↑leviathan93 wrote:I would be wondering if I would be thinking that scum could be in EITHER Thad OR Human at that point. I'd prefer human to Thad but even then i'm not so positive on the fact that human is scum. if he is, he is doing very well.
Levi, you were voting HD previously back when you were calling Iece town. Iece was indeed town, so what changed your mind about HD?
his posting style changed in my opinion and I don't know what to make of it other than I am not sure if my read on his was a solid as it is.
I'm not posting any differently than I was before...so, huh?
↑Nachomamma8 wrote:Why is Thad scum and why is Empking town?
ThAd's analysis in D3 seemed like he was trying to make as many things look scummy as possible, keeping options open. I didn't see any genuine attempt to understand motivations.
Empking just makes lots of sense, there seems to be a very clear thought-process behind all of his votes.
Levi's 180 turn on HD is by far the most scummy thing I've seen Today. When you take into account his defense of Pere, as well as his certainty that Iece was town, I'm leaning towards Levi/HD or Levi/ThAd as scum.
↑Nachomamma8 wrote:Why is Thad scum and why is Empking town?
ThAd's analysis in D3 seemed like he was trying to make as many things look scummy as possible, keeping options open. I didn't see any genuine attempt to understand motivations.
I have comprehensively ruled myself out of ever voting for vp baltar or levi. So I'm not sure how you are saying I am keeping my options open.
Prod gotten. and no i do disagree with both of you there. There has been a slight change in HD's play over the game. very subtle yes not obvious and of course if HD as scum would say that nothing changed. but i'm not accusing anyone here. I'm saying it happened.
I still think nacho is scummier though. The attack on me I feel is scum trying to divert the wagon upon a known townie. it has no town motivation behind it.
Only thing that really gives me pause on this wagon is PV's presence on it.
This vote came after he posted ISO #6, which was essentially a bunch of posturing to jump on an RF wagon with a tiny dig at PV. The inclusion of PV in this post is strange enough as it is.
This is the complete case from HD on PV, until he upgrades it here:
↑Human Destroyer wrote:Deflecting attention on RestFermata to SaintKerrigan, reasonless vote, adding another unexplained townread to your town pile
Which are a whole lot of things that are pretty fucking poor. I also don't like his avoidance of the Ms. M wagon; most people tried to push past it if they cared any about the PV wagon, but HD mentioned Marangal a grand total of one time. His Empking case is old and recycled, and the push on ThAd after he claims investigative role without any sort of counterclaim at all is scummy as all hell and I hate it with a burning, fiery passion.
"Playing with Nacho is like playing with a religious conservative." ~UncertainKitten
-- Fate, Vanilla Townie, was brutally stabbed by a throwing sword in endgame.
I'm also going to go out on a limb here and say that he's not bussing Empking. He wanted that lynch a hell of a lot more than he wanted the PV lynch, and has had decent interactions with pretty much everyone except for FT, who he's stuck in his town pile for the entire game for pretty much no reason. FT, I'm also wondering what the hell you mean by "basically vanilla".
"Playing with Nacho is like playing with a religious conservative." ~UncertainKitten
-- Fate, Vanilla Townie, was brutally stabbed by a throwing sword in endgame.
