A few things.
-I don’t like Buldermar’s RVS play. “Stupid shit” doesn’t cut it for me if you don’t transition it into something pro-town, and goading fery seems deliberately anti-town from my POV.
-I don’t like how Buldermar subtly sells fery to me. He says that scum-fery would quickread me as town, but I’ve also seen town-fery quickread me as town. Twice, in fact. He says that it looks “somewhat scummy” in 262 without elaborating, and when pressed, his argument is:
In post 270, buldermar wrote:It looks scummy because I've seen her do it as town and because she knows that I've seen her do it as town.
This doesn’t actually make sense. So playing to one’s town meta is “somewhat scummy” all of a sudden?
-He fabricates a reason to dodge answering me in 267.
-I do not believe anyone could legitimately read DCL’s majiffy vote as serious.
-I
still
think the DCL case is shit.
-His reaction to me does not come from a town perspective. Consistently he tries to get me to stop talking to him because I’m too biased. Which is pretty shitty, considering he and many other people know that my reads early-game aren’t consolidated at all, so bias is a terrible reason for tossing my opinions aside and not answering them.
-Ad populum twice in 299 and 262, which is scummy because you’re basically saying “So-and-so agrees with me, thus I am absolved of the responsibility of defending my beliefs”.
We are lazy people on an adventure, flirting with life but too shy to go all the way.
