Newbie 1356 (OVER)

[Mutleyddmc]

While I am suspicious of you varsoon, as I stated earlier for me you are not a day 1 lynch. I also agree with those 3 you are split on. I am sure there is 1 scum in there. Therefore we stand a better chance lynching one of those 3. I find it hard with their voting that none of them are scum.

Preference -- Freezing Hell

DDDP
Dexter

I realise two posts before this I said dexter over DDDP. However gut feeling says DDDP. Logically it should be dexter though.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

I'm not reading PP's 156

Enforcing the moderator's rules?

Unless the mod has a rule that says “don’t be an idiot writing massive tomes when a few lines works just as well”, no.

~~

I’m more than a little bit baffled how Dexter and I go from the two least scummiest players on Muttley’s list to suddenly two of the three players he’s most willing to lynch. Frankly it’s a town-tell that he’s so massively inconsistent but immensely aggravating to anyone with any common sense.

[Mutleyddmc]

Well yes that is weird but its because I looked bac kat something I hadn't previously. You two wouldn't be in the top 3 of my scum list. However as explained I think theres 1 scum in you dexter and FH. FH combined with shaboo is hugely above anyone else so he will likely be the only vote I make now.

[Mutleyddmc]

In a way it works like this. From me looking at post content etc you two stayed quite low on my list. Then I looked at voting patterns and I got 3 names that hit what I was looking for. 1 was my scum read. 2 were town reads. Hence I feel I've found scum in FH. Thats why when I listed you three you two were even given a space between him and you.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

In a way it works like this. From me looking at post content etc you two stayed quite low on my list. Then I looked at voting patterns and I got 3 names that hit what I was looking for. 1 was my scum read. 2 were town reads. Hence I feel I've found scum in FH. Thats why when I listed you three you two were even given a space between him and you.

It strikes me that if you see three players do X and two of those players are your most confident town reads than perhaps X is not a scumtell.

[Mutleyddmc]

Or I got you two wrong. More likely however is that I was only looking for 1 person in that group of 3 people to start with so no I can't agree with you.

[Mutleyddmc]

You and dexter also weren't confident town reads btw. In actual fact as I said a case could be made for all 9 of us right now.

[Varsoon]

What if this is some crazy setup where we're all scum but we just don't know it?

Anyway, DDDP, how do you feel about FH?

[Mutleyddmc]

I played a game opposite to that once, where we were all vanilla, and thought the doctor was amazing etc and we were all rubbish for lynching town constantly.

[freezing-hell]

I could see this, and I find FH's

posts a bit suspicious too, since he's clearly putting a lot down in a little time

. While I like the questions you've been asking, I'm also skeptical of the vote on me and

how you entered thread with several posts prodding and calling out certain players.

I am suspicious because I post a lot in little time and because I've entered the thread calling out certain players.. The "I'm skeptical about his vote" also sounds meh to me. I raised my points about you already. You just don't read them apparently. Even asking me to quote them. Which means you've not been reading the thread( but you do, since you like my questions according to your own words.) Kinda strange how you then missed the questions directed to you.

I'm pretty suspicious of people on my wagon, RC's, and Muttley's, and from some PoE I've whittled it down to
Paid Pyro - Has always been on my wagon. /shrug.
Shaboos - Originally on my wagon, left it for RC's wagon, then was replaced by FH who hopped on my wagon and put me at L-1.
DDP - Was on the Muttley Wagon, then swapped to Shaboos wagon with RC, then to my wagon.

[quoted]Actually, the fact that FH put me at L-1 and didn't say anything about it really strikes me hard.
It makes me seriously consider FH's status as town, since my wagon's an easy push AND since Shaboos' votes were largely opportunistic as well.[/quote]
Granted, I should've mentioned that I put you on L-1. That was a mistake on my part.
Why do you think you are an easy push? And Shaboos' votes were largely opportunistic, hmm?? He voted twice. Once in RVS. And once on RC when she started acting weird. You make it sound a lot more than it is.

Also, I'm at L-1, so if anyone wants to ask me questions regarding my alignment, or to discern my alignment, please do so before unvoting me or hammering.

I posted the questions already. I am not going to go back and find them for you. If you're town then it's your responsibility to read the thread and analyze posts; not mine. Your reluctance to do so, looks to me as avoidance.

While I am suspicious of you varsoon, as I stated earlier for me you are not a day 1 lynch. I also agree with those 3 you are split on. I am sure there is 1 scum in there. Therefore we stand a better chance lynching one of those 3. I find it hard with their voting that none of them are scum.

Preference -- Freezing Hell
DDDP
Dexter

So, you'd rather vote for FH than DDDP and Dexter?

