Khan's Wacky Xylbot II Mafia (Mini 1441) (Game Over)

[PimHel]

Now I'm sad that I never learned how to post with someone's avatar

And after one day

, we're talking about 'not-so-talkative' people ._. Bad ._.

Huge difference from what you're implying.

[Varsoon]

Now I'm sad that I never learned how to post with someone's avatar

And after one day

, we're talking about 'not-so-talkative' people ._. Bad ._.

Huge difference from what you're implying.

Hey, I'm talkative.
And, besides, it's like...
USERS CURRENTLY BROWSING THIS FORUM: Varsoon

I think people should be more active, but I won't worry about the inactives for now. Let's play long enough so that they'll get prodded, replaced, etc before we lynch based on inactivity.

[PimHel]

The first sentence was to you and Shos. Everything else was for Syry[something].
My point is that it's way too quick to mention who's part of the 'not-so-talkative' people.

[Syryana]

The first sentence was to you and Shos. Everything else was for Syry[something].
My point is that it's way too quick to mention who's part of the 'not-so-talkative' people.

I never mentioned who's part of the "not-so-talkative" people. I in no way stated that not being talkative is indicative of anything. I merely stated that I want "not-so-talkative" people to talk. If people don't talk, they can't be analyzed. Why are you making such a big deal of this?

[PimHel]

No, you didn't. But if you start talking about 'not-so-talkative' people, you should have at least players in mind.
Because it's way too early to talk about things like that. Take me for example. Just after you posted it, I was done with dinner. Before I started posting, I only had 1 post. Why? Because of my sister's birthday, staying over at my boyfriend's and work. People have lives and calling them out after one day of playing is bad.
I want the pre-game over and you, Serra and Untrod caught my interest during it. For me, it's good enough to look at it.

[Parama]

okay
someone point me to the posts that aren't setup nonsense
I only care about those

hint: setup speculation is totally useless in a randomly generated potentially bastard setup

[Varsoon]

No, you didn't. But if you start talking about 'not-so-talkative' people, you should have at least players in mind.
Because it's way too early to talk about things like that. Take me for example. Just after you posted it, I was done with dinner. Before I started posting, I only had 1 post. Why? Because of my sister's birthday, staying over at my boyfriend's and work. People have lives and calling them out after one day of playing is bad.
I want the pre-game over and you, Serra and Untrod caught my interest during it. For me, it's good enough to look at it.

Pre-game is over.

Let's keep our personal lives out of the game. ATE comes up sometimes and I'd rather it not in this one. I've seen games where scum has lurked 15 pages and made clever dodges about family and loved ones in order to dodge suspicion. We all, as players, understand that people are busy and can't lurk the forums 24/7. I think that we can also agree that if a player makes no post within about 5 days, they should be scrutinized.

With as many power roles as there are, it's an interesting set up. We, however, should play as if there are just town and mafia for now. PRs can become an issue to think about after the first day. Talking about it today will only lead to fluff discussion and won't get to the core of what needs to get done--scumhunting.

I'm going to go on a limb and say that one of the people posting so far is scum. Why? Scum often posts early on in threads instead of waiting to introduce and post. Also, it's statistically likewise, too, assuming a 1 to 3 scum/town ratio.

[Sharper]

Scum use policy lynching as an excuse to lynch town. So he's scummy, yeah.

I've always wondered what makes people think stuff like this. Do you have access to information that I don't?

You broke out the L word way too fast.

lol

!vote Untrod Tripod

Won't be very active till like Saturday as it's finals week.

[BBmolla]

hint: setup speculation is totally useless in a randomly generated potentially bastard setup

Determining the approximate of xylbot is relevent.

I'm done now obv, got everything we can imo

Lynch Monkey dood

[BBmolla]

Thoughts on mass claim?

[BBmolla]

okay
someone point me to the posts that aren't setup nonsense
I only care about those

hint: setup speculation is totally useless in a randomly generated potentially bastard setup

Btw Parama this post is shit and is as useless as setup spec

[serrapaladin]

Last game with same setup is here. Lot's of setups were posted there by KK and Katsuki. Spamming this with more setups is not cool.

