Micro 152 - BSG Mafia (Galactica Survives?)

[Malakittens]

You didn't have a problem when Orc acc slipped and never quoted it..

[buldermar]

You didn't have a problem when Orc acc slipped and never quoted it..

I'd like for him to do it too - I didn't even realize he acc slipped.

[buldermar]

I mean it's common sense that if you accidentally post from a different account, you post the same content from your actual account so that it's available when someone ISO you. I don't get why I am even having this discussion... Are you being obnoxious because I'm voting you or something?

[Malakittens]

I get pissed off when someone calls one person out for doing something, but doesn't call another person out for doing the same fucking thing. Regardless of whether or not you didn't see it.. He did it double as many times as I did and if you were reading the thread you would have saw him doing it.

This has nothing to do with you voting me.

Also I'm a few mins from her house so yeah.

[Syryana]

Alright, here's my beef with orc. As you said, he switched his read on both you and SD at the start of the day. He somehow figured out SD was the neighbor of Nero almost as soon as the Day started. He equally quickly blew the Nero NK onto you and off of SD, because "why would SD kill neighbor lololol". He hasn't mentioned SD since, even though SD claimed the scummiest rolename in the game thus far (Zoe Graystone was a Caprica character, not a BSG character). He scumreads pitoli and has ignored repeated requests to give out his read on her until #1085, where he gave a half-assed read based on waffling and her popcorn choice. I also really don't like his "I'm busy, sorry guys, I'll just sheep Syr". I don't buy this after his D1 frenzy with buld/fery, nor do I think town orcinus swarmed by games would just stop giving a shit about one of them. I think he's civic minded enough to replace out if that really were the case (yes it's subjective, but it's a vibe I've got). I also distrust his "syr is obvtown, I'll sheep him" because I'm a paranoid bastard.

[Malakittens]

My biggest beef is the fact I have never seen his town play as jumpy as it is right now. Day 1 he voted all of the player list, but Buld and somewhat of SD.

[Malakittens]

I'm not 100% sure of SD's alignment.

vigbait

I kept coming back to this post when reading his iSo.

[Syryana]

I'm not 100% sure of SD's alignment.

vigbait

I kept coming back to this post when reading his iSo.

Why?

[Malakittens]

Feels off in my gut, but can't pinpoint why.

[Syryana]

Well if you put that in conjunction with his Roslin claim and my recent post, it seems like he was already planning to NK Nero and claim vig if he ever got any heat for it.

[buldermar]

Alright, here's my beef with orc. As you said, he switched his read on both you and SD at the start of the day. He somehow figured out SD was the neighbor of Nero almost as soon as the Day started. He equally quickly blew the Nero NK onto you and off of SD, because "why would SD kill neighbor lololol". He hasn't mentioned SD since, even though SD claimed the scummiest rolename in the game thus far (Zoe Graystone was a Caprica character, not a BSG character). He scumreads pitoli and has ignored repeated requests to give out his read on her until #1085, where he gave a half-assed read based on waffling and her popcorn choice. I also really don't like his "I'm busy, sorry guys, I'll just sheep Syr". I don't buy this after his D1 frenzy with buld/fery, nor do I think town orcinus swarmed by games would just stop giving a shit about one of them. I think he's civic minded enough to replace out if that really were the case (yes it's subjective, but it's a vibe I've got). I also distrust his "syr is obvtown, I'll sheep him" because I'm a paranoid bastard.

That's in accordance with how I read it. My main issue is the fact that I really give credit to ff's reads, and she read him as town. If we pretend that he's scum, does this almost guarantee SD being his partner in your opinion?

[pitoli]

I don't understand why Orc as scum would want to suddenly stop giving a frak, I mean after Day 1 ended it looked like he had enough power to lead next day's lynch.

[buldermar]

I don't understand why Orc as scum would want to suddenly stop giving a frak, I mean after Day 1 ended it looked like he had enough power to lead next day's lynch.

If you were scum-orc and you had night-killed Nero, what would you do differently?

[Syryana]

That's in accordance with how I read it. My main issue is the fact that I really give credit to ff's reads, and she read him as town. If we pretend that he's scum, does this almost guarantee SD being his partner in your opinion?

The problem with this is that fery's reads stopped yesterday. I had him as town at the end of yesterday too, but some of his latest posts have caused me to reconsider. Fery didn't have that luxury.

I feel like you should have realized this already.

Also, his partner if he is scum would be SD... or you.

[buldermar]

That's in accordance with how I read it. My main issue is the fact that I really give credit to ff's reads, and she read him as town. If we pretend that he's scum, does this almost guarantee SD being his partner in your opinion?

