't even put a vote on anyone else until a little later? I feel like I'm in some bizzarro universe.

Mac, you were suspicious of PC because of the 2 scum team thing, and you're suspicious of Viomi because of the lack of content? Do you have any real scumreads based on anything substantial?

and you're suspicious of me because... Oh wait. I tore it apart and you ignored it.

Are you missing the part where I vote AN? Because that's a pretty substantial scumread.

I ignored it because it was bullshit, you keep doing scummier and scummier things so I always have something fresh to comment on. You've never explained your AN read as far as I can tell, and I summed up the two that I know you've explained. Feel free to tell us why AN is a substantial scumread.

Prove it's bullshit instead of just saying that and hope people will believe you.

#1457

^ That's where my suspicions begin and then they stay on PC for the day 2 lynch. Despite your claim. They started off posting heavy and now very rarely contribute at all.

[PeregrineV]

I can pretty much confirm that PirateCat is town. Just keep that in mind if I'm killed/lynched - thanks.

What?

Just before you kept calling us scum and now we are confirmed town?

What.the.hell?

^ This...

VOTE: buldermar

I'm so relieved. Can you explain your incredibly odd flip-flopping and subsequent cessation of posting yesterday? I'm willing to listen to outlandish explanations like multiple personalities, demonic possession, etc.

I already did and it's super simple. I thought PirateCat claimed to have an innocent investigation on me in her first post yesterday. If she had an innocent investigation on me, she must be town. Therefore I claimed to know that PirateCat is town. However, she then questioned this claim of mine. This suggests that what I intially thought was an innocent investigation on me being claimed in her first post really wasn't an innocent investigation on me. Therefore, I had to retract my statement that PirateCat is town and could once again vote her.

If you'd read my previous posts carefully instead of going into noob-mode and vote me, you'd see that I am indeed telling the truth. You can even read PirateCat's first post of yesterday to confirm what I'm saying. However, we both know that you aren't going to do so because you're scum and you're pretending to be retarded.

@Fitz

- I'd like to hear your response to this explanation.

[Knight of Cydonia]

Buldermar's logic and approach to this game, while not indicative of his alignment necessarily, detracts from scumhunting as he draws attention onto himself by flailing at anyone who holds an opinion contrary to his. While it is not necessarily scummy, it is anti-town in that it muddies the waters, and therefore I would prefer not to take him to endgame.

I've just been playing poorly and being lazy in this game specifically - it's not my general approach.

Which raises the question of just why you're posting so much and yet with so little actual content, whilst leading us around in logic that wouldn't look out of place in dead R'lyeh dreaming.