Open 488: Pick Your Poison [GAME OVER]

[Bacde]

^^I understand the reasoning behind your vote

I really do

but I'm more interested in lynching scum, skilled scum at that

which is why we need to lynch AP

[mastin2]

By the way, just for kicks, I'm going to call AP and Bacde as two of the three scum for now.
Why?

No reason, really. Just Mastin throwing out a crazy theory for posterity so that if it SOMEHOW turned out to be right, I can go, "I told you so!"
It's got no real basis in logic. Just my insane gut logic saying the AP-Bacde routine is odd.

Now watch me read the thread and call them both town.

[Bacde]

^^lol mastin you better not have replaced in at AP's request

[mastin2]

Nah, not this time. He did cause me to replace in, but it was by stalking this time.

(Sorta. His name caught my eye as did yours, and I took a look, determined this game might be interesting and fun, and saw that there was need for a replacement.)

[Bacde]

Do you promise it was cuz his name caught your eye?

and not because he asked you?

this is important to me

[fuzzybutternut]

I should have just focused on my Great Vote Count Analysis. But no...

I'm going to re-read the thread. Consult my notes. Do something. Maybe find a way to explain why fuzzy sucks.

But first.

vote fuzzy

Opportunistic trick.

lol

[Bacde]

^^Why is that a funny vote to you?

[mastin2]

Do you promise it was cuz his name caught your eye?

and not because he asked you?

this is important to me

Yes, Bacde, yes.

'Sides. If we were scum together again, I'd be mindlessly sheeping him, not calling him scum with you blindly.

[fuzzybutternut]

^^Why is that a funny vote to you?

because it wasn't an "opportunistic vote"

[Bacde]

^^Why is that a funny vote to you?

because it wasn't an "opportunistic vote"

why not?

[Bacde]

Do you promise it was cuz his name caught your eye?

and not because he asked you?

this is important to me

Yes, Bacde, yes.

'Sides. If we were scum together again, I'd be mindlessly sheeping him, not calling him scum with you blindly.

Actually I have meta that disagrees with this

but I'll take your point into consideration

[mastin2]

Oh, and by the way, have initial reads. (Don't take this as the holy bible when I'm NK'd, since this is still purely off the first two pages. )

Fuzzy-AP feels like {one alignment} vs {opposite alignment}.
Slimer I *think* is town, but I can't tell for certain yet. Baboon (GNR)'s slightly town, Scott's town unless AP's scum (in which case he could be scum with AP but is more likely town), Shisou (FuDu) is likely (though not definitely) scum, and PimHel is definitely town.

[Bacde]

wanna help me lynch my partner? I never thought I'd say this but AP is deadweight to my team, he needs to go

[fuzzybutternut]

^^Why is that a funny vote to you?

because it wasn't an "opportunistic vote"

why not?

because I said.

[Bacde]

^^good answer

[mastin2]

wanna help me lynch my partner? I never thought I'd say this but AP is deadweight to my team, he needs to go

Dammit, you have no clue how tempting it is to

bus

vote AP for me right now, but I

promised not to lynch scumbuddies

want to not lynch him D1.

[AngryPidgeon]

Mastin, if you are done trolling elsewhere, read the thread. This game is stalled and desperately needs new opinions.

I won't let this game be a repeat of _ongoing_ for me where I keep responding to

NAcho

Bacde who keeps tunneling on me and my reads never develop because no one interacts with me. I'm taking the gloves off now:
Im not getting lynched this game. Not today, not tomorrow. If you even remotely think Im scum, then vote me.

Im not dealing with your crap about me deserving a pass to be looked at later.

Read the fing game or I policy shove you for your currently pro-scum play.
Your talk about meta policy wrt me is trite. See above.

[Bacde]

Mastin aint trolling, as much as he is joking about his reasons

AP if you didn't want to be lynched then you shouldn't have been randomly assigned a scum PM

@Mastin, why do you feel like fuzzy/AP are of different alignments?

[AngryPidgeon]

^^lol mastin you better not have replaced in at AP's request

This did not happen.

By the way, just for kicks, I'm going to call AP and Bacde as two of the three scum for now.
Why?

Absolutely pointless posting. There is no content worth smokescreening, mastin. If one of us is scum, then vote it.

Fuzzy-AP feels like {one alignment} vs {opposite alignment}.

Ok, why is fuzzy scummy?

Shisou (FuDu) is likely (though not definitely) scum

I can work with this.

[AngryPidgeon]

UNVOTE: KBW
VOTE: Fuduzn

[AngryPidgeon]

Also Bacde might not be town. I take back all of that. If one of Bacde/mastin flips scum, the other needs to go.

Bacde is never this confident as town. Mastin/Bacde feel awkward as hell and I know mastin is more capable than what he is giving me here.

[Psyche]

^^Why is that a funny vote to you?

because it wasn't an "opportunistic vote"

Okay, read your iso as an unbiased observer and make the case that your vote wasn't opportunistic.

I'm very interested by the erratic way you're responding to things.

[Psyche]

Mastin, if you are done trolling elsewhere, read the thread. This game is stalled and desperately needs new opinions.

I won't let this game be a repeat of _ongoing_ for me where I keep responding to

NAcho

Bacde who keeps tunneling on me and my reads never develop because no one interacts with me. I'm taking the gloves off now:
Im not getting lynched this game. Not today, not tomorrow. If you even remotely think Im scum, then vote me.

Im not dealing with your crap about me deserving a pass to be looked at later.

Read the fing game or I policy shove you for your currently pro-scum play.
Your talk about meta policy wrt me is trite. See above.

Oh, look AP is playing badass.

vote AP

[mastin2]

@Mastin, why do you feel like fuzzy/AP are of different alignments?

Calling it as I see it, Bacde.

And currently see AP as scum. For instance, not dealing with the "put off to later". He of all people should know why I do so; if he is town this game it's a perfect example of it in motion. Simply put--he's not a player I like to make a definitive call on early-on. Least of all when we're apparently close to a night phase where the very real possibility of me being NK'd when my reads are incomplete is present.

Normally I see AP as being town; I don't see that at all this game. Not with any of his interactions with anyone. If for once in my career my first read on AP is an accurate read on AP? Sure, yeah, lynching him's all fine and nice. If as in previous games my first read on AP is incorrect and he's town? Exactly why I don't want to lynch him right now.

[AngryPidgeon]

Also, fuzzy is town. Not letting mastin/Bacde hedge that one in. He is a super logical player and his stream of thoughts posting reads REALLY genuine. Hes very similar to Rob13. I'd expect scum fuzzy to be way more cautious and analytical about everything.