The problem with this is that fery's reads stopped yesterday. I had him as town at the end of yesterday too, but some of his latest posts have caused me to reconsider. Fery didn't have that luxury.

I feel like you should have realized this already.

Also, his partner if he is scum would be SD... or you.

I doubt that he changed alignment over night so if ff's reads were initially accurate, they necessarily must still be.

So, if SD is scum, how likely is orc to be his partner?

[Syryana]

I doubt that he changed alignment over night so if ff's reads were initially accurate, they necessarily must still be.

So, if SD is scum, how likely is orc to be his partner?

lolwot. lolWOT. LOLWOT.

So if he was town yesterday, he's town today? If fery was right about him yesterday, she's right about him today? Could you BE more banal? This whole statement of the obvious rests on the assumption fery was right and wouldn't have changed her mind about orc based on what he said today. Assuming fery's reads were right simply because she flipped town is very sloppy.

An SD scumflip implicates orc or pitoli. An orc flip would implicate SD or buldermar.

[orcinus_theoriginal]

Stuff:

Yes, because assuming big flavor names are PRs worked out so nicely for fery
Syr, what did you find suspicious about pitoli?
I popcorned Buldermar because he had no flavor knowledge and if he was scum that would be the only way I would be catching him
Yes Buldermar, you did take a long time to claim. You did a burst of posts...stopped halfway (never before) and then came back the next day to claim. You guys can go check it if you want

You know what, I'm just going to PoE my way to victory here

VOTE: Lurker

If you want me to replace out I can/will.

[orcinus_theoriginal]

And yes, Syr, if my alignment was town yesterday my alignment is also town today.

[orcinus_theoriginal]

Alright, here's my beef with orc. As you said, he switched his read on both you and SD at the start of the day. He somehow figured out SD was the neighbor of Nero almost as soon as the Day started. He equally quickly blew the Nero NK onto you and off of SD, because "why would SD kill neighbor lololol". He hasn't mentioned SD since, even though SD claimed the scummiest rolename in the game thus far (Zoe Graystone was a Caprica character, not a BSG character). He scumreads pitoli and has ignored repeated requests to give out his read on her until #1085, where he gave a half-assed read based on waffling and her popcorn choice. I also really don't like his "I'm busy, sorry guys, I'll just sheep Syr". I don't buy this after his D1 frenzy with buld/fery, nor do I think town orcinus swarmed by games would just stop giving a shit about one of them. I think he's civic minded enough to replace out if that really were the case (yes it's subjective, but it's a vibe I've got). I also distrust his "syr is obvtown, I'll sheep him" because I'm a paranoid bastard.

I didn't understand the Nero nightkill and I still don't, and that threw me off on Buldermar completely. I've only been in two games with a NK as off as that--both times, the obvtown player was scum. Which makes sense, because you kill someone who impacts the game the least if you're obvtown

J said that I would be willing to vote SD based on role claim (I think I did or at least I meant to)

Why WOULD SD kill neighbor? And miller town+scum neighbor just doesn't make sense

Yes I scumread pitoli. Do you have something to say about this?

[AngryPidgeon]

Vote Count 2.5

Lurker [2/4] - orcinus_theoriginal, Safety Dance
Malakittens [1/4] - buldermar

Pacifists (Not Voting): Lurker, pitoli, Malakittens, Syryana

With 7 alive, its 4 to lynch

Deadline: April 24th at Noon (GMT-8)

(expired on 2013-04-24 12:00:00)

Mod Notes:
*SafetyDance is V/LA through the weekend
*Malak is V/LA to Tuesday

@Mod - please make it clear which player in this game posted from pirate mollie.

Malakittens is Pirate Cat.

Lets make a hustle to not alt-slip though guys

[orcinus_theoriginal]

Read in above post is past tense. I don't anymore.

I think I'm going to assume Buldermar town for a bit, even though the Nero NK implicated him heavily. I would be open to a SD lynch based in everything.

For neighbor, I have an excellent memory of game events. Remembering neto's awk talks about sd wasn't hard

[Syryana]

Read in above post is past tense. I don't anymore.

I think I'm going to assume Buldermar town for a bit, even though the Nero NK implicated him heavily. I would be open to a SD lynch based in everything.

For neighbor, I have an excellent memory of game events. Remembering neto's awk talks about sd wasn't hard

So you want to kill Lurker or SD, correct?

[orcinus_theoriginal]

Yep

[orcinus_theoriginal]

What exactly is this case on mala? I'm not very good at reading right now

[Syryana]

What changed your mind on pitoli?