Open 488: Pick Your Poison [GAME OVER]

[theslimer3]

Why with the face hammers? They never work e.e

[xtopherusD]

Vote Count 2-2

Scott Brosius

- 5
(mastin2, Siveure DtTrikyp, uctriton00, fuzzybutternut, theslimer3)

---

Psyche

- 2
(Keybladewielder, PimHel)

fuzzybutternut

- 1
(Psyche)

Not Voting

- 2
(Guy_Named_Riggs, Scott Brosius)

10 alive, 6 to lynch

Deadline in (expired on 2013-05-05 21:28:49)

Note:

Prodding Guy_Named_Riggs for the second time.

[fuzzybutternut]

Why with the face hammers? They never work e.e

not when you point them out.

Can we lynch scott already?

[theslimer3]

Autocorrect mang.

And nah. I've yet to see that trick work.
It's a waste of 16 posts talking about it >.>

[PimHel]

Well, I object. Time for me to post about your ISO against Scott.

-Scott did not coach Shisou. Shisou asked a question about RVS and Scott answered as it was about his attack.
-Fuzzy was not in banter with AP at that time. Fuzzy only asked why AP said that Penguin was mafia and wonders afterwards if it was serious.
-Your argument about Scott attacking Penguin can be as you say. However, Penguin wasn't going for AP much, so why would he do that?
-Agreeing with somebody about a post doesn't mean that you find that player the scummiest. Heck, FuDuzn could coast for some time of the day with barely being questioned.
-Bad interaction says nothing about allignment.
-And Keyblade was scummy at that point.

This is why I asked players to look, because most points aren't valid. And Scott's last post screams town.

Furthermore, if we're going to talk about cop direction, the cop should look at you. So that we know if you're being guinine, because I'm starting to doubt it.

[mastin2]

PimHel, you're town, but you're an idiot.

That's not the entirety of the Scott case. There's more to it than what you're replying to, among them being quite valid POE. Scott's last post is entirely null with regards to alignment, especially given that two scum are already dead and that he's a veteran player. He's DEFINITELY experienced enough to fake the towntell you're seeing, and yes I know what towntell you seem to think is there.

Spoiler: As for this?

Furthermore, if we're going to talk about cop direction, the cop should look at you. So that we know if you're being guinine, because I'm starting to doubt it.

As I said, I'm town. There's multiple pieces of evidence which prove it. First and foremost? I don't bus. This is a well-documented fact, consistent across all my games. If you don't think that my past games hold truth, then you can go to MD. Literally everything I've posted since my last bus backfired big-time has had "don't bus" in it. EVERYTHING. So to say it doesn't hold true means you have to have called my saying those things in MD to be lies setting me up for some scum game that I hadn't even joined yet.

But for the sake of argument. Let's say I did bus FuDuzn. Let's say that when we easily could have lynched any player, that I chose to be the turning point onto the FuDuzn lynch to milk the towncred. I'm still town, because I know better than to double-bus, and AP was one of my lead suspects. Yes, I never voted him, but I was quite clearly on the verge of voting him. So for me to be scum, I'd have had to have double-bussed, and that never ends well. In all my 40+ scum games, I've only ONCE won as solo-scum, and that was in a scumsided micro setup where I cruised on a doc claim. So I know better than to let my scumbuddies die. I'd have directed attention elsewhere, to ensure that even if one of my scumbuddies died by either lynch or nightkill, that the other survived.


AND ON TOP OF ALL THAT, there's how I acted post-hammer. Scum players milk towncred for being on the lynch. I actively backed off of it. I distanced myself from the lynch of scum after it was done. I made it difficult to claim towncred for being on the lynch, by sabotaging my part in it. By making me not be happy with it, by having that doubt about it, by making it clear I had second-thoughts and believed FuDuzn might be town. All of that combined meant I'd have difficulty using it in the future, meaning once again, I'm not scum.

[uctriton00]

Post. Didn't get around to rereading.

But my read on Scott Brosius is what the other person pointed out, in the "ooo defensive, I'm going to remember that" comment. If there's anything worse than baboon's actions, it's what Scott just wrote right there. baboon was my biggest scum read, but the read on Scott is much better.

[Psyche]

Well I like the Scott case and that's all that matters, huh?

[Psyche]

Actually, I may think that scott is probably just lazy ass town. Should I hammer him anyway?

[PimHel]

@mastin
I'll respond to the spoiler later, I'm posting from my phone.
1. I was willing to give you some love again as a player. Don't screw by calling me an idiot.
2. There is only one scum left. Do you think scott-scum would post that? From what I remember, he wouldn't.
3. If you use thee veteran argument, then you can also say that a veteran player wouldn't have madee those links that you're pointing out.