Wacky isn't necessarily bastard, I think - it's just swingy and PR heavy. If your role says VT, you're most likely a VT. I don't like Syryana's "treating this as mountainous". Care to elaborate, Syr?

I"m pretty sure asking for setups is just for the sake of asking. Katsuki's attempt to ask for them last game didn't seem to be very fruitful to me.

Still waiting on Sharper.

That's not quite true - last game we did sort of solve it towards the end.

Not liking Serra voting 'with reason'.

K?

PimHel and Syryana/Varsoon's back-and-forth about activity is odd. Doesn't really strike me as something either would want to waste time over on D2 of play.

Hey, I'm talkative.
And, besides, it's like...
USERS CURRENTLY BROWSING THIS FORUM: Varsoon

Particularly this is deflecting an accusation of lurking that wasn't made. Jumpy?


Why are we PLing monkeyman?

Mass claim later, methinks.

[BBmolla]

Wacky isn't necessarily bastard, I think - it's just swingy and PR heavy. If your role says VT, you're most likely a VT.

Absolutely wrong, pay attention.

[BBmolla]

Why are we PLing monkeyman?

He's Monkeyman

[serrapaladin]

Millers and death millers get VT, cops and similar mightn't be sane, and some roles are false. That's not THAT bastardy. It's not 'insane'.

[MonkeyMan576]

Obviously no one wants to policy lynch. Policy Lynching is for people that are trolls or stupid. I am neither of those.

Unvote:

[BBmolla]

Millers and death millers get VT, cops and similar mightn't be sane, and some roles are false. That's not THAT bastardy. It's not 'insane'.

What besides cults and jester

is

bastard then. You're silly.

[shos]

!vote Varsoon

Serra brought it to my attention that Varsoon has responded too heavily to the 'accusation' of sorta-lurking.

[shos]

Also about Massclaim - no, not at all. what difference is it from any other setup in which you offer a massclaim D1??

[Syryana]

Wacky isn't necessarily bastard, I think - it's just swingy and PR heavy. If your role says VT, you're most likely a VT. I don't like Syryana's "treating this as mountainous". Care to elaborate, Syr?

I am treating this as mountainous for the moment, as there are nearly infinite possible setups with infinite possible powers/combinations/whatever. Once more information is known about possible roles (e.g. night actions or mod-confirmed day actions) I will begin to consider various roles and their contributions. However, at this point we have 13 people in a forum. We've no idea what they are, nor have any of them done anything we can verify in terms of PRs. Therefore all I have to go on is analysis of reactions, hence my statement I will treat this as mountainous.

Yes, it is likely this is extremely power heavy, but none of them are relevant as of right now.

Need I say more? Obviously my treatment of this game as mountainous will cease once we actually have some PR or night actions to work with. Read the thread.

Serra brought it to my attention that Varsoon has responded too heavily to the 'accusation' of sorta-lurking.

This is a pretty good point. I'm keeping my vote on Sharper for the moment though; dude completely ignored my questions from a couple pages ago.

[BBmolla]

Also about Massclaim - no, not at all. what difference is it from any other setup in which you offer a massclaim D1??

Balance is determined by Xylbot not by Khan.

Normal balance on the site dictates a lot of VTs.

Balance in this game dictates like 1 or 2 VTs, with one of those probably not a VT.

[MonkeyMan576]

Vote: Sharper

He did get quiet all of a sudden. Plus he questioned why lynching town is a bad thing.

[serrapaladin]

!vote Varsoon

Serra brought it to my attention that Varsoon has responded too heavily to the 'accusation' of sorta-lurking.

It's more that he responded to an 'accusation' that wasn't even made.

Sharper is also a good vote, though.

[Syryana]

Vote: Sharper

He did get quiet all of a sudden. Plus he questioned why lynching town is a bad thing.

Also don't forget to put votes in proper format. Probably not a good idea to make the mod mad in a possible bastard game

[serrapaladin]

It's really not 'bastard' in the sense you're implying though. There are some non-standard roles, is all.

KK

will not

, however, count votes in the wrong format. Even caused us a No Lynch last game...