Gears of War Mafia - ( Game Over! )

[Messiah]

I claimed Day 1.

[DrippingGoofball]

@Goat
@Rubicon

Convince me. You've got my attention.

[The Goat]

How am I supposed to tell which of you is telling the truth?

It's obviously rubi

cmon dgb join me

rubi is obviously telling the truth

Is what I said

You silly head

I'm borderline close to being rude to you. Which isn't good, because I picture you as a kitten, lost in a field somewhere.

Reviewing.

[The Goat]

DG: I didn't really crumb, either. Here's my reaction to what I THOUGHT was a complete lack of attempts on Messiah (I was clearly relying to much on writeup flavor). Again, I've protected him every single night:

vote Qwints

On a completely unrelated note...does anyone else find it weird that Messiah is generally unharmed, despite being the only town PR claim for the last three days?

Gonna go back through and look a lil...I can think of a perfectly simple reason why Rubicon didn't die last night.

[The Goat]

Is it reasonable to think that if there is an un-NKillable town PR that there would be an equivalent role for each scum team?

[The Goat]

For what it's worth, if we do NOT lynch Rubicon today, and still hit scum, I am completely okay with being the lynch for tomorrow. If we hit scum today, I don't see how the town can possibly lose, even with me being lynched tomorrow.

This will prove beyond a shadow of a doubt that Rubicon is lying.

[The Goat]

(1) the Goat (who would have been lynched immediately today if I died) used some kind of protection / redirection / etc. to make people wonder about both me (and to some extent you) for why I didn't die.

Rubicon...

...let me ask you something...

...if I "used some sort of protection or redirection on you"...why isn't Messiah dead?

[The Goat]

(I also welcome the masses to try and figure out my previous question.)

[Messiah]

How many votes is Rubicon at?

[Venmar]

Votecount 6.2

[L-4]

Guille2015:

Angelious Nero

[L-5] Messiah:

[L-5] DrippingGoofball:

[L-5] Angelious Nero:

[L-3]

Rubicon:

The Goat, DrippingGoofball

[L-3]

The Goat:

Ms Marangal, Viomi

[L-5] Mac:

[L-5] Viomi:

[L-5] Ms Marangal:

Not Voting

• Guille2015, Messiah, Rubicon, Mac

Deadline

• May 18th, 2013

Mod Notes

• I do not believe anybody is V/LA.. I might be wrong however.
  
• Links and front page should be updated shortly.

[DrippingGoofball]

DG: I didn't really crumb, either. Here's my reaction to what I THOUGHT was a complete lack of attempts on Messiah (I was clearly relying to much on writeup flavor). Again, I've protected him every single night:

vote Qwints

On a completely unrelated note...does anyone else find it weird that Messiah is generally unharmed, despite being the only town PR claim for the last three days?

Gonna go back through and look a lil...I can think of a perfectly simple reason why Rubicon didn't die last night.

How would you have known an attempt on his life? And there was that missing kill Night 2.

[The Goat]

DG: I didn't really crumb, either. Here's my reaction to what I THOUGHT was a complete lack of attempts on Messiah

(I was clearly relying to much on writeup flavor)

. Again, I've protected him every single night:

vote Qwints

On a completely unrelated note...does anyone else find it weird that Messiah is generally unharmed, despite being the only town PR claim for the last three days?

Gonna go back through and look a lil...I can think of a perfectly simple reason why Rubicon didn't die last night.

How would you have known an attempt on his life? And there was that missing kill Night 2.

Please read the bolded.

[DrippingGoofball]

How come you didn't put two and two together with the missing kill?

[Angelious Nero]

Mac, what is your case on us?

I'm not 100% sold on Gulli's claim but meh.

[Angelious Nero]

AN: Where in the writeup do you see a blocked kill?

I haven't read any of the "flavor" yet. TL;DR. We've usally had 2 kills a night, tonight we only had one. Either a kill was stopped some kind of way or the red scum is all dead but metawise I'd think it was a 3v3.

False.

We had 2 kills on Night 1, 1 kill on Night 2, and

4 kills on Night 3

.

Try again.

and yet they are claiming the kills of both Fitz and Bork. Now maybe he was lying to make it look like he didn't have extra information but I don't like liars at all.

[Angelious Nero]

we probs only have one scum left now

no

How likely is there to be a 21p game with 2 rivaling scum as with 3 and 2 members. This type of speculation is quite harmful.

and this is still fucking retarded. It was MS claiming it was 2 and 3 member teams, not me.

[Mac]

I'll get to the case on a minute although I'm starting to doubt myself.

I'm also not sure I buy guile and his bomb claim, seriously it must be some fucking funny coincidence that 3 carmines died in the same night.

one has to wonder why Rubicon is not dead if he was "primed" as guille is suggesting. Add to the fact there were no other kills means we've EITHER taken out one scum team (likely orange? CEO and chairman dead, dont know if that means anything) or something else is going on.

can I suggest massclaim or is that stupid at this point? we need to get information I think.

[DrippingGoofball]

one has to wonder why Rubicon is not dead if he was "primed" as guille is suggesting. Add to the fact there were no other kills means we've EITHER taken out one scum team (likely orange? CEO and chairman dead, dont know if that means anything) or something else is going on.

can I suggest massclaim or is that stupid at this point? we need to get information I think.

I already claimed vanilla.

SPECULATION: With the scum having a Strongman/Godfather combo and a Ninja/Robleblocker combo, I could see the last scum (I assume one from each group) as having some sort of NK protection, like Strongman/Godfather/Doctor and Ninja/Roleblocker/1-shotBP.

I think either Rubicon or The Goat is a

Mafia

Doctor and is of course lying about who they protected.

[Mac]

if we speculate 1shot BP surely that MUST mean Rubi is maf? & assuming guile is town.

I'm also vanilla. claiming flavour too or leaving that?

[DrippingGoofball]

I'm Commander Miran Trescu.

I think 1-shot BP is the most likely scenario explaining Rubicon's survival, I believe Guille's claim.

[Mac]

I'm Private Samantha Byrne.

[The Goat]

Phone posting.

DG, to answer your question, I just never thought about it. I'm conditioned to playing in games where protects are shown in write ups. If you look back, there's an instance when I actually asked someone what made them rhino there was a protect because it WASN'T shown in the writeup.

In short, I'm a dufus.

[The Goat]

Think, not rhino.

[DrippingGoofball]

I'm conditioned to playing in games where protects are shown in write ups.

I've never seen that. Can you point to an example?

[The Goat]

I'm conditioned to playing in games where protects are shown in write ups.

I've never seen that. Can you point to an example?

Current game at :sj:. Read the morning writeup.

http://www.packmentality.net/forum/inde ... 4.msg0#new