In post 224, BeautyAndTheBeast wrote:around p5. "how", it was the way that rofl reacted to majiffy (didn't I already explain this?). the replace out is null, I don't think it is alignment indicative. rofl looked town to me cos of how he reacted not because he got all dramatic and went ahead and replaced out.
Alright, that makes sense. In particular, I was curious about your
post 114. I was trying to figure out why you were extending the olive branch to roflcopter. It makes sense if you were already leaning Town on him.
In post 299, BeautyAndTheBeast wrote:Perpetuating?
I didn't see anything scummy, ergo I didn't act. When I did see something scummy, I did act. How is that in any form
perpetuating?
Consider yourself officially on my shitlist.
Yes,
perpetuating
. Your first 11 posts were all bullshit banter. That means you were keeping the pre-game stuff non-game related. Perpetuating it, even. The question was why you shifted gears when someone else changed the tenor of the conversation.
You didn't see anything scummy, fine. But, your posts weren't designed to find anything scummy, either. So, again, I ask, why did you shift your style when someone else changed the game environment?
In post 299, BeautyAndTheBeast wrote:Why are you trying to superimpose scumminess onto my play? You'll note the parenthetical word - presumably - in the quote. From my POV, he was calling me scum for voting Cephrir.
Sure, I noted your use of the word presumably. I wasn't directly involved in the conversation, so it may have been easier for me to see the connections after the fact, but your interpretation struck me because you had the cause and effect reversed. Your later
post 105 makes me believe you really were just confused, not intentionally misconstruing the chain of events.
All things considered, I think you're slot isn't scum. The answers both of your heads gave regarding potential scum motivation in your posts seem consistent with a Town mindset much more than a scum agenda.
Your Cephrir push is weak. His suspicions towards your slot make sense from a Town point-of-view. Couple that with the following:
In post 401, Cephrir wrote:Since not everyone in the game is tunneling me, you're gonna have to actually debunk my arguments rather than laugh at them. Or, just keep standing by yourself in a field yelling about how I'm scum. That's fine too.
This demonstrates a belief in the things he's saying and I can totally see where someone with a Town role PM would react this way to your cutesy derision. And:
In post 408, Cephrir wrote:I'm gonna do my best to ignore you for a few pages, as I think I've made my position clear enough and I'm sick of arguing about exact wording and how arguments argued with arguments on arguments.
On Ryu: My initial reaction was agreement with HD (that Ryu had voted Thor arbitrarily for what he himself claimed was a dumbtell), but then I went back and read it and the posts after that one were better.
This reads significantly more like Town fed up with an argument that had spiralled way out of original context than it does like a scum retreating from a fight they feel they've lost. Plus, the double check on Red Ryu vs Thor665 seems to indicate someone who is interested in finding things out, not just casting aspersions where convenient.
tl;dr
BeautyAndTheBeast is likely town and needs to get over the push on someone else (Cephrir) who is likely Town.
If I agreed with you, we'd both be wrong.
)
