Micro 152 - BSG Mafia (Galactica Survives?)

[Syryana]

... I hate you.

Why couldn't you use an analogy like I did? Huhuhuh?

Sometimes you have to hit buldermar over the head with things before he gets it <3

[SafetyDance]

Hey, SD. Out of curiosity, since you claimed

Blatant attempt at role-fishing. There is no reason why I should give this up right now.

I've town-read Syry but his reactions and reads are really bad, so I'm re-considering.

Do elaborate.

For starters you're wrong about me and your vote d2 (based on d1) is bad.

Buldermar still needs to answer for how hard he seemed to have ridden fery. Don't think he can get off lightly for 825.

I think what I state in post 825 is perfectly accurate when she's scum, which is the scenario I was talking about. What is it that you think I have to answer for with respect to this post?

No it's not, you were talking about her being scum in this game. You were on her lynch, you spent the good part of 250+ posts convincing her (and the rest of town) why you think she's scum, she clearly had this crazy idea that she was the only lynch candidate. How did all that happen?

Why shouldn't you be looked at? I explained already why orc can't be, if he's scum and you're town you opened that one up and are to blame. The only other person we don't know the alignment of was inactive for most of the day.

Why wouldn't I think you should take a lot of heat for it compared to the others?

[SafetyDance]

Sorta. It depends. The name isn't irrelevant

Why not? If flavors are assigned randomly I struggle seing how it can be anything but irrelevant.

I already mentioned it, based on what my own and nero's flavor name is, our character flavor is definitely not random. Alignment is another question altogether (which is irrelevant to flavor discussion)

Hey, SD.

Out of curiosity

, since you claimed Nero's neighbor and all, what's your flavor role? Fery was Kara, Nero was Baltar, who're you?

This is utterly irrelevant for every aspect of the game related to actual alignment.

Read the quote, thanks. Besides, he might be a liar depending on what name he claims. Like William Adama, for example, would never be a Gaius neighbor.

You're right. I'm Zoe Graystone.

[Syryana]

I've town-read Syry but his reactions and reads are really bad, so I'm re-considering.

Do elaborate.

For starters you're wrong about me and your vote d2 (based on d1) is bad.

So being wrong about you is a scumtell? Also voting my greatest scumread (which I was also coincidentally voting when fery was mislynched) at the start of Day 2 when the PL material from Day 1 turned up dead is also a scumtell? Try again.

Pedit: A

Caprica

character? You're claiming a

Caprica

character?!?! Not to mention that said character was a bloody Cylon.

[AngryPidgeon]

Vote Count 2.3

Lurker [3/4] - orcinus_theoriginal, Syryana, Safety Dance
Malakittens [1/4] - buldermar

Pacifists (Not Voting): Lurker, pitoli, Malakittens

With 7 alive, its 4 to lynch

Deadline: April 24th at Noon (GMT-8)

(expired on 2013-04-24 12:00:00)

Mod Notes:
None?

[Syryana]

Also
UNVOTE:

No hammers yet today, kthx.

[SafetyDance]

I've town-read Syry but his reactions and reads are really bad, so I'm re-considering.

Do elaborate.

For starters you're wrong about me and your vote d2 (based on d1) is bad.

So being wrong about you is a scumtell? Also voting my greatest scumread (which I was also coincidentally voting when fery was mislynched) at the start of Day 2 when the PL material from Day 1 turned up dead is also a scumtell? Try again.

Pedit: A

Caprica

character? You're claiming a

Caprica

character?!?! Not to mention that said character was a bloody Cylon.

Yes.

Oh and:

[SafetyDance]

V/LA for weekend

[buldermar]

Sorta. It depends. The name isn't irrelevant

Why not? If flavors are assigned randomly I struggle seing how it can be anything but irrelevant.

Say player x in neighbor claims batman. Player b is actually batman. Player b CC's and player x could be lynched or vice Vera so one is proven wrong/right and it either condemns or confirms the other.
Then there's the route people claim stupid names that don't even fit in with a possible character.

Why would town neighbor ever fake-claim a flavor? I don't get it.

