Let’s go. (Again, will be posting thoughts as I read, so sorry if I repeat some logic. Starting a hard read from my post 270.)
#271: I didn’t like how weak Varsoon’s case was on Selkies, considering according to Varsoon in his 200 that Selkies was the top scum read.
#272: Majiffy says Icebox is town for pursuing something no one else was talking about. Even though Selkies was pursuing Icebox, someone I barely even talked about, just said I’d keep an eye on it. He also assumes Selkies is lining up lynches, even though he said he
thought
one of Varsoon and Icebox is town at that point. Hardly looks like a lined-up lynch.
#273: Varsoon’s words as to why you were scum are as follows:
↑ Varsoon wrote:I agree with your Icebox post, but I’m also preeeetty wary of you. Here’s why.
In a game-climate where a wagon just failed, you make a compelling case against Icebox.
Good scum-hunting,
or scum trying to start another wagon with some inertia this time?
We’ll see. We’ll see.
The bolded is the line I’m talking about. From what I read, I don’t remember you mentioning that, but instead commented saying “Varsoon’s case is crap because all he gave me was compliments.” I just felt like you really didn’t give the statement a second read and think “OH HE THINKS I’M SCUM BECAUSE OF OPPORTUNISM.”
#283: Majiffy seemingly ignoring things, saying he can’t tell what other people think, referring to Icebox (even though he’s assuming the hell out of Selkies with statements later in the argument*), and discussing RVS. Not liking Majiffy here.
*I skimmed the game as it went on before making this long post, and Majiffy did this enough for me to notice it.
#298: Majiffy assumes (hey look he does it again) that Selkies would put blame on me if Icebox were lynched and flipped town. Firstly, I don’t see that at all coming from Selkies’ play. Second, I don’t even say in my very first catch-up post that it’s a huge scum tell in the first place, so Selkies putting blame on me would be bullshit. Third, something tells me the way it’s worded, Icebox is town because Majiffy knows he is.
Yep, I’m feeling Majiffy’s starting to look scummy from this argument. It’s not scum-scum, so it’s either town-town or Selkies is town and Majiffy is scum.
#300: PoE to victory? That sounds like lining up lynches
way fucking more
than Selkies saying one of those two people were probably scum.
#302: Majiffy seems to be talking to other players about incredibly miniscule things (like discussion about RVS, pointless responses to fluff, etc.) except when it comes to Selkies. Awesome. Does it again in
#324 but doesn’t comment on the actual content of Icebox’s most recent post.
#346: Yeah…I don’t see why you think Majiffy is town here. His scum case on you is that your views aren’t the same as his, and he’s been contradicting himself the entire argument.
#355: Rach thinks that Varsoon looks like an easy lynch because he’s a newbie. Which is wrong. Varsoon doesn’t play this game like some of the newbies that make newbie mistakes all the time to get lynched.
#399: Sven is doing better from when he woke up to this post. (Not saying he won’t do better later, just thought now would be a good time to say this.)
It’s at this point that I’m thinking my vote won’t be very set in stone, may move it to Majiffy but not sure at this point.
#402: Rach’s reads here are all fence-sitting. Bad Rach. And instead prefers to search meta instead of sticking her neck out and questioning actions.
(And
Icebox beat me to it.)
#409: Varsoon
really
seems like he wants reads from people. I’ve never seen anyone push that hard for people to give reads.
#423: Yes, Rach, because 5 posts from a player [sarcasm]definitely pings really hard on a scumdar.[/sarcasm]
(Sven beats me to this in
#429)
#453: An argument from PoE could be lining up lynches if you keep your town reads. An argument from 1v1 could also be lining up lynches if it’s a situation where there’s a possible mislynch with LyLo the next day and they actually say, “Okay we’re lynching one today and the other tomorrow.” The latter definitely isn’t happening right now, and the former could happen.
*sigh* 100 posts left.
#459: Meh, I honestly didn’t remember to answer your questions three times, Orc. If you don’t believe me that’s fine. Also, I can see why you see me fence-sitting; I had been skimming the game and not really giving huge opinions on anyone except Sven.
#464: Rach quit posting pointless stuff while you expect D_O and Jen to post pointful stuff.
(
Sven beats me to this again.)
And at this point I
UNVOTE: Svenskt. Vote will be at the end once I finish the read.
#470: Varsoon switches vote from D_O back to Selkies…I don’t like this. It’s like he chose a time to vote D_O for pressure as soon as Rach did, but then he saw it wasn’t catching much attention, so he switched back. That’s more of my gut telling me that than anything, though.
(also, I know the guy you’re talking about, the one that told you scum like to post pics/gifs…not exactly the best person to listen to when it comes to scum tells. Trust me on that one.)
#477: Maybe I’m just incredibly self-centered, but the vote on me didn’t feel like much of a “I want him lynched” vote. More of a suspicious vote that seemed to be placed to get the most information. But maybe you change your mind further along.
#485: Rach trying to tell more people to participate again. My gut’s telling me that if Rach is scum (which I’m leaning ATM), D_O and Jen may be a very good place to look. (Me too, I guess, but she just started telling me to try to get more active; she’s been telling D_O and Jen that since forever and a half.)
#490: Yeah, Selkies beat me to my comment I made in this post about 470.
#494: Rach’s 17254th mention about telling others to post. Also just says more about past games and meta, no real content again. (Surprise surprise.)
#510: Varsoon’s efforts here have ups and downs. I pretty much agree with most of the post except I still think Selkies is town.
#520: Rach. You say you want 2 scum but can’t get enough reads. Half the players post a lot. Half of 2 is 1. How do you not have even a close-to-scum read that I can see from you?
#529: Awesome, Varsoon’s come to his senses about Selkies. And he’s voting Rach. Sweet, because I’m still thinking Rach-scum at this point.
#535: Um what? Any reason you quit the Selkies wagon that was losing momentum and joined the wagon that has more players on it?
#540: I know you just dropped your solid scum read on me, but no thanks, I’m too lazy to read 66 pages of a game when I’m playing in one that’s going to reach 66 pages by Monday.
#541: Your very first post after my catch up post was simply calling me town. You didn’t agree, but you never really have any reason for your townread. D_O’s in the same position, except he hasn’t posted after that.
#552: Maybe Rach can drop her D_O-scum fetish now that he posted again. And Jen posts later too.
