Newbie 1365 - Vantasmagoria of Flower View (Game Over)

[Tierce]

Votecount 2.2

(2)

TheIrishPope

- Thor665, MontyWhittaker
(1)

MontyWhittaker

- TheIrishPope

(4)

Not voting

- Commandodude, Ms Marangal, Nekoko, sycorax

With 7 alive, it takes 4 votes to lynch.
The deadline is May 13 at 5:55 PM PDT. Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2013-05-13 17:55:00)

[TheIrishPope]

Sorry, my actions. I also forgot to mention you dropped the hammer on Shawn without asking for suspicions and whatnot. Nekoko, what did I just say? Don't mess with someone whose trust you have. You made a good case against Shawn, and he was being pretty silly in his play, being resentful and all. He flipped town, and you are not the most cleared to me right now, but your play can get the real scum out now, I suppose. For now, you can really push and focus on one player, now that we have 7, a fairly small number. Which are your suspicions?

[Thor665]

I'm game to call Nekoko town.
Just saying.

[Ms Marangal]

No, my suspicions have pretty much stayed the same. the only thing that I regret is retracting that town read I had on Shawn.

Nekoko is still probably town, Sycor I don't remember much about her. I would like her to speak up, I can't get a clear read off him though I think TIP is the most suspicious out of everyone. I'm iffy on Monty, though he remains to be null-scummish.

I'll make more content later on, though that's the bulk of my mindset atm

Thor, what happened to your suspicions on me?

[Ms Marangal]

also... I ask alot of question, but contribute little to the game? and how am I known for wagon hopping? I'm curious to see how you came up with that theory, especially since I only voted twice...

[Thor665]

Thor, what happened to your suspicions on me?

I wasn't aware I'd changed my opinion of you.
Crazy, you should tell me when I do that.

[Tierce]

Votecount 2.3

(2)

TheIrishPope

- Thor665, MontyWhittaker
(1)

MontyWhittaker

- TheIrishPope

(4)

Not voting

- Commandodude, Ms Marangal, Nekoko, sycorax


sycorax has been prodded.

With 7 alive, it takes 4 votes to lynch.
The deadline is May 13 at 5:55 PM PDT. Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2013-05-13 17:55:00)

[TheIrishPope]

Putting Shawn at L-1 isn't enough evidence?

[Ms Marangal]

Uhh... no. wagon hopping is hopping from bandwagon to bandwagon. There were other wagon that I could have hopped onto, but I did not. throughout the entirety of yesterday, I only moved my vote once. And what about you? You placed Shawn at L-1 early on in the game and you also used your vote far more frequently than I did, you hopped onto wagons than I did, and so did a couple other people yet you don't call them out on it?

[Tierce]

Commandodude has been prodded.

[Tierce]

Votecount 2.4

(2)

TheIrishPope

- Thor665, MontyWhittaker
(1)

MontyWhittaker

- TheIrishPope

(4)

Not voting

- Commandodude, Ms Marangal, Nekoko, sycorax

With 7 alive, it takes 4 votes to lynch.
The deadline is May 13 at 5:55 PM PDT. Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2013-05-13 17:55:00)

[Nekoko]

Never seen any suspicious post from Thor665. He obviously made a good case against shawn.
His scum hunting looks natural and doesn't look fake so I'm inclined to think he's town.

I actually like her vote on Shawn. It doesn't look suspicious to me. I don't agree with TIP's
claim that MM joined the wagon to blend in or something. Voting for the player she
previously thought was town would actually make her suspicious to other players so she's town.

And commandodude is probably noob town.

So I actually think scum could be here [MontyWhittaker, sycorax, TheIrishPope] by PoE.

TheIrishPope is my top suspect though.

[Commandodude]

Anyone have a read on Sycorax? He's pretty much posted every prod to prevent getting replaced and that's about it.

[Tierce]

Searching for a replacement for sycorax.

[TheIrishPope]

Never seen any suspicious post from Thor665. He obviously made a good case against shawn.
His scum hunting looks natural and doesn't look fake so I'm inclined to think he's town.

I actually like her vote on Shawn. It doesn't look suspicious to me. I don't agree with TIP's
claim that MM joined the wagon to blend in or something. Voting for the player she
previously thought was town would actually make her suspicious to other players so she's town.

And commandodude is probably noob town.

So I actually think scum could be here [MontyWhittaker, sycorax, TheIrishPope] by PoE.

TheIrishPope is my top suspect though.

VOTE: Nekoko

[Ms Marangal]

Dat OMGUS

I see nothing wrong with that post

[TheIrishPope]

Sycorax (or Sycorax's replacement now) is pretty much confirmed town. She has been laying low for a while, but hasn't Commandodude done the same? Using that same logic, sycorax should be noob town as well...
And no, it's not OMGUS. I want reasons. Not just saying "lol i hate TIP but i have no reasons and i won't vote him lol"

[Ms Marangal]

Laying low is not what made Commando town, that on it's own is a null-tell though Commando has done many other things that stated to me that he was town

[TheIrishPope]

Such as...
You scum have a really horrible tendency of not giving reasons.

[Ms Marangal]

Commando is pretty open with his thoughts, when he posts it's short but you know what he's thinking. That's something I find to be a town-tell of sorts. He also dared to go for a no lynch (which is always a bad idea) regardless of the kinds of criticism he would have gotten

[Tierce]

MontyWhittaker has been prodded.

[Thor665]

Uhh... no. wagon hopping is hopping from bandwagon to bandwagon. There were other wagon that I could have hopped onto, but I did not. throughout the entirety of yesterday, I only moved my vote once. And what about you? You placed Shawn at L-1 early on in the game and you also used your vote far more frequently than I did, you hopped onto wagons than I did, and so did a couple other people yet you don't call them out on it?

Are you claiming that bandwagon hopping is scummy here?

Anyone have a read on Sycorax? He's pretty much posted every prod to prevent getting replaced and that's about it.

I have a better read on her than you...who has done the same, but with less input.
Are you seriously dinging someone for lurking?

Commando is pretty open with his thoughts, when he posts it's short but you know what he's thinking. That's something I find to be a town-tell of sorts. He also dared to go for a no lynch (which is always a bad idea) regardless of the kinds of criticism he would have gotten

Is your argument that players who make daft choices are more likely to be town?
Because I thought the case on Irish was that he was daft.
That's why I'm voting him, to be sure.

@Neko - vote Irish?

[Ms Marangal]

No, I'm not saying that making stupid choices makes a player likely town, nor does it make a player likely scum. I'm saying that Commando believes in what he's doing which is what I think is a town-tell

I am also not claiming that wagon-hopping is a scum-tell, I was countering someone who accused me of wagon-hopping. I want to know why he called me out on wagon hopping, while he didn't call others out on the same thing. TIP obviously believed that my wagon hopping was scum motivated though he doesn't extend that same belief on other people

[Thor665]

Why are you voting Irish with me?

[Ms Marangal]

He's at L-2 right now, I want to dance with him a little before I decide if I should vote him