@Psyche
No. You need to respond to me what you've been ignoring for way too long

[mastin2]

2. There is only one scum left. Do you think scott-scum would post that? From what I remember, he wouldn't.
3. If you use thee veteran argument, then you can also say that a veteran player wouldn't have madee those links that you're pointing out.

Yes and no. Yes, I think scum-Scott would post that. No, I don't think that a veteran player wouldn't make those links. If anything, a veteran player of that day and age is MORE likely to do so.


Oh, and though I expect the game to be over before this, I need to announce it anyway.

Mod: V/LA next Friday through Monday.

Pacific Northwest Square Dance Festival is May 3rd and 4th, plus prep time and recovery time. (Granted, not MUCH of a difference to my normal weekend V/LA, but enough to be important; it cuts time from Friday and Monday posting.)

[Psyche]

@Psyche
No. You need to respond to me what you've been ignoring for way too long

Respond to what?

[xtopherusD]

Guy_Named_Riggs is being replaced, and Keybladewielder gets prodded.

[PimHel]

Then you may tell me how you can see scum-Scott post that last post.
And no, do you know how easy it is not to make links anymore for a veteran? The site meta has changed drastically.
P.S. Hvae you looked at Antagon's post in which he defends AP, votes Baboon for a terrible reason (he defende AP with something Baboon did) and stating that he thinks Penguin is scum? All your quotes against Scott fall into nothingness compared to this post from Antagon.

@Psyche
You mentioned that the attack on Antagon is based on him replacing out ever since you are in the game. Ever since then, I keep pointing out that that's not the case. Now respond to it.

[PimHel]

As for me saying the cop should investigate you, I need to know if we can trust you.
That self meta isn't helping. I already know how you play. And some things that are mentioned in the spoiler are things that I don't even recall (You wanting to vote AP as biggest example)

But this is extra. Just help me lynch Psyche and we don't even need this convo.

[Keybladewielder]

Please put me on V/LA starting tomorrow

The relatives are invading the household.

[Keybladewielder]

Why the prod? Back anyway

[Keybladewielder]

Vote: Scott Brosius

And that's how we hammer.

[Psyche]

@Psyche
You mentioned that the attack on Antagon is based on him replacing out ever since you are in the game. Ever since then, I keep pointing out that that's not the case. Now respond to it.

But it is. You If Antagon had stayed and accounted for himself, there would be no problem.

[xtopherusD]

Vote Count 2-3

Scott Brosius

- 6
(mastin2, Siveure DtTrikyp, uctriton00, fuzzybutternut, theslimer3, Keybladewielder)

---

Psyche

- 1
(PimHel)

fuzzybutternut

- 1
(Psyche)

Not Voting

- 2
(Guy_Named_Riggs, Scott Brosius)

10 alive, 6 to lynch

Scott Brosius has been lynched!

Note:

To avoid future confusion in this area, I strongly recommend using the site's inbuilt "Vacation/Limited Access" function. It'll show any mod or players that you're

definitely

not available.

[xtopherusD]

The town decided that Scott Brosius was to blame - some even going so far as twice voting for him! In the end, he was strung up and killed.

A quick rummaging through his earthly possessions showed nothing of interest. The real killer was still hiding among them.

Scott Brosius was lynched Day 2. He was

Vanilla Town

.

Night Two begins now! Night Actions must be sent within 72 hours of this post - currently (expired on 2013-04-30 18:16:24).

[xtopherusD]

An addendum: Day will not start before Guy_Named_Riggs is replaced. If a replacement is found before 72 hours, the normal deadline applies.

[xtopherusD]

DeasVail replaces Guy_Named_Riggs, and Night Two will end 24 hours from now (or (expired on 2013-05-01 19:47:01) from when you read this) to allow for reading the thread and, if necessary, an action to be submitted.

[xtopherusD]

After the unfortunate death of Scott Brosius, the night seemed to last longer than usual. How peculiar!

The townsfolk woke to a pair of bodies in the centre of their small village. Both were mutilated beyond recognition, though neither had anything of interest on them. A quick head count revealed that the bodies belonged to possibly two of their most trusted...

theslimer3 was killed Night Two. He was

Vanilla Town

.

mastin2 was killed Night Two. He was

Vanilla Town

.

Day Three begins now! With seven players alive, it takes four to lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2013-05-15 20:00:17).

Note:

Keybladewielder is on V/LA.

[DeasVail]

Hi!

Stuff later.