Honestly, FH and DDDP are top of my list.
In fact, I don't know why I didn't do this in the post I made earlier when I made a case on FH. Guess it'd seem a bit OMGUS? Whatever, doesn't mean my case isn't a solid one.

You seemed quite eager on PP before, yet you change when Mutley is telling his two suspects. Sheeping a bit here, hm? Also, town doesn't have to worry about looking OMGUS. Build a fine case and you're fine. Yours isn't fine. Neither was the one you had on PP. You're grasping at straws. But please do continue your 'scum-hunting', I'm sure you'll point us straight to your scum buddy.

[freezing-hell]

Unless the mod has a rule that says “don’t be an idiot writing massive tomes when a few lines works just as well”, no.

I see. Thought you didn't like the: 'no hidden text' rule, with all those spoilers. Oh and wanna share your reads on the mafia choo-choo wagon?

[freezing-hell]

@mist, dexter, zoggoth: Who is your top suspect at the moment?

[Varsoon]

FH, good points.
Will write more later when I have time.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

What if this is some crazy setup where we're all scum but we just don't know it?

Anyway, DDDP, how do you feel about FH?

He's not one of the two people I'd really like to lynch (you, Mist) and he's not one of my town reads (Muttley, PP, RC) but he's closer to the second group than the first.

Unless the mod has a rule that says “don’t be an idiot writing massive tomes when a few lines works just as well”, no.

I see. Thought you didn't like the: 'no hidden text' rule, with all those spoilers. Oh and wanna share your reads on the mafia choo-choo wagon?

Nah, no hidden text generally means something where you're trying to communicate in a way that only one other person will find (basically scum can't daytalk in thread through invisible text or crazy codes that allow them to communicate full sentances and thoughts that no one else can see). I have absolutely no idea what you mean by "mafia choo-choo" wagon, is that the Varsoon wagon or is it the wagon on you?

[Zoggoth]

I'm back, sorry for the lack of posts recently. Reading through and should have a decent post ready within a few hours.

[freezing-hell]

@DDP: Meant the Varsoon wagon.
@Zoggoth:Looking forward to that post.

[Messiah]

Newbie 1356 - Vote Count 1.11

---

Varsoon [L-1]

- Paid Pyro, RadiantCowbell, Debonair Danny DiPietro, freezing-hell
freezing-hell [L-3] - Mutleyddmc, Varsoon

Not Voting (3):

Zoggoth, Mist7676, dexter9264

With nine alive it takes

five

to lynch.

---

Deadline:

(expired on 2013-04-24 20:00:00)

[Varsoon]

Lynch me and I'll flip town.
What information will you get out of that?


We've got another week, feel free to look into other possible scumspects.

[Mutleyddmc]

Zoggoth never delivered I know someone mentioned him possibly buddying up with varsoon.
If varsoon does get lynched and flips scum. I will seriously look I to zoggoth. I know he will say real life came in to play but that's an easy out. I reckon that it's more he couldn't think of a decent enough post to try and help his mate and not link himself either?

[freezing-hell]

Lynch me and I'll flip town.
What information will you get out of that?


We've got another week, feel free to look into other possible scumspects.

Then by all means, continue to do so. I don't think you'll flip town.
Anyway, why haven't you answered some questions yet?

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

@DDP: Meant the Varsoon wagon.

Well I think I've pretty much answered that and if I was bothered by the people on the wagon surely I would be off it.

Varsoon: show, don't tell.

[Varsoon]

@DDP: Meant the Varsoon wagon.

Well I think I've pretty much answered that and if I was bothered by the people on the wagon surely I would be off it.

Varsoon: show, don't tell.

The only way to show is for you to lynch me and see.
This is a game of telling.

[freezing-hell]

@DDP: Meant the Varsoon wagon.

Well I think I've pretty much answered that and if I was bothered by the people on the wagon surely I would be off it.

Varsoon: show, don't tell.

The only way to show is for you to lynch me and see.
This is a game of telling.

If you flip town, who do you hope we lynch next?

[Varsoon]

@DDP: Meant the Varsoon wagon.

Well I think I've pretty much answered that and if I was bothered by the people on the wagon surely I would be off it.

Varsoon: show, don't tell.

The only way to show is for you to lynch me and see.
This is a game of telling.

If you flip town, who do you hope we lynch next?

Right now, I feel like Freezing Hell is scum, because I tend to feel that at least one of the active players is scum and at least one lurker tends to be scum.
If I am lynched, I hope everyone who is town spends more time and puts in more posts that'll help make scum and town clearer.

[freezing-hell]

What's your opinion about mist?