Ok, so I haven't actually read Tammy's ISO in ages, so let's start there. (By the way I'm going backwards in case there's any confusion. It's the new cool thing to do)
-Her posts today seem pretty natural. They could be faked, but it would be pretty well done by scum and that and other things involve more effort than I'd expect from Tammy-scum at this stage. (and this probably applies previously too when she was part of TET).
1849 is an example.
[aside]Regarding Shadoweh, I think that if she is scum, she needs to do
something
here to avoid losing. Continuing to attack Benmage probably wouldn't have helped her I don't think? Going for defending Benmage is risky, but is the kind of thing I'd expect from scum in a desperate situation (and the kind of thing I would like to try and do as scum too).[/aside]
Ok, I know this is from earlier in the game, but I think mentioning the possibility of CES selective scumhunting by not attacking Nacho
before
either of them flip scum is a really bold move for scum because obviously she'd see it as something that actually incriminates her partners (so she probably wouldn't say it) and also if I considered it as scum I'd think it was something I only thought of because I knew the two of them were scum.
1607 is pretty excessive for scum (similar to something I said about Tierce I think) and the key thing with Tammy is that in her position (especially back then) she didn't need to make the extra effort to look town.
The thing with Empire is another thing that is really really probably from town (why risk adding drama to the relationship with Empire as scum unless she's desperate to look town which she isn't?).
I'll probably do the rest if Benmage and Shadoweh are suddenly super super town or something (oh I really really hope not!), but I'm having a lot of trouble seeing Tammy-scum here.
To be continued! (tomorrow)
(which I really should have done before now)