Gears of War Mafia - ( Game Over! )

[Bacde]

it sucks that its really easy for town to make a quick post w/ their thoughts, doesn't it majiffy?

its like so easy for me to make a case about why I think you are scum

because I actually do

[Majiffy]

1) Based on your interactions w/ piratecat yesterday I figured one of the two of you were mafia (and now piratecat is dead)
2) You pushed on buldermar despite him being town, when I think you should have seen that buldermar was town and I think you should understand why I also saw buldermar as town
3) You are pushing on me today with no reasoning and now are acting like I am "confirmed" scum despite you having no reasoning to hop the BW in the first place
4) You are actually pretty good at reading me when I am town, which you have failed to do this game (because yesterday everyone was like "LOLZ LYNCH BULDER GET BACDE NEXT" which you decided to just slip into w/ everyone else)

basically, I can understand where KoC is coming from, but you I have no idea

1) Which interactions are suspect? Quotes, please. And reasons to support.
2) Buldermar was really scummy. This is such a shit argument. Also you've yet to explain WHY I should see buldermar as town.
3) I have reasoning, so this argument is also void.
4) I've only played like one other game with you... where the fuck are you pulling all these stupid one-game meta arguments from? (see: Viomi, now me)

Die scum, die.

[Bacde]

if you are gonna make me go through the effort of "quoting" and "reasons to support" and stuff like that then you have to do it too

I'm not going to talk to you more about point 2) because it should be really fucking obvious what I'm referring to here. There is a site-wide rule against talking more about point 2 so I'm not gonna do it.

[Bacde]

I like how you responded to me to try to discredit my case

but you never actually came up with your own about me

you look like a proactive town player to me

oh wait

[Majiffy]

if you are gonna make me go through the effort of "quoting" and "reasons to support" and stuff like that then you have to do it too

What would you like me to quote to support?

I'm not going to talk to you more about point 2) because it should be really fucking obvious what I'm referring to here.

Nah, that ain't gonna fly. The wagon went through because a lot of people felt Buldermar was scummy; you're in the minority, you explain yourself.

There is a site-wide rule against talking more about point 2 so I'm not gonna do it.

Cop-out. What did he do

in this game

that was so town I should have seen it?

I like how you responded to me to try to discredit my case

but you never actually came up with your own about me

Well there's this. And this. And a few other spots in the past in my ISO.

[Bacde]

There is a site-wide rule against talking more about point 2 so I'm not gonna do it.

Cop-out. What did he do in this game that was so town I should have seen it?

he was being incompetent and wasn't caught in a game-affecting lie, just a dumb one about explaining his reads

Buldermar appears competent as scum, he really does

Also I just remembered that you wanted him lynched after he had a scum-read on you (but wasn't able to fully explain it to your satisfaction)

why are you trying to get everyone with a scum-read on you lynched?

[Majiffy]

he was being incompetent and wasn't caught in a game-affecting lie, just a dumb one about explaining his reads

Buldermar appears competent as scum, he really does

Also I just remembered that you wanted him lynched after he had a scum-read on you (but wasn't able to fully explain it to your satisfaction)

why are you trying to get everyone with a scum-read on you lynched?

Why is incompetence town?
Why was the lie not game-affecting, given that it had to do with his reads in-the-game?

Argument from Bulder-Competent ergo Incompetent-Town is faulty.

I wanted him lynched for a while. Him pushing on me for bullshit reasons just gave weight for other people to join on.

Why are all the scummy people in the game trying to point fingers at me?

[Bacde]

lol the way you use logic confirms you as scum

You aren't using logic to guide your reads, you are using it as a tool to PROVE that other's arguments can TECHNICALLY be considered incorrect

its the same way how you said you caught buldermar in a "lie"--well the lie was a little white lie that really didn't affect the game that much yet you turned it into a big deal so he got lynched for it

the way you repeat "he was scummy" over and over again is indicative of the way that

you are avoiding taking the blame

for buldermar's mislynch. And you are clearly trying to diffuse the impetus behind the buldermar lynch to hide better.

Guess what buckaroo--he wasn't scummy. He was just misinterpreted

You are harping on me to talk about something that I'm not allowed to talk about.

I refuse to talk about an ongoing game

but I DO think you had the capability to see that buldermar was town in that situation, and I believe you purposely pushed to have him lynched to further your scumgenda

[Majiffy]

lol the way you use logic confirms you as scum

Oh god! He's dismantling my argument with valid analysis! How

scummy!

You aren't using logic to guide your reads, you are using it as a tool to PROVE that other's arguments can TECHNICALLY be considered incorrect

Like how logic is normally used. Gotcha.

its the same way how you said you caught buldermar in a "lie"--well the lie was a little white lie that really didn't affect the game that much yet you turned it into a big deal so he got lynched for it

Problem?

the way you repeat "he was scummy" over and over again is indicative of the way that

you are avoiding taking the blame

for buldermar's mislynch. And you are clearly trying to diffuse the impetus behind the buldermar lynch to hide better.

Kind of like how you keep repeating "you should have known he was town" over and over again, because you are avoiding the obvious and trying to push a mislynch on me.

Guess what buckaroo--he wasn't scummy. He was just misinterpreted

Sure thing brah.

You are harping on me to talk about something that I'm not allowed to talk about.

I refuse to talk about an ongoing game

Then maybe you should bring up something that's rooted in this game, yeah?

but I DO think you had the capability to see that buldermar was town in that situation, and I believe you purposely pushed to have him lynched to further your scumgenda

Right, well, I'm going to have to disagree with you there.

[Ms Marangal]

HEY GUYS

here's an idea, instead of having town fight, why don't we lynch someone who has tried to deflect the Slandaar wagon the first day. hasn't done much the second day, and is absent to day entirely. he goes by the name of Qwints.

Bacde, you are retarded if you expect Majiffy to know that you're town. further more for him to expect that Buldemar was town, because guess what? Molliecat thought he was scum, I thought he was scum and so did a few others which is why he was lynched. get over it and lynch Qwints

[Majiffy]

I'm ok with a Qwints lynch. But we really should be lynching Bacde first.

[Ms Marangal]

No Jiffy, I already sheeped you, it's time for you to sheep me!

[Ms Marangal]

and Bacde is retardedly town

[Bacde]

and Bacde is

retardedly town

absolutely correct on both words

[Majiffy]

No Jiffy, I already sheeped you, it's time for you to sheep me!

Lynch better go through.

[Majiffy]

VOTE: Qwints

[Bacde]

this is honestly the first I've heard about qwints

I dunno who is really in this game and I didn't see d1

[CryoChemist]

Bacde isn't obv town at all. That said, we are always up for a qwints lynch.

VOTE: qwints

[Ms Marangal]

I have been talking about him the entire damn game Dammit. Qwints is scum, Jiffy is not. stop arguing with him and get onto the scum wagon

Pedit: YAY!!

[Ms Marangal]

Viomi come back to the Qwints wagon please?

[Bacde]

lol ms marangal you are very helpful this game

although it is hard for me to believe that you, and the three people following you, can all somehow be town

[Majiffy]

Says the self-admitted retard.

[Bacde]

I never said that

[Majiffy]

and Bacde is

retardedly town

absolutely correct on both words

[Viomi]

Qwints today, Bacde tomorrow...