[buldermar]

Hey, SD.

Out of curiosity

, since you claimed Nero's neighbor and all, what's your flavor role? Fery was Kara, Nero was Baltar, who're you?

This is utterly irrelevant for every aspect of the game related to actual alignment.

Read the quote, thanks. Besides, he might be a liar depending on what name he claims. Like William Adama, for example, would never be a Gaius neighbor.

I don't know the flavor aspect of this game, but I'm assuming that when flavor roles are randomly assigned it means that they're randomly assigned, i.e., any one person could be any other persons neighbor. Where am I wrong?

[buldermar]

... I hate you.

Why couldn't you use an analogy like I did? Huhuhuh?

Sometimes you have to hit buldermar over the head with things before he gets it <3

I still don't get it, though.

[buldermar]

No it's not, you were talking about her being scum in this game. You were on her lynch, you spent the good part of 250+ posts convincing her (and the rest of town) why you think she's scum, she clearly had this crazy idea that she was the only lynch candidate. How did all that happen?

Why shouldn't you be looked at? I explained already why orc can't be, if he's scum and you're town you opened that one up and are to blame. The only other person we don't know the alignment of was inactive for most of the day.

Why wouldn't I think you should take a lot of heat for it compared to the others?

Are these the questions you think I have to answer with respect to my post?

[buldermar]

I already mentioned it, based on what my own and nero's flavor name is, our character flavor is definitely not random. Alignment is another question altogether (which is irrelevant to flavor discussion)

Reminder: flavor is 100% not related to this game.

[Syryana]

... I hate you.

Why couldn't you use an analogy like I did? Huhuhuh?

Sometimes you have to hit buldermar over the head with things before he gets it <3

I still don't get it, though.

FuriousFalcon is obligated to say that flavor is not related to the game. I'm personally not convinced this applies to the names of the characters. We have two confirmed town, Kara Thrace and Gaius Baltar. Their roles (VT and Miller Neighborizer) currently correspond at least superficially to their character roles in the show. I wanted to hear what name SD threw out there, because it's incredibly unlikely that certain names would be the neighbor of Gaius Baltar (e.g. William Adama, Laura Roslin). Nor would I find it likely that certain names would be town names (e.g. Brother Cavil, Simon).

That's why I wanted to know SD's flavor name.

[buldermar]

FuriousFalcon is obligated to say that flavor is not related to the game. I'm personally not convinced this applies to the names of the characters.

Wait, what? How is he supposedly "obligated"? If the flavor isn't completely random as he insinuates then this is by definition a bastard game since he's then been deliberately misinforming us.

@Mod: is this a bastard game?

[Syryana]

Bah, that came out poorly. I don't think this is a bastard game, and my apologies to AP for implying such.

Buldermar, I think there's a correlation between the role name and alignment. That's all I'm trying to say here.

[Selkies]

LOL

"Rage after finding fery lynched"

You thought her scum, SD.

Do you remember that??

[orcinus_theoriginal]

i'm alt slipping all over the place

[Selkies]

I already mentioned it, based on what my own and nero's flavor name is, our character flavor is definitely not random. Alignment is another question altogether (which is irrelevant to flavor discussion)

Reminder: flavor is 100% not related to this game.

I thought you lynched fery based on her roleclaim

You filthy, filthy, filthy

[Selkies]

Oh wait

Never mind

God I need to put more effort into this game

[orcinus_theoriginal]

Lets mass claim rolenames

What do you guys think

[AngryPidgeon]

@Mod: is this a bastard game?

No, it is not.

To clear up any confusion, when I said flavor was unrelated I mean whatever I write for updates.

Role flavor may or may not be relevant to the game, but I will guarantee the game is not breakable by flavor.

[orcinus_theoriginal]

Lets mass claim rolenames

What do you guys think

Laura Roslin

Popcorn buldermar

[orcinus_theoriginal]

Gaius Baltar as neighbor makes a lot of sense

[Syryana]

What do you intend to get out of massclaiming rolenames, Orc?

Pedit: It does, considering he had a Playboy model in his head telling him what to do.